Sometimes consensus is correct. Ask Sheep about how town had consensus on the Serial Killers game we just played. We decided everyone who was active was town and the replacements both wound up being scum. Consensus =/= wrong
Also podo was in that game too.
i know, i've played a bunch of games recently where it was just the consensus scumreads
but people settling on you/nsg/mastina (your slot wasn't here; mastina hasn't really been as active) doesn't feel like the *right* consensus for this game
idk how to explain that better; this feels like a game where scum might be in the townbloc
Sheep do you do "clears" and "never lynches" as town? You just pulled that as scum in our game that finished. Anyone else is welcome to respond as well.
Don't like the subtle posturing of #812 "Oh why wasn't the person I replaced voting this scummy person" this slot is laying it on thick about the slot being town
In post 943, mastina wrote:Btw, skitter's 722 is the first post of skitter's which I've had any feeling on at all, pretty much--and it was positive. I liked it; it wasn't something stellar, but it made me feel loosely town there. 724 actually gives me similarly good vibes, too.
Skitter had like at least three AI posts in their ISO and its concerning you are late to the game on that
I know I'm supposed to be sorting but I am really enjoying Podo reacting to Mastina and that's probably not funny to either party but it is hilarious to me
Okay scumreads this game are weak but I'm pretty damn confident in
(Podo, Skitter) town and pretty -no damn- confident in (Sheep, Pink Ball) town.
NSG's contrived reads list and her clunky replace-out, along with Meph's not subtle AND subtle attempts at posturing the slot as town and a mislynch .
Their whole entrance is on the only real counterwagon they have a shot at
#991 is very bad, Meph says the slot is town and then basically threatens it with a scumread for Sheep scumreading her
#994 is also kind of bad, considering their last post is #916 and has Skitter as a town read. Then she throws shade on Skitter for being the third vote.
There's some isolated sorting in there but it all seems contigent on whether the slot is voting Meph or not. I don't like how quickly they abandon townreads who vote them and how they don't even really do it directly, as was the case with Skitter and Sheep.
I think part of what has made this game so grueling is the overuse of meta.
With all the talk y’all have done about it any player could probably earn a townread from half the town just by following the outlines that have been put in place in thread. I try to use meta more retroactively.
Like, the Sheep thing about clears. That’s done. He can’t take that back and it’s not subjective or vague.
In post 1140, Nibbui wrote:Very interesting by the way that you're not town reading me lolwagons
I was the first half of the game, then after the reaction test you shifted to constant pontificating and vote switching and promising reads tomorrow or whatever and it looked way less goal-oriented sorting and way more like trying to stay busy.
Why would I try to make it look like I'm busy reading people games when I can just keep giving comments on posts in-thread and keep the status quo in my town read?
Also I'm not stupid enough to promise something only to not deliver it later
I think part of what has made this game so grueling is the overuse of meta.
With all the talk y’all have done about it any player could probably earn a townread from half the town just by following the outlines that have been put in place in thread. I try to use meta more retroactively.
Like, the Sheep thing about clears. That’s done. He can’t take that back and it’s not subjective or vague.
I'm not putting any outlines here to Nancy to follow
I tried first to get interactions with her only to afterwards explain whatever alignment her posts might indicate that she has
what you are scum reading Nancy for is NAI as a fact even if she is scum, and that's also a fact. I'm just pointing it out.
I think part of what has made this game so grueling is the overuse of meta.
With all the talk y’all have done about it any player could probably earn a townread from half the town just by following the outlines that have been put in place in thread. I try to use meta more retroactively.
Like, the Sheep thing about clears. That’s done. He can’t take that back and it’s not subjective or vague.
I'm not putting any outlines here to Nancy to follow
I tried first to get interactions with her only to afterwards explain whatever alignment her posts might indicate that she has
what you are scum reading Nancy for is NAI as a fact even if she is scum, and that's also a fact. I'm just pointing it out.
She can still be scum but not for those reasons.
Yeah I’m not really going to let you draw the lines on what should and shouldn’t be a scumtell for each player. Quite frankly I’m not particularly interested in your opinion when you try to frame it as a fact.
My first game back I drove a lynch on BrightEyedFish and everyone told me everything he did was NAI and he was lynchbait but what do ya know he flipped scum. I don’t typically get talked out of scum reads by meta talk.
