Open 752: Donner Party [Game Over]

[Vedith]

Also last thing: yeah, I do disagree with the hammer so soon, though surprisingly it wasn't from DT or Vedith.

Why is this surprising?

[ChibiBear]

VOTE COUNT 1.07

texcat

(7): Eyes without a face, PenguinPower, Bittersweet, Persivul, Elsa Jay, Vedith, Chateau Lobby

LYNCH

Eyes without a face

(2): Dr Worm, scum reading

Bittersweet

(1): TheGoldenParadox

DoubtingThomas

(1): texcat

Not Voting

(1): DoubtingThomas

With

12

alive, it takes

7

to lynch.

Day 1 ends in

(expired on 2019-03-09 11:00:00)

It's Friday night ya'll and I just got home, you'll have to bear (hah) with me while I slowly get stuff done

[ChibiBear]

Night 1 has begun!

texcat has been lynched! She was a…

Spoiler:

Welcome, texcat, you are a

Vanilla Townie

.

Abilities:

Your weapon is your vote, you have no night actions.

Win Condition:

You win when all threats to the town are eliminated and there is at least one town-aligned player alive.

Please confirm by replying to this PM with your role name.

Please send in all night actions.

I will start Day 2 ASAP if everyone sends me a PM to request a Fast Night.

Night 1 ends in (expired on 2019-03-04 01:00:00)

[ChibiBear]

I just had something urgent come up, so it’s likely that I will have to extend the night by approx 10 hours unless it is somehow resolved unexpectedly soon, but I wouldn’t count on it. Apologies for the delay!

[ChibiBear]

Looks like I'm having a lucky day! Day 2 will begin on schedule (more or less), sorry for the false alarm.

[ChibiBear]

Day 2 has begun!

Bittersweet has gone missing...

Persivul has gone missing...

VOTE COUNT 2.0

Not Voting

(9): Chateau Lobby, Elsa Jay, Dr Worm, Eyes without a face, Vedith, PenguinPower, DoubtingThomas, TheGoldenParadox, scum reading

With

9

alive, it takes

5

to lynch.

Day 1 ends in

(expired on 2019-03-16 01:00:00)

[Elsa Jay]

2 kills and not 3? Hmm...

[scum reading]

Since I was rudely dragged back in because of DT taking Anna hostage, let's focus on Persi for a bit.

Frankly the ones who know me know that my lynch day 1 literally gives nobody information. Going for me while knowing my past d1? That's the ultimate way to try and waste day 1.

How about day two though? Elsa, what do you think about the choice of victims and who is the person that should be lynched today, in your opinion?

[scum reading]

I hope I was clear about my intention for today in that posts, if we can get some opinions on this and I’ll present my case in a bit, I just want to get reactions at the moment

[Chateau Lobby]

Are you implying
That Elsa is responsible
For Persivul's death
Based on the post you quoted?

[TheGoldenParadox]

Why is bittersweet still in VC

@mod

?

Mistake from manual typing, my bad!

[Elsa Jay]

Are you implying
That Elsa is responsible
For Persivul's death
Based on the post you quoted?

I was wondering that too, really...

Gotta reread the game too see what went wrong but I think it's possible (likely) that both of the Mafia voted for Tex. The SK I will worry about later.

[scum reading]

I wanted to make a badass entrance but it seems like I’ll have to belittle it now I think Elsa is scum, she could’ve killed either Persi or Bittersweet. What’s certain is that Persivul mentioned she was not her usual self. It seemed to me like Persi was the only one that knew scum elsa’s gameplay. He was already throwing some shade at her, in rvs as well as later on. I was suspicious of elsa ever since I noticed she was an active poster in rvs and then stopped posting when more serious accusations were thrown. After that, vedith, dr worm and me decided to pressure eyes and then elsa hops on again to seem like she’s contributing, but her 176 isn’t helping in any way. After that, Eyes comes along and he doesn’t defend himself just yet. On post 262, Elsa already disagrees with my read and claims eyes seems town, even though his response to our pressuring wagon comes only at post 272. Then she slips under the radar again. What happens next is interesting though: Tex’s wagon gains momentum and Elsa says she doesn’t want to be on the wagon because she’ll get hammered and that she will evaluate Tex’s iso before voting. Then, DT and vedith drop their votes and here comes Elsa, voting tex, whom Elsa has never commented on. Her vote was not at the beginning of the push, and not at the end, just in that sweet spot, the middle towards the end a bit. I have a lot of confidence in my read, but I’ll wait for other people’s responses because I can make mistakes. I’m interested in hearing DT and Vedith’s opinions on this, as I townread them the most. Anyone can hop in and leave thoughts, especially Elsa

[Vedith]

374 was bothering me as if it was trying to put shade onto me an DT.
I did find Else's play in organised yesterday though which is different to BooneyToonz where they were Scum (I replaced in as Scum after Elsa was killed).

I think I'll 're check that game first to see if the play is similar.
Pers being killed isn't too odd as he's a strong player but Bittersweet wasn't put in the Scum light yesterday so if Scum/SK I'd suspect Elsa killing here as killing Pers doesn't make sense with potential pressure.

[scum reading]

After I second guessed myself, I saw persi’s kill as a weak attempt at framing Elsa. But her behavior is anti-town in my opinion, she posted reads when i asked and then when DT does, she is reluctant to share updated ones. When I pushed on Elsa to get a reaction she didn’t even want to defend herself. That to me isn’t townie behavior. Half of her posts are just chit chatting and the other half are an attempt at pocketing Eyes, even though Eyes didn’t say anything relevant that would come off as town-indicative. Elsa town read him before he even got to defend himself against our push. That to me is suspicious. For me, this is the lynch that should take place. Perhaps a few reads from Elsa might change my mind, but for now, I’ve never felt so confident in my reads.

[Elsa Jay]

One who doesn't defend herself is one without anything to hide, young one.

[scum reading]

VOTE: Elsa Jay

I predict I’ll see a defence by the end of this day.

[Elsa Jay]

VOTE: Scum reading

Or you can move your merry way off of me and forget about this, huh? There's 7 other slots for you to accuse, surely from your perspective 3/8 odds shouldn't mean let's just go crazy and pick me out.

Going for me is the worst play though, I assure you.

[scum reading]

Is this an omgus just like that Persi situation, or are there actual leads against me?

[scum reading]

In the meantime, FoS : Dr Worm.

[Chateau Lobby]

In the meantime, FoS : Dr Worm.

I want to take your reads
seriously
But it seems you are just throwing shade
At everyone.

And besides I'm still waiting
On that "actual information"
You have on me
That you promised
To share today.

[Elsa Jay]

And of all the names to pick, you pick Worm? The guy who probably should have been vigged?

Before we do that I guess, does anyone know what happened to the 3rd kill? Remember, we got Mafia, the Vigilante, AND Serial Killer. We lost Bitter and Persi but that leaves one unaccounted for.

[Chateau Lobby]

As to the missing
3rd kill,
I'm guessing either someone holstered
Or the roleblocker
Chose correctly.

[Elsa Jay]

There is one more option that the Mafia or Vigilante had shot the SK last night, Chateau. The SK is one-shot Bulletproof AND one-shot roleblock proof.

[scum reading]

And of all the names to pick, you pick Worm? The guy who probably should have been vigged?

Before we do that I guess, does anyone know what happened to the 3rd kill? Remember, we got Mafia, the Vigilante, AND Serial Killer. We lost Bitter and Persi but that leaves one unaccounted for.

I don’t get why you’re so stuck on that, maybe the vig just didn’t have information to shoot? Is it a thing where vigis here shoot without any clues as well? Not worth risking shooting a town.