Now that the game is over and I can mention it:
The reason I town read pvturist here is because I had just seen scum!Pvt get flipped here after replacing into both of these games around the same time:
viewtopic.php?f=11&t=78126&start=500
If you ISO PvtUrist there, his scum game was highly obvious fence sitting/hand-wringing/worrying about what people thought and therefore trying to justify his play.
While I obviously disagree with him here, his play is like the opposite of those things. But I had doubts about whether it meant he's town here, or that, since he replaced in here just after he was lynched in that game, he learned to never look like he's fence sitting and change his play entirely. Regardless of play style, it didn't seem that he held up under scrutiny there versus here, which is why I had changed my read after the 1v1.