Greatest Idea Mafia - Game Over

[TheGoldenParadox]

so i'd slight leantown there.

Useful comment.

Cherrypicking part of my post to sarcastically say that's useful without doing anything of your own? Color me amazed at your play.

[Vedith]

Discards mean a lot in this game type, and the whole purpose Greatest was created was to increase WIFOM but also eliminate RVS. What you discard shows what you didn't discard, and anyone who says otherwise is misinformed or scum.

No it's for people with over sized egos to think that they can solve a game from discards.
I see it tried every time, I see it failed every time.

Of course I discarded, i am saying otherwise right now. So I guess I'm mis informed of what I said and did or Im Scum.

[Vedith]

Cherrypicking part of my post

Get used to it, I will do that a lot.

[Alchemist21]

wtf was ur third card if u picked miller

I had mafia Godfather, town Godfather and Miller. I looked for town Godfather on the wiki and it redirected to Vig so I wanted to pick that, but in here it was just a VT, so I picked the Miller to claim in my first post and be townread for it

Are you kidding me?
Does anyone else realize the irony of someone CHOOSING to have miller (negative utility, doesn't confirm whatsoever) over Named Townie?
I can't decide if this is scummy or just very poor town play.
I'm also of two minds when trying to figure out notmyspam. On one hand, it's likely that he discarded IC so that he could be scum. On the other, he could have had a more powerful town role. But IC is pretty powerful, and I don't see many that are more powerful, so I'm going to keep my vote on notmyspam.
Gamma reads town to me. I'm not sure what to make of the wait until day 3 to lynch me comment, but it comes across as scummy, so i'd slight leantown there.

What makes Godfather more confirmable than a Miller? It would look a lot more suspicious if he had said “yeah I threw out a Godfather card but I had another one so I’m still a Godfather. Miller is negative utility but Godfather has no Town utility here.

[TTTT]

I think it's very likely
that NotMy would choose a town role over a scum role
just thought that should be put out here

[pinturicchio]

wtf was ur third card if u picked miller

I had mafia Godfather, town Godfather and Miller. I looked for town Godfather on the wiki and it redirected to Vig so I wanted to pick that, but in here it was just a VT, so I picked the Miller to claim in my first post and be townread for it

Are you kidding me?
Does anyone else realize the irony of someone CHOOSING to have miller (negative utility, doesn't confirm whatsoever) over Named Townie?
I can't decide if this is scummy or just very poor town play.
I'm also of two minds when trying to figure out notmyspam. On one hand, it's likely that he discarded IC so that he could be scum. On the other, he could have had a more powerful town role. But IC is pretty powerful, and I don't see many that are more powerful, so I'm going to keep my vote on notmyspam.
Gamma reads town to me. I'm not sure what to make of the wait until day 3 to lynch me comment, but it comes across as scummy, so i'd slight leantown there.

Named townie is a VT? I already said that I chose Miller to get to claim it in my first post to be townread along with discarding the Godfather role. It's closer to an IC claim that saying "I chose VT".

If by Names Townie you ment something else, then you misunderstood something.

[pinturicchio]

I think it's very likely
that NotMy would choose a town role over a scum role
just thought that should be put out here

Lol I thought exactly the same when he popped up

[TTTT]

everyone should claim the alignments of their two accepted cards
not the ability
just the alignments

I don't see how this hurts and it may help later by restricting fake-claims
if this is a dumb idea say so

[TTTT]

actually this might be a bad idea...

[Vedith]

TTTT might be scum.

[TTTT]

I'm trying to think through if it gives scum an advantage in multi-ball

[Alchemist21]

I'm trying to think through if it gives scum an advantage in multi-ball

I think it could help them ID who’s on the other team(s).

I don’t see much use in claiming the alignments alone. Doesn’t really narrow anything down.

[davesaz]

I think it's much too early to consider card claiming.

[Elsa Jay]

I frankly have to agree with not putting my 2 cards yet. But trust me when I say I know too CC a particular clsim because of my card.

[davesaz]

There are many singleton cards, so that wouldn't be a huge surprise if true.

[Vedith]

It's also an easy comment for scum to make

[NotMySpamAccount]

I see people wanting a claim, so here it is. I am a

1-Shot Unlynchable Townie

.

[Vedith]

I believe it

[Elsa Jay]

What card number on the wiki is the Unlynchable part?

[mcqueen]

Does 1-shot unlynchable means we have to “lynch” him twice? Like if we vote him to majority the Unlynchable goes away and then he can be lynched?

[Vedith]

Does 1-shot unlynchable means we have to “lynch” him twice? Like if we vote him to majority the Unlynchable goes away and then he can be lynched?

Yes

[mcqueen]

well look here i think i finally found a role i don’t like

[mcqueen]

well look here i think i finally found a role i don’t like

and this is because if he hadn’t claimed, it punishes us too much for trying to lynch a scumread...

... or not because it saves us a mislynch

idk man

[Alchemist21]

I see people wanting a claim, so here it is. I am a

1-Shot Unlynchable Townie

.

What was the card you used for your alignment?

[DoubtingThomas]

only thing to note is maybe throwing away mafia godfather because that role is pretty bastard

Non-normal yes, bastard hell no. You are a weak-spirited mafia player if you consider Godfather bastard.

all the other sites I play on consider godfather pretty much bastard so don't shove your futile opinion down my throat