Mini 2049: The Townsquare Game Over

[themilkcartonkid]

No, I just realized nothing that they said would change my mind that this was a good thing to do

[DuckDuckJab]

FFS, I AM THE BLOODY VIG AND I HAVE THE BLOODY INFO I NEED!

First off, let me come clean: I lied about being a Commuter. I didn't know how to handle my "slip" otherwise. And yes, it was a slip indeed, just not a "scum slip".

My role is bizarre. I simply submit a list of 3 living players each night. If one (and exactly one) of them is Scum, they die and the scum kill is blocked. If none, 2 or all 3 are scum my action fails and the scum NK goes through.

On N1 I picked DDJ as a slot I hard TR'd. My 2nd choice would have been in Cheeky/Flubber/LA (as TRs), and Robert as the 3rd (the counterwagon to a flipped townie), and I decided to go for a Cheeky. If it ended up with someone else dying I would have assumed Robert was Town because DDJ was already all but confirmed in my eyes and Cheeky was close enough and was not on the lynch wagon on D1. I guess I was a bit lucky with Robert, thus confirming the other 2 as Town and from then on it was an easy job.

On N2 I was torn between 2 thoughts: Pick 3 others and see what happens (at best it could have confirmed 2 more townies, but at worst it could have resulted in mine or DDJ/Cheeky's death at the hands of the Mafia and I would have taken a step back rather than forward, so to speak). I picked the alternative of using my 2 confirmed townies with someone I suspected, so as to either kill scum or confirm a third townie 100%. I picked joges over milk.

N3 is going to be even easier. I am using DDJ+Cheeky+milk. Either milk dies or he is confirmed a townie.

The thing is if we hypothetically assume milk to be Town then we most probably lose a Townie tonight due to the Mafia kill. And now that I fully claimed I suspect that Townie would be me. This is partially why I didn't want to out, because as long as they thought I was a Commuter they would not have risked shooting me anyway, and especially so with the situation they're in. They simply cannot afford a failed NK.

The other reason was for fear they may have a Doctor or a roleblocker. *Sigh*

At first I thought NO WAY we have a JK with my role. Then it hit me: WHAT IF the game had went another route on D1 and I wasn't as lucky on N1? There would have been every chance that >I< would be the NK (the designer certainly didn't account for my "slip" resulting in me faking Commuter, did they?). If that was the case then would the Town be without an investigative/protective for the rest of the game? Because my role IS THE BLOODY INVESTIGATIVE, PROTECTIVE AND KILLING ROLE ALL IN ONE. That's why I didn't go for a milky lynch and decided it's better to verify him via my night action. It makes sense that a JK may exist as a backup for my role minus the killing part. Also the investigative part of his in nerfed compared to mine under the current situation.

Now how bloody hard would it have been for you to just trust me on a MECHANICAL DECISION? It has nothing to do with "gut" or "associative tells" or anything like that. A purely mechanical play by someone in the know.

Any chance of making this skitter + milk + us?
11/10 would help my paranoia

[DuckDuckJab]

~ the head that is bad at signing and also this game

[DuckDuckJab]

Keen to end this before LadyAngel is replaced.
A50 if you can't signal one way or the other before deadline please proceed with YOUR PLAN not mine

[DuckDuckJab]

Oh my mission failed.
some replacement queue pilot I am.

[DuckDuckJab]

Anyway Trivium was lolwolfy, Omo was towny at the start but heavily inconsistent so idrk or mind how this flips

I'll jam with Buj over night if this game continues because I have been an AWFUL hydra partner and I think we can nail this

[themilkcartonkid]

Ducky! Glad to see you back

[DuckDuckJab]

Happy to be here fam

How do you feel about my suggestion for A50?

[themilkcartonkid]

I think it gives him a chance of surviving. Which I'm for, but if he survives that doesn't really tell us anything until one of us flips. Actually I've changed my mind, it's a good idea.

[DuckDuckJab]

Who should #3 be? (obviously having us in there is brilliant because I believe were softconftown from his previous night actions)

Actually if there's only one scum left he should pick 3 scumspects but I can't recall if this is confirmed 3v10 or not

[Jingle]

Vote Count 3.Final

Flavor to be added.

With 9 Alive, it's 5 to lynch!

Omochao: (5) skitter30 (1109), DuckDuckJab (1115), Almost50 (1169), CheekyTeeky (1170), themilkcartonkid (1172)
CheekyTeeky: (0)
themilkcartonkid: (0)
DoubtingThomas: (0)
Flubbernugget: (0)
skitter30: (0)
Gamma Emerald: (0)
DuckDuckJab: (0)
Almost50: (0)

No Lynch: (2)

Not Voting (5): Gamma Emerald, DoubtingThomas, Omochao, Flubbernugget (1139),

A Lynch has been achieved!

Important Notes:
-

The Game is currently in Day 3.

-

skitter30 is permanently V/LA on Fridays and Saturdays.

[Jingle]

Omochao

, a

Townsperson

, has been lynched Day 3!

[Jingle]

Deadline for Night 3 is in (expired on 2019-01-22 18:00:00).

[Jingle]

themilkcartonkid, an

Innocent Evil Person

, (Mafia Goon), has left the town Night 3.

[Jingle]

Vote Count 4.0

Flavor to be added.

With 7 Alive, it's 4 to lynch!

CheekyTeeky: (0)
DoubtingThomas: (0)
Flubbernugget: (0)
skitter30: (0)
Gamma Emerald: (0)
DuckDuckJab: (0)
Almost50: (0)

No Lynch: (0)

Not Voting (7): Gamma Emerald, DoubtingThomas, Omochao, Flubbernugget, skitter30, DuckDuckJab, Almost50, CheekyTeeky,

Deadline is in (expired on 2019-02-06 12:00:00).

Important Notes:
-

The Game is currently in Day 4.

-

skitter30 is permanently V/LA on Fridays and Saturdays.

-

As I'm unavoidably busy tonight, expect OP and formatting work to be done tomorrow afternoon. If I don't manage that, I give explicit permission to insult me.

[Gamma Emerald]

;Thonk:

[DuckDuckJab]

MY DAY OF REDEMPTION
IS UPON US

though like I was thinking 3:10

and kinda townread tmck

my bad

[CheekyTeeky]

So like, can we lynch flubber now?

[DuckDuckJab]

MY DAY OF ATTEMPTIHG REDEMPTION
IS UPON US

Fixed

Buj is gonna laugh at me for that flip

[DuckDuckJab]

So like, can we lynch flubber now?

Yes, Flubber greens

Tonight A50 targets {us, Lady, skitter} in case there's another red flip

[DuckDuckJab]

@Mr. Jingle sir

any chance of an update to post#0?

[Jingle]

I was supposed to stop mafia-ing 2 hours ago, but I have free time most of tomorrow afternoon. I'll do it then.

[skitter30]

ngl i think a50's claim kinda strains credulity. it's kinda op and incredibly swingy, especially since the jk did not, in fact, exist and there does not seem to be much power otherwise. like we seem to be in 9:4 and if a50 had died early game, like day1 or n1, then what?

like while he's alive, the role is op in that effectively combines a vig/cop/doc, and it has the capacity to generate an absurd amount of investigative results; all the flipped scum thus far are goons so, like, what did they have to countermand this? and once he's dead, the game becomes scumsided by scum's sheer numbers.

the role as described basically means the game's swing and balance depends on how well one player plays and if they manage to live long enough to utilize their role. if he does, it's townsided, and if he doesn't, it's scumsided.

like from what i see in this setup rn, it's incredibly hard for me to see how a role like this, like, makes sense from like a balance/swing pov. it just doesn't really makes sense as like a real role tbh

==

also i think today should be mass-claim day

==

MY DAY OF REDEMPTION
IS UPON US

though like I was thinking 3:10

and kinda townread tmck

my bad

not entirely certain where the milk townreads stemmed from; i thought his voteparking on the day1 and day2 wagons was quite awful, especially coupled with his, like, lack of any sort of discernible sorting. i kinda said this yesterday, but i thought there was a fairly decent chance that he claimed to fend off the pushes he probably would have gotten yesterday otherwise, especially since his claimed night actions didn't make that much sense.

==

So like, can we lynch flubber now?

Yes, Flubber greens

Tonight A50 targets {us, Lady, skitter} in case there's another red flip

sorry, maybe i'm not reading this right? you want to lynch flubber today even though you think he greens?

[Flubbernugget]

Uh if there's no jk a50 shouldn't be alive

Maybe there's just no nk for scum and there's like 5 of them?

[Jingle]

OP mostly up to date. I'll finish adding links and put in the pagetop links later.