Greatest Idea VIII - Game Over

[TemporalLich]

Yeah just in case Elsa isn't bluffing about being a Judas Vigilante...

VOTE: Sakura Hana

Cop discard is very suspicious.

[Alchemist21]

Yes. The role is still a strong informational role. It also doesn’t have the baggage of NK WIFOM with people wondering “did they target scum or did scum kill them?”

[Micc]

Votecount 1.01

Sakura Hana (2) -

Alchemist21, TemporalLich

Elsa Jay (1) -

Shadowlesscloud

Shadowlesscloud (1) -

brassherald

brassherald (1) -

JunkoChan

Not Voting (16) -

TTTT, Allomancer, Vedith, ofrhz, davesaz, NotMySpamAccount, Elsa Jay, DoubtingThomas, pinturicchio, Performer, Gamma Emerald, Blooper, Chemist1422, Irrelephant11, Xtoxm, Sakura Hana

With 21 players alive it takes 11 votes to lynch.

The deadline for Day 1 is in (expired on 2019-03-30 23:30:00).

[Sakura Hana]

I thought the same. Is mafia a favored faction in this site? Like do people like to be scum?

I know some people that do, not sure how favored it is, I used to like it like years ago, then i grew to hate being scum.

[JunkoChan]

actually I'm susps of the vanilla throws, having 3 town roles was a slim chance from what I could tell and picking vanilla + role is was the most reasonable thing to do becaus you can avoid unfavorable convinations, unless someone can prove me wrong it stands out to me

[Elsa Jay]

I think if you count the cards in the deck Mafia does have the most chance to occur of any scumgroup. Plus my Judas card would turn me into Mafia.

It's all about the odds, really. And I guess looking at the discards help too.

[JunkoChan]

combinations* I'm sleepy bye

[Alchemist21]

I wanted to RVS Elsa because so far they keep getting scum and killing me N1. With that claim it’s probably best to let Night actions resolve the slot.

Sakura’a Cop discard is definitely sus to me.

VOTE: Sakura

I thought the same. Is mafia a favored faction in this site? Like do people like to be scum?

I’m not sure. It’s probably fairly split overall but our last run of this setup had 2 scum and a survivor out of 16 players. That’s part of why this run had 3 different sets of card choices.

[Sakura Hana]

Btw, what are people's opinions on claiming the cards used for alignment?
I'm fine going first on that since im being suspect already and it was an unique card so.

[Shadowlesscloud]

Btw, what are people's opinions on claiming the cards used for alignment?
I'm fine going first on that since im being suspect already and it was an unique card so.

what would be the point?

[Alchemist21]

actually I'm susps of the vanilla throws, having 3 town roles was a slim chance from what I could tell and picking vanilla + role is was the most reasonable thing to do becaus you can avoid unfavorable convinations, unless someone can prove me wrong it stands out to me

If you had VT + Town card + scum card with a favorable role then it makes sense to discard the VT. Discarding a rare card tells scum what they can’t fakeclaim so it’s a little better to throw out something more common.

[Elsa Jay]

+1 to Alch

[Shadowlesscloud]

Btw, what are people's opinions on claiming the cards used for alignment?
I'm fine going first on that since im being suspect already and it was an unique card so.

what would be the point?

Like i really dont like this as it makes it seem like "Yeah, im town, heres the card I used for my alignment!"

[Sakura Hana]

Btw, what are people's opinions on claiming the cards used for alignment?
I'm fine going first on that since im being suspect already and it was an unique card so.

what would be the point?

Everyone would have to claim something townie and some people might claim something that can be CC'd.

[JunkoChan]

actually I'm susps of the vanilla throws, having 3 town roles was a slim chance from what I could tell and picking vanilla + role is was the most reasonable thing to do becaus you can avoid unfavorable convinations, unless someone can prove me wrong it stands out to me

If you had VT + Town card + scum card with a favorable role then it makes sense to discard the VT. Discarding a rare card tells scum what they can’t fakeclaim so it’s a little better to throw out something more common.

(y)

[Alchemist21]

Btw, what are people's opinions on claiming the cards used for alignment?
I'm fine going first on that since im being suspect already and it was an unique card so.

No. We’re not about to just give away info for no reason.

[Shadowlesscloud]

Current reads are: Alech town lean, Sakura scum lean, Elsa scum. This is going great so far.

p-edit: Wait cards can only show up once? No repeats?

[Alchemist21]

actually I'm susps of the vanilla throws, having 3 town roles was a slim chance from what I could tell and picking vanilla + role is was the most reasonable thing to do becaus you can avoid unfavorable convinations, unless someone can prove me wrong it stands out to me

If you had VT + Town card + scum card with a favorable role then it makes sense to discard the VT. Discarding a rare card tells scum what they can’t fakeclaim so it’s a little better to throw out something more common.

(y)

Idk what (y) means.

[Elsa Jay]

I only outted my,alignment card because it's a special case, but yeah. Don't out your alignment cards yet.

[Sakura Hana]

p-edit: Wait cards can only show up once? No repeats?

If there's 7 VT cards in the deck, then there can only be 7 VT cards total, same for all the others.

[Alchemist21]

Current reads are: Alech town lean, Sakura scum lean, Elsa scum. This is going great so far.

p-edit: Wait cards can only show up once? No repeats?

Depends on the card.

https://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?ti ... ia/RolePMs

Anything with a single number is unique. Anything with a range of numbers can show up multiple times.

[Elsa Jay]

These are the cards. The 146. Not the weird extras.

You can find and read the Judas card too. It's very fun

Pedit: Dang You linked it too.

[JunkoChan]

actually I'm susps of the vanilla throws, having 3 town roles was a slim chance from what I could tell and picking vanilla + role is was the most reasonable thing to do becaus you can avoid unfavorable convinations, unless someone can prove me wrong it stands out to me

If you had VT + Town card + scum card with a favorable role then it makes sense to discard the VT. Discarding a rare card tells scum what they can’t fakeclaim so it’s a little better to throw out something more common.

(y)

Idk what (y) means.

thumbs up

[Shadowlesscloud]

Honestly confused why you didnt hold that information in as if i was mafia, I would have probably slipped hard

[Sakura Hana]

I've seen alignment card massclaim done before in GestI, but i was bored while waiting for this to start and i read the previous 2 games, and saw that it didnt happen until like D2 or 3 so I decided to ask instead.