Open 752: Donner Party [Game Over]

[scum reading]

In the eventuality Elsa gets hammered while I’m sleeping(which I am totally fine with) and she flips scum, if vig is still alive they should shoot Chateau for trying to divert attention. He also said that he believes my case against elsa is good, but he is not pushing with me, he is pushing against me. Reason being he wanted to look town by saying “your case actually deserves merit points” , to only then vote me because I “keep switching my reads”. Just because I switch my reads doesn’t change my case against Elsa in any way, and he knows that, but he can’t bus his team mate, so he just has to cling onto a stupid excuse as a reason not to vote Elsa. Another potential target would be dr worm, but I’ll wait to see who he votes for. I’d go for the first option though, a lot safer compared to dr worm who I don’t have a lot of information on.

[DoubtingThomas]

But, yes, I think town!TGP is more solvey here.

I fully agree here.
TGP who should I be voting?

i dont understand how you can agree with this

[DoubtingThomas]

i think i town read scum reading

[scum reading]

Don’t say that just to look town as well, vote accordingly to your read.

[DoubtingThomas]

eyes still havent given a read

[Vedith]

i dont understand how you can agree with this

Care to tell me why I'm wrong?

[DoubtingThomas]

i can't talk about it

[Vedith]

Okay fair enough.

[scum reading]

eyes still havent given a read

How would eyes affect this lynch by giving reads? We, as a town, aren’t focusing on a lynch collectively. Again, this elsa push is rather slow for the evidence I provided. Scum and town are reluctant to vote this. I’d says scums are reluctant to vote because I have them already on my radar and if they went for any vote other than Elsa, I’d suspect them. They also don’t want to push Elsa, hoping someone will save her from this situation or they are expecting her to get herself off the L1. Any sort of defence on elsa will be seen as scum. Why is nobody defending elsa by the way? I wonder... Nobody has town read her except for eyes, who she has town read. My guess would be Elsa tried to pocket someone in a way, and seeing town pushed eyes day one, she tried to look town giving him the benefit of the doubt. Not even eyes is defending this right now.

I’ll take it as an attempt to form a scum read for yourself, DT, however, once eyes replies with a readslist, I expect you to be on this wagon.

[PenguinPower]

Bullet point your evidence for me.

[DoubtingThomas]

I find it offputting that you request others to state their thoughts and reads but don't yourself do so.

Like...I don't usually give reasons for my stances, but I at least make them.

penguin not making stances after this post

[PenguinPower]

[Vedith]

PP look me in the eyes!

[PenguinPower]

[Vedith]

I believe \o/

[Elsa Jay]

I'm back. Have we seen reason yet?

[Vedith]

If you're willing to discuss your reads that would be great.

[PenguinPower]

^
yes this

[Elsa Jay]

In order of importance from most town to most scum:

1 - Cheateu (I like him. What elsa can I say?)
2 - Penguin (the more Scum read shades him the more I like him)
3 - Doubting Thomas (I feel the pain of having no town reads)
4 - Eyes with no face (but a good mouth with wise words)
----------------
5 - Vedith (Jumped on my Wagon)
6 - Paradox (non factor)
7 - The Worm (I wOnDeR wHy?)
8 - Scum Reading (cannibal slip)

Those below the line, if town, please do better.

[Vedith]

Why would you want people under the line to do better if you suspect are likely Scum?
I don't hate your reads though. Scum reading is most likely town though.
Do you have any actual reasons aside from me and scum Reading?
Sell me on TGP.

[PenguinPower]

Is SR shading me?

[Elsa Jay]

Is SR shading me?

Not at all, but I'm glad you read my post and thought to ask about it. +2 trust.

[Vedith]

Sell TGP to me.

[Elsa Jay]

Started off voting Penguin, then did a tangent on me, then Penguin again, the goes V/LA for the nightphase, but comes back in swinging at me and being the 3rd vote on me. Atleast I understand why you'd vote me Ved... But Scumreading took what Paradox said about me not "being myself" and saying I'm an easy Scumread. Perfect middle wagon too. Paradox has played me multiple times and the last time he targetted Bambi and got reversed lynched for being to aggressive... But now I realize that was a sign of town him. This play so far is far from town at all.

VOTE: Paradox

Frankly a few of you also townread Scumreading, so I'll take majority opinion to heart. This is probably a better area to start with. Reread what he's said so far and make your opinion, but I know for sure I'm not wrong here on one of them being scum.

[Eyes without a face]

VOTE: Elsa

Elsa who's Scum other than Scum reading?

I think I'm gonna have to veto this. Pick one of the other 2. (i.e. WIRM or TGP)