Prey Mafia - Game Over

[Persivul]

Big swinging dick - someone very (perhaps overly) confident in their abilities and not shy about it.

If you watched Breaking Bad, the guy whose car Walt set on fire at the gas station was a bsd.

[Almost50]

i'm putting some weight into skitter's Almost read, so we'll see where that goes.

So let me get this straight: You are sheeping skitter on me, and she is sheeping you on me?? Am I such a pain in the neck to read that everyone seems to be denying responsibility for a mere preliminary read based on tone/gut?

~A50

[Almost50]

Hmmm.. say, why the freak am I signing my posts??

[Enter]

Persivul (in hood and out here): I'm big and important I wanted to vote enter cuz he seemed like he was trying too hard (lul)


Also why is A50 putting his signature on his posts... the site already does that for him

PEdit: Ninja'd

[Enter]

Sorry I got a little excited haven't played mafia from the start in a while.

If I could lynch three people right now it would be BEF, Robert2424, Pers

In that order.

[Enter]

I take that back, if BEF flipped town, I'd prolly flip Minyu over persi.

Persi doesn't seem all too scummy, just feels fake and has a larger than necessary sense of self-importance that also feels fake. Zito's feels real, tho, which is why he's (maybe) town (zito's been kinda raining on my parade in the hood, too, but his feels like he didn't conjur it up for the sake of squashing the hopes of dreams of the people who play with him, seems like just him)

[redtea]

Considering BEF is in the neighborhood, I had assumed Enter wasn't looking out for his reaction, but those of other people's.
Seeing his recent posts, I don't know if this is just more of his games or he really picked up something on BEF.

Sorry to bring up the hood again, but, if I were to take a guess on this:
Personally, if I were in BEF's position, I would play along to see what reads could be accrued. There is a PT after all, it could be a good use for it. This is the kind of attitude Enter might have been looking for.
Now the first responses in the main thread could be seen as playing along, but long past that, up to now, BEF takes issue with it (worried or not). Which may be why Enter seems to be legitimately pushing him now?
I don't think it's working though.

As an aside, keep in mind it is highly likely one of the neighbors is scum.

[Papa Zito]

Yeah I'm just kindof an ass, call it becoming jaded watching people do things over 10 years, apologies in advance.

From what I can tell I'm on the same wavelength with His Majesty the King on most everything, which scares me a little bit.

I also don't wanna kill Chara yet which is a new an exciting experience.

[Enter]

@BEF

I want to know if you feel comfortable playing scum. I'm not going to meta you, I don't read games I'm not in (most of the time). If you don't answer me, that's your perogative. You have the right to remain silent. Anything you say can and will be held against you in a mafia game (unless no one notices).

Considering BEF is in the neighborhood, I had assumed Enter wasn't looking out for his reaction, but those of other people's.
Seeing his recent posts, I don't know if this is just more of his games or he really picked up something on BEF.

Sorry to bring up the hood again, but, if I were to take a guess on this:
Personally, if I were in BEF's position, I would play along to see what reads could be accrued. There is a PT after all, it could be a good use for it. This is the kind of attitude Enter might have been looking for.
Now the first responses in the main thread could be seen as playing along, but long past that, up to now, BEF takes issue with it (worried or not). Which may be why Enter seems to be legitimately pushing him now?
I don't think it's working though.

As an aside, keep in mind it is highly likely one of the neighbors is scum.

Like I said in hood, you have a way with words that is exceptional. Someday I'll just stop talking.

No games right now, though, just lynching. Personally, I would have liked it if people played along, but noooo, people just kinda sat and watched. Guess I shouldn't have said anything in the hood, people would have actually tried to lynch me and things might have gone much smoother. This is what I get for spilling the beans. Me and my big mouth.

Yeah I'm just kindof an ass, call it becoming jaded watching people do things over 10 years, apologies in advance.

From what I can tell I'm on the same wavelength with His Majesty the King on most everything, which scares me a little bit.

I also don't wanna kill Chara yet which is a new an exciting experience.

Ha, it's fine? I think.

Have you played w/ Chara before?


======

In other news this seems like the sort of game where the mod would give us an all - town hood (but wouldn't tell us for the purpose of balance), so once we get a little more concrete in our reads, I'm ok w/ using hood chat again.

[Chara]

Have you played w/ Chara before?

i can only remember the one time, because Zito's frustration made it into my signature. (of Not Chara)
i for one am excited to have a more positive experience with poor Zito.

[Chara]

So let me get this straight: You are sheeping skitter on me, and she is sheeping you on me?? Am I such a pain in the neck to read that everyone seems to be denying responsibility for a mere preliminary read based on tone/gut?

i told skitter to avoid sheeping me on you, actually.
let's just say coalition taught me a lesson.

townleaning pinyu. i have a sense he would have at least tried to fake a read or two. not that strong because he could be 100% NAI lost.

[redtea]

Persivul has a decent amount of content in his isos, if a little directionless, so maybe "active" scum.
Zito is like wise man of few words.
That's if you were to compare them directly. Perisvul would be nowhere near close to the first person I'd lynch.

@Enter
That's a rather brave assumption about the hood.

[skitter30]

i'm putting some weight into skitter's Almost read, so we'll see where that goes.

So let me get this straight: You are sheeping skitter on me, and she is sheeping you on me?? Am I such a pain in the neck to read that everyone seems to be denying responsibility for a mere preliminary read based on tone/gut?

~A50

i've never said or implied that i was sheeping chara on you; i said i wanted to know if they had an opinion so that i could bounce my read off of someone
nor do i think i'm denying responsibility for the read

==

i'm not entirely following the resurgence of the bef push tbh
it was bad the first time around and i don't get why it came back

i also don't think the composition of the neighborhood is really that interesting. there might be scum in there, there might not be; it's an inherently wifom-y discussion and there's really no way for me, from here, to tell at this stage so i'm not going to wonder about it too much rn

i think bef's paraphrase of the neighborhood was kinda townie tho

==

redtea what's your mafia experience

==

From what I can tell I'm on the same wavelength with

His Majesty the King

on most everything, which scares me a little bit.

sorry, who is this?

[Papa Zito]

Have you played w/ Chara before?


======

In other news this seems like the sort of game where the mod would give us an all - town hood (but wouldn't tell us for the purpose of balance), so once we get a little more concrete in our reads, I'm ok w/ using hood chat again.

We played together in this game which was a lot longer ago than I thought hmm.

If we get a red flip from the hood crew I'm fine going back there but until then it may as well be Chernobyl.


In other news Robert2424 continues to be inscrutable, I'd appreciate some help increasing his scrutableness.

[Papa Zito]

From what I can tell I'm on the same wavelength with

His Majesty the King

on most everything, which scares me a little bit.

sorry, who is this?

That's Persivul's title.

[Persivul]

sorry, who is this?

That's my title. I earned it in a kingmaker game.

[skitter30]

whoops, i missed that

[Enter]

Have you played w/ Chara before?


======

In other news this seems like the sort of game where the mod would give us an all - town hood (but wouldn't tell us for the purpose of balance), so once we get a little more concrete in our reads, I'm ok w/ using hood chat again.

We played together in this game which was a lot longer ago than I thought hmm.

If we get a red flip from the hood crew I'm fine going back there but until then it may as well be Chernobyl.


In other news Robert2424 continues to be inscrutable, I'd appreciate some help increasing his scrutableness.

Agreed, which is why two of my lynch propositions are from the hood.

[Chara]

didn't you just say you were thinking there's a good chance the hood is all town? i know that's an obvious question, but.

[implosion]

alright skitter is town probably. I agree with like all of the sentiment in her posts in the past couple pages. I am curious what she sees in redtea.

I could go for a flashwagon on a50. None of his posts yet have really made me feel anything at all.

All of the speculation about how many scum are in the neighborhood is dumb.

[Enter]

didn't you just say you were thinking there's a good chance the hood is all town? i know that's an obvious question, but.

Yes, but

there are two ways to approach this:
1. Lynch outside hood to see if it comes up red (if so, and we can draw conclusions that the other is red, then inside is green)
2. Lynch scummiest inside hood to see if it comes up green (if two people come up green in hood, it's p safe to say the rest are green, IMO)

Sure this is a brave stance to take, but hey, I like to take chances.

[implosion]

didn't you just say you were thinking there's a good chance the hood is all town? i know that's an obvious question, but.

Yes, but

there are two ways to approach this:
1. Lynch outside hood to see if it comes up red (if so, and we can draw conclusions that the other is red, then inside is green)
2. Lynch scummiest inside hood to see if it comes up green (if two people come up green in hood, it's p safe to say the rest are green, IMO)

Sure this is a brave stance to take, but hey, I like to take chances.

3. don't make assumptions for no reason?

[implosion]

like chances, sure. But like, here.

Here are some people in this game: almost50, robert2424, skitter30.

This is all of the people in this game that have numbers in their names.

I'm willing to bet that there's one scum and exactly one scum in that group but there might be zero.

Therefore, I propose we lynch robert2424. If he flips green, it basically clears the other two.

This is literally exactly the same as your argument, modulo trying to outguess the mod.

[Papa Zito]

1. Lynch outside hood to see if it comes up red (if so, and we can draw conclusions that the other is red, then inside is green)

What does this mean exactly?

I'm dumb, use small words.

[skitter30]

alright skitter is town probably. I agree with like all of the sentiment in her posts in the past couple pages. I am curious what she sees in redtea.

I could go for a flashwagon on a50. None of his posts yet have really made me feel anything at all.

All of the speculation about how many scum are in the neighborhood is dumb.

redtea's posts kinda feel like they're equivocating without actually saying much. or kinda like they're talking to talk? idk might be a playstle thing but like look at the number of words they're using to say ... not much at all really, or to cite someone else's opinion as a reason to think something

or like they'll ask questions and then do nothing with the answer

What are Almost50 and Robert's thoughts so far? Other than passive commentary and band talk.

and i'm pushing a50 and papa zito is trying to wagon robert but there's like no interaction with these pushes really; makes me feel like the questions are there to look busy

i could flashwagon a50, sure

VOTE: a50

==

lynching someone based on whether or not they're in a hood is dumb, no offense