Booneytoonz IX - Under The Sea -- Game Over!

[Creature]

Now We're Only Falling Apart

[Kaito Momota]

VOTE: Jingle

[Nero Cain]

We should have lynched him over molla but Wisdom put mechanics over common sense.

except when I voted Katio you were all like "$%%^$$&^%$ Y R U HOLDING UP THE DAY!?"

I mean TBF, that's on me but my initial response was "this is scum that's anxious to get to night" I'm just having a hard time getting around the miller claim.

I'm wondering if I was right earlier and Nikk was our token VT and it's just a Katio vs. PB team. The only thing slightly problematic about that is there are so many prs so yes a Katio, Jingle team makes some sense to me as well.

[Nancy Drew 39]

We should have lynched him over molla but Wisdom put mechanics over common sense.

except when I voted Katio you were all like "$%%^$$&^%$ Y R U HOLDING UP THE DAY!?"

I mean TBF, that's on me but my initial response was "this is scum that's anxious to get to night" I'm just having a hard time getting around the miller claim.

I'm wondering if I was right earlier and Nikk was our token VT and it's just a Katio vs. PB team. The only thing slightly problematic about that is there are so many prs so yes a Katio, Jingle team makes some sense to me as well.

I drank Wisdom koolade. \_0_/

He was so focused on his scum rb theory, that he put that above who was most likely scum. I am town miller. LA hardclaimed PR in another game very similar to this one, which is why I chose her slot to rep into over Dave’s whom I was less sure on.

I hardtownread Creature and think PB is also town. You’re IC and Kaito/Jingle are the only ones left and Chara hard scumread that slot and apparently Maki has a meta of only pushing scum!Kaito, according to both Maki/Chara.

[Nero Cain]

I'm also flirting with the idea of no lynch like it prob does nothing since I'm pretty likely to be the kill but on the off chance scum don't have a roleblocker AND Creature is a backup rolecop giving him an extra investigate seems the smart play, no?

[Nero Cain]

Is it so implausible that you'd be wrong about PB? The only real argument I could see is "scum wouldn't do that!" when he's sheeping and bussing his buddies.

[Nancy Drew 39]

Hey Chara I'm confident Kaito is scum. Now come join me

Kaito has no reason to make that claim in the first place

He does if he thinks clemency was bsing a pr claim in order to force him to commit to it

Faking vanilla cop is trying to fish a pr at best. Clearly, scum motivated he could've reaction tested in a dif manor. This was meant with pure scum intent

i disagree but youre tunneling so it doesnt matter

You're correct that I'm tunneling. I haven't been wrong when I've called him scum as town before though so I don't see a reason to stop.

Wisdom won't listen Chara it's useless.
You know I can read Kaito

[Kaito Momota]

Chara can't read me and doesn't even try to, he follows Maki

Maki's play was proven to be atrocious in this game, we're following her likely lead and voting out Jingle

[Nero Cain]

you don't need to sell me on Katio.

[Kaito Momota]

Nero is despicable and Nancy is tunneled, and that's everyone

[Nero Cain]

I'm so despicable for having a scum read on you. Go ad hom somewhere else, Dunn.

[Nancy Drew 39]

wisdom/dave/lady

oh yeah forgot about kaito

he can be scum too

I still rather Kaito bite the dusto, but if I have to compromise then so be it. Besides, when Maki commits Seppuku and Clem is murdered, we all know who caused that to happen.

VOTE: Lady Angel

Sometimes to get the Super Scum, you got to massacre a few expendable slots.

forgets about his Kaito scumread for a second, but it's still the player he wants most to lynch. and LA is a compromise despite being in his scumlist?

aside from that Elsa's reads are

extremely

static and i'm not seeing much evidence of them changing in response to game events.

[Nancy Drew 39]

I'm also flirting with the idea of no lynch like it prob does nothing since I'm pretty likely to be the kill but on the off chance scum don't have a roleblocker AND Creature is a backup rolecop giving him an extra investigate seems the smart play, no?

If they killed Wisdom why wouldn’t Creature be next, since he is now town rolecop?

[Nero Cain]

he could be but if scum did have a blocker I think they'd block him and shoot me.

[Kaito Momota]

I'm also flirting with the idea of no lynch like it prob does nothing since I'm pretty likely to be the kill but on the off chance scum don't have a roleblocker AND Creature is a backup rolecop giving him an extra investigate seems the smart play, no?

If they killed Wisdom why wouldn’t Creature be next, since he is now town rolecop?

Maybe we should be no lynching today

[Kaito Momota]

I take that back

I don't really think Creature is scum

Let's get Jingle

[Nancy Drew 39]

Is it so implausible that you'd be wrong about PB? The only real argument I could see is "scum wouldn't do that!" when he's sheeping and bussing his buddies.

I think this is PB’s townplay here. I also have the strongest srs on Kaito, followed by Jingle. I don’t see why we should lynch anywhere else but I feel and have been feeling the most confident on Kaito scum from after town!Maki flip.

[Kaito Momota]

I'm done talking to Nancy/Nero, you guys can win with me or lose and blame clemency/maki post-game

[Kaito Momota]

I'm still vanilla town and we should be lynching Jingle

[Creature]

I'm also leaning Jingle and I think I only let him live yesterday because he could prevent roleblocker. However I don't think he's that useful anymore anyway if I'm likely getting nightkilled tonight.

[Nancy Drew 39]

he could be but if scum did have a blocker I think they'd block him and shoot me.

Why didn’t scum block Wisdom and kill you last night then? I think Wisdom kill over you, points to probably no scum rb and probably Clem rb’d Wisdom.

[Nancy Drew 39]

I'm also leaning Jingle and I think I only let him live yesterday because he could prevent roleblocker. However I don't think he's that useful anymore anyway if I'm likely getting nightkilled tonight.

I’m not opposed to Jingle. I didn’t really care too much for his entrance. @Kaito, why didn’t you vote Vedith?

That really pings me that he did sheep driveby vote and never switched it to Vedith.

[Kaito Momota]

@Kaito, why didn’t you vote Vedith?

I tried to replace out when Nero entered the game because I didn't want to play with him

I never even comprehended Vedith being in the game, nor do I know why we lynched him

[Nancy Drew 39]

@Kaito, why didn’t you vote Vedith?

I tried to replace out when Nero entered the game because I didn't want to play with him

I never even comprehended Vedith being in the game, nor do I know why we lynched him

He was bleeding informed scum, who replaced Fire scum.

[Nancy Drew 39]

P.edit. What does Nero have to do with you not voting Vedith?