Greatest Idea Mafia - Game Over

[Alchemist21]

I see people wanting a claim, so here it is. I am a

1-Shot Unlynchable Townie

.

What was the card you used for your alignment?

And also why take unlynchable over Innocent Child?

[DoubtingThomas]

thinking vedith and gamma are town

[DoubtingThomas]

I see people wanting a claim, so here it is. I am a

1-Shot Unlynchable Townie

.

What was the card you used for your alignment?

And also why take unlynchable over Innocent Child?

good point

[Elsa Jay]

Unlynchable is legit the perfect card as a scum though, not gonna lie. What are the chances of a vigilante in this setup?

[DoubtingThomas]

Unlynchable is legit the perfect card as a scum though, not gonna lie. What are the chances of a vigilante in this setup?

if someone had a vigi card, 100% of the time

[Alchemist21]

Unlynchable is legit the perfect card as a scum though, not gonna lie. What are the chances of a vigilante in this setup?

There are 4 different vig roles in the list:

Town vig
Town 1-shot vig
Town 1-shot Day vig
Mafia 1-shot Day vig

[Alchemist21]

Unlynchable is legit the perfect card as a scum though, not gonna lie. What are the chances of a vigilante in this setup?

There are 4 different vig roles in the list:

Town vig
Town 1-shot vig
Town 1-shot Day vig
Mafia 1-shot Day vig

And the Town 1-shot Dayvig has 2 numbers that could roll it.

[DoubtingThomas]

right spam claiming unlynchable is nagl, but the claiming itself can be >rand town very very slightly because as wolf he didnt have to necessarily claim yet

but unlynchable IS a good scum card so theres a change spam claimed 50% of the truth with unlynchable and the other 50% is a lie wrt his alignment

[Elsa Jay]

Yeah, since he threw away innocent townie, that means in order for him to be town, he had to draw all 3 cards as town.

[DoubtingThomas]

Yeah, since he threw away innocent townie, that means in order for him to be town, he had to draw all 3 cards as town.

is there mafia unlynchable?

he could have had town role + mafia unlynchable to become town unlynchable then

[Elsa Jay]

I read the page. Only 1 unlynchable card in the entire list.

click here to check for yourself.

[Alchemist21]

There is an Alien 1-shot Unlynchable card.

The way he named his role though is exactly how it’s named for the Town card which makes me believe that’s the card he had, and it sounded like he tried to use the role name to imply his alignment without claiming what specific card he took alignment from which is also suspicious to me.

[DoubtingThomas]

yea looks sus

lolSpam when you claim and still becomes top lynch candidate

[Elsa Jay]

Not lynch candidate, more vigilante if it exists, but yeah.

Why waste time on a slot that literally doesn't die to a lynch?

[Alchemist21]

I do believe that they’re actually Unlynchable. The real question is, if there’s no Day vig, do we wait to see if there’s a regular vig or go ahead and lynch them twice and if there is a Night vig they just shoot elsewhere?

[DoubtingThomas]

Not lynch candidate, more vigilante if it exists, but yeah.

Why waste time on a slot that literally doesn't die to a lynch?

yeah i meant getting got not only a lynch

[DoubtingThomas]

I do believe that they’re actually Unlynchable. The real question is, if there’s no Day vig, do we wait to see if there’s a regular vig or go ahead and lynch them twice and if there is a Night vig they just shoot elsewhere?

no i dont think lynching twice is economically sustainable, especially when they can really be a town unlynchable too. even if they are mafia unlynchable i dont think its worth our time.

[Alchemist21]

UNVOTE:

Guess we’ll leave it to the vig then. If there’s no vig though we’ll have to double lynch, unless you think another faction would kill them at some point?

[Alchemist21]

I just don’t see a scenario where he picks a Town alignment card and then picks Unlynchable over Innocent Child.

[DoubtingThomas]

UNVOTE:

Guess we’ll leave it to the vig then. If there’s no vig though we’ll have to double lynch, unless you think another faction would kill them at some point?

not sure what other factions are out there but i dont see mafia faction ever killing them because feels like he is a LHF who will be scum read widely

do you have a reads list?

[Alchemist21]

UNVOTE:

Guess we’ll leave it to the vig then. If there’s no vig though we’ll have to double lynch, unless you think another faction would kill them at some point?

not sure what other factions are out there but i dont see mafia faction ever killing them because feels like he is a LHF who will be scum read widely

do you have a reads list?

Werewolf, Alien, and Mafia are all possible factions in this game and all would have to kill any existing members of the other factions to win.

I don’t have any other reads beyond what I’ve stated so far.

[DoubtingThomas]

UNVOTE:

Guess we’ll leave it to the vig then. If there’s no vig though we’ll have to double lynch, unless you think another faction would kill them at some point?

not sure what other factions are out there but i dont see mafia faction ever killing them because feels like he is a LHF who will be scum read widely

do you have a reads list?

Werewolf, Alien, and Mafia are all possible factions in this game and all would have to kill any existing members of the other factions to win.

I don’t have any other reads beyond what I’ve stated so far.

what have you stated? all i remember is you talking about spam tbh

[Alchemist21]

Got that FOS on orhz, a couple TR’s on TTTT and Pint. These are all based on discards though and I haven’t seen enough to form reads away from that yet.

[TTTT]

There is an Alien 1-shot Unlynchable card.

The way he named his role though is exactly how it’s named for the Town card which makes me believe that’s the card he had, and it sounded like he tried to use the role name to imply his alignment without claiming what specific card he took alignment from which is also suspicious to me.

^this
+ needing all three cards to be town
+ choosing unlynchable over IC
= vig shot

[TTTT]

so like I have a reason for wanting everyone to claim their cards' alignments
but since nobody is interested I'll move on
for now