Booneytoonz IX - Under The Sea -- Game Over!

[Nancy Drew 39]

So does scum Jingle.

I'm always free with reads unless I’m scum.

FIFY

[Nancy Drew 39]

It’s blatantly obvious that scum isn’t killing PB or me over IC/town rolecop.

But sure you giving results on a confirmed non-PR, it going to totally tip scum off and lose us the game.

[Nancy Drew 39]

It’s blatantly obvious that scum isn’t killing PB or me over IC/town rolecop.

But sure you giving READS on a confirmed non-PR, it going to totally tip scum off and lose us the game.

[Jingle]

People I would never consider lynching regardless of circumstances: Nero.

Other People: Not Nero.

Is that good enough for you?

Say I come out and say I suspect Nancy PB. Kaito scum now has a reason to let Creature conftown me. Creature scum now has a reason to fake a town result on me. Say I say I suspect Creature. Non Creature scum now has a reason to kill Nero and attempt a 1v1 between me and creature. Say I say I suspect Kaito. Non Kaito scum has no reason to rock the boat. And it doesn't just apply to me.

Say Creat/PB is the scumteam, Creat knows his best play is to conftown Nancy, because conftowning Nancy means her tunnel on me has literally no reason to change. Say Creat is town, creat claiming who he is going to investigate tonight just gives the scumteam the ability to shoot a potential conftown instead of Creature or Nero.

Keeping the scumteam as in the dark as possible is a good idea. I'm not going to die tonight in any universe, so there's no reason for me to worry about getting my reads out in the open now. AND, and possibly most important, there are more things to analyze tomorrow. Did scum shoot Creature or Nero? Who did creature claim to investigate? Are there any lies?

100/100 times, I'm going to attempt to make the important lynches with more information rather than less.

[Jingle]

viewtopic.php?f=51&t=77108 -> Town Jingle, withholding reads to avoid outing PRs. Additionally, town Jingle being mean to conftown because the conftown was being dumb and ignoring optimal play. You wanna know how that ended up? A draw. Because the conftown didn't hammer in time after I spent 2 weeks telling him we would draw if he didn't hammer.

So does scum Jingle.

I'm always free with reads unless I’m scum.

FIFY

[Nancy Drew 39]

People I would never consider lynching regardless of circumstances: Nero.

Other People: Not Nero.

Is that good enough for you?

Say I come out and say I suspect Nancy PB.

Kaito scum

now has a reason to let Creature conftown me. Creature scum now has a reason to fake a town result on me. Say I say I suspect Creature. Non Creature scum now has a reason to kill Nero and attempt a 1v1 between me and creature. Say I say I suspect Kaito. Non Kaito scum has no reason to rock the boat. And it doesn't just apply to me.

Say Creat/PB is the scumteam, Creat knows his best play is to conftown Nancy, because conftowning Nancy means her tunnel on me has literally no reason to change. Say Creat is town, creat claiming who he is going to investigate tonight just gives the scumteam the ability to shoot a potential conftown instead of Creature or Nero.

Keeping the scumteam as in the dark as possible is a good idea. I'm not going to die tonight in any universe, so there's no reason for me to worry about getting my reads out in the open now. AND, and possibly most important, there are more things to analyze tomorrow. Did scum shoot Creature or Nero? Who did creature claim to investigate? Are there any lies?

100/100 times, I'm going to attempt to make the important lynches with more information rather than less.

I swear if we lose this game to this, all of you should feel really bad.

[Pink Ball]

Hey I just realized that Jingle has been on L-1 since Nancy's vote 'cause Kaito voted Jingle at the very begining of the day. So Creature is conftown from my PoV then, the only way Jingle flips town is a Kaito/Nancy team or that there's only one scum remaining and it's not Jingle. If it's the first case, I again lose fair and square to scum!Nancy, and if it's the latter, we lynch Kaito tomorrow and we win too. Like, my only reason to unvote Jingle would be voting Kaito, jut then it would be the same two circumstances for Kaito to be town: either it's Jingle/Nancy or it's Jingle alone. So let's just lynch Jingle 'cause he would be the PR of the team

[Jingle]

Yeah, the only reason I haven't self voted is that it would literally be gamethrowing to self hammer in MYLO.

[Jingle]

I swear if we lose this game to this,

all of you should feel really bad.

FTFY.

[Creature]

When Creature expectedly claims “no results”, scum will try to pudh his mislynch.

Again, I expect them to be pretty aware they're unable to push my mislynch unless Kaito is town and one of Pink/Nancy is scum with Jingle.

Kaito isn’t. Read that Fire post, I just quoted.

If I were scum with Jingle, I would be onboard with the no lynch idiocy. I think - hope not Pink isn’t falling for Jingle bs.

Not lynching Jingle or Kaito, costs us the game. It really doesn’t matter which one of them we lynch.

You should have no problem nolynching if you and Pink settle to never lynch me.

I'm afraid I'm somewhat close to conftown and we'll go from 2 to 1 conftown tomorrow.

[Jingle]

Hey look. Creature also thinks my posts today are reasonable. It's like I make sense or something.

[Jingle]

close to conftown

If it helps, FMPOV you're conftown. From everyone else's PoV you'd have to be my partner.

[Jingle]

Which... means no lynch is no longer viable.

UNVOTE:

[Jingle]

VOTE: Kaito

[Pink Ball]

Oh forgot considering Creature as partner, duh.

[Pink Ball]

Uggg Jingle that post was townie as fuck not gonna lie, but Creature can't be Kaito's partner so if you think Kaito is scum then it would be either Nancy or me and that's not possible, sorry

[Jingle]

Uggg Jingle that

post

ISO is townie as fuck not gonna lie

FTFY

And I honestly don't know which one of you it is. I just know that it has to be one of you FMPOV. I get that I'm gonna lose here, but I don't really feel bad losing to whichever one of you it is. Hence, lynch the partner first.

[Creature]

close to conftown

If it helps, FMPOV you're conftown. From everyone else's PoV you'd have to be my partner.

???

[Creature]

VOTE: Kaito

can't be Kaito alone

[Jingle]

close to conftown

If it helps, FMPOV you're conftown. From everyone else's PoV you'd have to be my partner.

???

If you were scum you'd have hammered me. Everyone else can assume that you didn't hammer because we're partners, but I'm L-1 and you didn't hammer.

[Jingle]

Hence, lynch the partner first.

[Creature]

close to conftown

If it helps, FMPOV you're conftown. From everyone else's PoV you'd have to be my partner.

???

If you were scum you'd have hammered me. Everyone else can assume that you didn't hammer because we're partners, but I'm L-1 and you didn't hammer.

Why I'd have to be your partner?

[Creature]

Oh right, realised Kaito has voted Jingle too

still not hammering

[Creature]

@Nancy

I think the chance of Jingle winning the 1v1 against me is basically zero now.

[Jingle]

@Nancy

I think the chance of Jingle winning the 1v1 against me is basically zero now.

Literally 0. Still can't no lynch because you just die.