Greatest Idea Mafia - Game Over

[brassherald]

Discards are not the be all and end all of this game.

bullshit. says the guy leaning on discard analysis

As I've already said, it's mod confirmed information. It's a factor in the equation, not the equation itself.

The be all end all would be the only information that matters, that's what the phrase means.

yes i got that but when you are top 3 in the game at relying on discards, you shouldn't be talking at all about how they aren't the equation

I don't need your permission to take it into account, and weigh them how I see fit. I used a phrase correctly, and you are trying to shade me for it?

It's not my fucking fault you are claiming to have made a shitty choice that I don't believe anyone would actually do.

[OkaPoka]

I'd prefer if tttt didn't hammer and let me hammer

[mcqueen]

page 19, taking another break.

as of, here's reads:

town

davesaz
Vedith
Allomancer
ofrhz
NotMySpamAccount
Alchemist21

null

Elsa Jay
pinturicchio
OkaPoka
TheGoldenParadox
Nimueh

leanscum

Gamma Emerald
DoubtingThomas

scum

TTTT
brassherald

[mcqueen]

Discards are not the be all and end all of this game.

bullshit. says the guy leaning on discard analysis

As I've already said, it's mod confirmed information. It's a factor in the equation, not the equation itself.

The be all end all would be the only information that matters, that's what the phrase means.

yes i got that but when you are top 3 in the game at relying on discards, you shouldn't be talking at all about how they aren't the equation

I don't need your permission to take it into account, and weigh them how I see fit. I used a phrase correctly, and you are trying to shade me for it?

It's not my fucking fault you are claiming to have made a shitty choice that I don't believe anyone would actually do.

idgaf what you think someone would do. fuck off would ya?

[pinturicchio]

That's like the third person you tell to fuck off in the game and you aren't even fully caught up. Take a deep breath pal

[brassherald]

Discards are not the be all and end all of this game.

bullshit. says the guy leaning on discard analysis

As I've already said, it's mod confirmed information. It's a factor in the equation, not the equation itself.

The be all end all would be the only information that matters, that's what the phrase means.

yes i got that but when you are top 3 in the game at relying on discards, you shouldn't be talking at all about how they aren't the equation

I don't need your permission to take it into account, and weigh them how I see fit. I used a phrase correctly, and you are trying to shade me for it?

It's not my fucking fault you are claiming to have made a shitty choice that I don't believe anyone would actually do.

idgaf what you think someone would do. fuck off would ya?

No.

[brassherald]

That's like the third person you tell to fuck off in the game and you aren't even fully caught up. Take a deep breath pal

I also never just fuck off.

[mcqueen]

nah, they actually need to fuck off. i've given them the time of day already, and they blew it.

[TTTT]

I'd prefer if tttt didn't hammer and let me hammer

then why haven't you hammered?
curious why you find it necessary to post this

[brassherald]

I'm apparently scum because I did math and said town nurse is not actually high town value.

[Gamma Emerald]

By the way, @Brass, Merchant's Daughter has finished. That's the game Vedith and I have been talking about. Allo suspecting Vedith is like predance all over again, and there's no way Allo is faking that 'cause it's too specific.

That's why I'm townreading DT too: he was scum there and during the game, Krazy gave 5 games from DT to ISO and I got them all right, but I got his alignment wrong on Merchant's Daughter: that's why I know he's better than he was back on August, he's harder to read. And I'm townreading him because he has been WAY more engaged here than that game. It's a little inconsistent since, if I believe he's better, he could be playing with a different playstyle in order to get townread, but it still seems out of his scumrange.

I agree DT is town because his play here feels solidly different than Merchant's Daughter

[TTTT]

mcqueen we have your reads
do I really need to drag this out?

[mcqueen]

I'm apparently scum because I did math and said town nurse is not actually high town value.

no you're scum for heavily relying on discards as a way to scumhunt/give out townreads but when pressed about it "its only part of the equation"

[mcqueen]

mcqueen we have your reads
do I really need to drag this out?

yes

[pinturicchio]

nah, they actually need to fuck off. i've given them the time of day already, and they blew it.

I don't know if they need to fuck off or not, but you seem frustrated and that doesn't help right now if you want to avoid being lynched. Also I don't like when people have a bad time while playing this game, it gets me anxious

[brassherald]

Nothing makes me want to push someone more than someone telling me to fuck off.

If you made better choices from the start, or made a better claim, I wouldn't be pressuring you. You get mercy when you show yourself to be town, which you have utterly failed to do.

[TTTT]

mcqueen we have your reads
do I really need to drag this out?

yes

ok so plz stop with the fuck offs
and keep reading and posting thoughts

[pinturicchio]

By the way, @Brass, Merchant's Daughter has finished. That's the game Vedith and I have been talking about. Allo suspecting Vedith is like predance all over again, and there's no way Allo is faking that 'cause it's too specific.

That's why I'm townreading DT too: he was scum there and during the game, Krazy gave 5 games from DT to ISO and I got them all right, but I got his alignment wrong on Merchant's Daughter: that's why I know he's better than he was back on August, he's harder to read. And I'm townreading him because he has been WAY more engaged here than that game. It's a little inconsistent since, if I believe he's better, he could be playing with a different playstyle in order to get townread, but it still seems out of his scumrange.

I agree DT is town because his play here feels solidly different than Merchant's Daughter

Hey good job by the way, it's the scumgame I've seen from you so far. I must say that made me more paranoid about you here but I still have a clean sheet reading you

[brassherald]

I'm apparently scum because I did math and said town nurse is not actually high town value.

no you're scum for heavily relying on discards as a way to scumhunt/give out townreads but when pressed about it "its only part of the equation"

IT IS ONLY PART OF THE EQUATION, you idiot, if someone is town by posting, I would not be pushing them.

You are scum by both claim and posting.

[pinturicchio]

I meant to say "it's your BEST scumgame..." @gamma

[mcqueen]

yeah me neither and i've tried to be a nice person within this community upon my return. but, holy shit this game

example not even related to me: look

how many pages

they focused on NMSA. it was clear within maybe 3 pages the ideal play is not to lynch him today.

[Gamma Emerald]

By the way, @Brass, Merchant's Daughter has finished. That's the game Vedith and I have been talking about. Allo suspecting Vedith is like predance all over again, and there's no way Allo is faking that 'cause it's too specific.

That's why I'm townreading DT too: he was scum there and during the game, Krazy gave 5 games from DT to ISO and I got them all right, but I got his alignment wrong on Merchant's Daughter: that's why I know he's better than he was back on August, he's harder to read. And I'm townreading him because he has been WAY more engaged here than that game. It's a little inconsistent since, if I believe he's better, he could be playing with a different playstyle in order to get townread, but it still seems out of his scumrange.

I agree DT is town because his play here feels solidly different than Merchant's Daughter

Hey good job by the way, it's the scumgame I've seen from you so far. I must say that made me more paranoid about you here but I still have a clean sheet reading you

Thanks pal. I wonder what our record is against/with each other.

[mcqueen]

I'm apparently scum because I did math and said town nurse is not actually high town value.

no you're scum for heavily relying on discards as a way to scumhunt/give out townreads but when pressed about it "its only part of the equation"

IT IS ONLY PART OF THE EQUATION, you idiot, if someone is town by posting, I would not be pushing them.

You are scum by both claim and posting.

TTTT IS SCUM BY POSTING AND YOU TOOK OFF YOUR VOTE BECAUSE OF HIS DISCARD

[brassherald]

I'm apparently scum because I did math and said town nurse is not actually high town value.

no you're scum for heavily relying on discards as a way to scumhunt/give out townreads but when pressed about it "its only part of the equation"

IT IS ONLY PART OF THE EQUATION, you idiot, if someone is town by posting, I would not be pushing them.

You are scum by both claim and posting.

TTTT IS SCUM BY POSTING AND YOU TOOK OFF YOUR VOTE BECAUSE OF HIS DISCARD

I disagree with you. And I am allowed to do that.

[TTTT]

who here has experience playing with mcqueen?