Greatest Idea Mafia - Game Over

[ofrhz]

night action claims:
oka vigs TGP (success)
Elsa watches brass (nobody visits)
brass docs DT
vedith investigates ???
TTTT docs ???

VOTE: Nimueh

I'm a JOAT

I rb'd Nimueh last night, and I suspect that's why there was only one kill last night

Another possible explanation for the lack of NK is that scum tried and failed to kill DT last night, but I don't think it's very probable that they would kill DT over two claimed doctors and a vig

full claim
all your cards
thx

I already did

JOAT, Mason, Mason

[DoubtingThomas]

i didn't say she was. i just like their play/contribution in this game less than elsa. i scum read both of them at some point in this game due to their posting. now everyone claimed something and we have very little mechanical evidences to deduce scums, so i am going with my guts

[ofrhz]

Ofrhz ISO makes no sense to block nim

Idk why you think this

I was basically deciding between TGP/Elsa/Nim last night for my target.

I figured TGP was unlikely to do the NK since he was basically caught scum

Elsa was also suboptimal because she was likely to investigate rather than kill and was already rb'd on N1 by someone else

And Nim has been flying under the radar so I figured any scumteam with her on it, she'll likely be doing the NK anyway

[DoubtingThomas]

Ofrhz ISO makes no sense to block nim

Idk why you think this

I was basically deciding between TGP/Elsa/Nim last night for my target.

I figured TGP was unlikely to do the NK since he was basically caught scum

Elsa was also suboptimal because she was likely to investigate rather than kill and was already rb'd on N1 by someone else

And Nim has been flying under the radar so I figured any scumteam with her on it, she'll likely be doing the NK anyway

this feels like you are implying you know there are 3 scums

[ofrhz]

They're just my top scumreads

[ofrhz]

It was just heavily implied the beginning of day that Okapoka was mafia by night results from Gamma.

if this is the case than VOTE: Okapoke

This is basically allo's explanation of his scumread on oka in his ISO

even though the night action result thing was later explicitly denied by Gamma

[ofrhz]

Good chance Elsa and Ofrhz are Scum together.

She’s either lying or

she’s confirming I’m telling the truth

. Either way her vote on me makes no sense.

What

No

How

[ofrhz]

i didn't say she was.

i just like their play/contribution in this game less than elsa

. i scum read both of them at some point in this game due to their posting. now everyone claimed something and we have very little mechanical evidences to deduce scums, so i am going with my guts

[ofrhz]

I can case Nim later when I have more time, but it's just going to boil down to "just look at their ISO"

[TTTT]

JOAT, Mason, Mason

alignments on the kept cards?

[ofrhz]

I had all town cards

[Allomancer]

so did i

[DoubtingThomas]

i had a mafia card

[pinturicchio]

And I'm from Chile. That makes me a south american. A latino. A hot blood latino with dancing skills you would never imagine in your dreams as possible for a human being.

And I'm dancing right now,
with the cold blooded queen,
But it won't be for long
if you know what I mean

[Nimueh]

given these claimed night actions
why is ohfrz more likely scum than elsa?
real question
I'm trying to figure this out

I doc’d Brass. Elsa claims a no visit result on him. Ohfrz claims to have rb’d me but is still voting me, which makes 0 sense. Ohfrz claim would back up both Elsa’s and my claim, if true. Outside of the 1v1, I wasn’t sr him. I find everything about Ohfrz claim and vote on me suspicious.

VOTE: ohfrz

[Nimueh]

I can case Nim later when I have more time, but it's just going to boil down to "just look at their ISO"

Precisely why you shouldn’t be voting me.

[Vedith]

I'm thinking the no lynch idea and big doesn't shoot is good.
If we are only against Aliens then then there's nothing that could be done to stop is.

I could also then check in Elsa, ofrhz or nim depending who agrees where?

[Nimueh]

I'm thinking the no lynch idea and big doesn't shoot is good.
If we are only against Aliens then then there's nothing that could be done to stop is.

I could also then check in Elsa, ofrhz or nim depending who agrees where?

I’m fine if you check me, since I’m telling the truth.

[Vedith]

Don't get me wrong, I believe you.

I think town are
DT, TTTT, nim, Brass, Pintu and Oka

[Nimueh]

Don't get me wrong, I believe you.

I think town are
DT, TTTT, nim, Brass, Pintu and Oka

I know, I think you do. I just didn’t want to leave any room for doubt. I will be legit shocked if ohrz isn’t scum here.

[TTTT]

Don't get me wrong, I believe you.

I think town are
DT, TTTT, nim, Brass, Pintu and Oka

why DT?
I'm with you on everyone else

[Vedith]

why DT?
I'm with you on everyone else

I visited night 1.

[TTTT]

yeah that's a pretty good reason to TR someone

[pinturicchio]

Are you really gonna ignore my beautiful piece of art and not vote Elsa?

[TTTT]

town:
DT, TTTT, nim, Brass, Pintu, Oka, Vedith

leaving:
Allo, ofrhz, Gamma, Elsa

so I'm trying to decide if no-lynch is better than just lynching in the PoE pool
alien faction does seem likely
if we no-lynch what's the best order for the day4 claiming of results?