STELLARIS MAFIA - [Mafia Win]

[Joan of Arc]

First things first, the Firestarter hammer: DG's hammer post does feel fueled by righteous anger. Unfortunately it's the lynch we secretly wanted ever since D1, so it's hard to judge DG for actually pulling the trigger.

uhh who is the "we"

??

"we" - everyone who wanted Firestarters to reap what they sowed and be held accountable.

Hey, I was one of those, yet you still read me as scum. Wut?

[Keyser Söze]

First things first, the Firestarter hammer: DG's hammer post does feel fueled by righteous anger. Unfortunately it's the lynch we secretly wanted ever since D1, so it's hard to judge DG for actually pulling the trigger.

uhh who is the "we"

??

"we" - everyone who wanted Firestarters to reap what they sowed and be held accountable.

Theres plenty of logical reasons that could explain why scum would take the risk


theres literally no pro-town motivation for doing it. At all.

Why ask "we" when you yourself wanted Firestarters to be judged D1?

[Keyser Söze]

First things first, the Firestarter hammer: DG's hammer post does feel fueled by righteous anger. Unfortunately it's the lynch we secretly wanted ever since D1, so it's hard to judge DG for actually pulling the trigger.

uhh who is the "we"

??

"we" - everyone who wanted Firestarters to reap what they sowed and be held accountable.

Hey, I was one of those, yet you still read me as scum. Wut?

You're one of my top two town reads.

[Joan of Arc]

Oh?

Also.... PP was a weird NK.
We're forced to look at his ISO here. If I'm to take tentative scrutiny of his reads, the following players look retrospectively marginally good:

"I think I like

Shadowless

..."
"

Fakesnek

is prob!town independent of Fire."


These players look marginally bad in hindsight:

"I don't really like

Joan

."
"VOTE:

Mephistophanes

"


Note: this isn't me lining up lynches.. It's looking at all the info in front of us, and putting my personal reads to a side. PP didn't really have any direct/cutting interactions with anyone, so I'm not gonna push hard on these.

[Tsuchinoko]

Lol even Joan is confused by that post

[Tsuchinoko]

Speaking of which
Hi Joan.

[Keyser Söze]

Oh?

Also.... PP was a weird NK.
We're forced to look at his ISO here. If I'm to take tentative scrutiny of his reads, the following players look retrospectively marginally good:

"I think I like

Shadowless

..."
"

Fakesnek

is prob!town independent of Fire."


These players look marginally bad in hindsight:

"I don't really like

Joan

."
"VOTE:

Mephistophanes

"


Note: this isn't me lining up lynches.. It's looking at all the info in front of us,

and putting my personal reads to a side

. PP didn't really have any direct/cutting interactions with anyone, so I'm not gonna push hard on these.

I was 'personally' town reading Joan.

But looking purely at PP's ISO, I picked out 2 names that look good respectively, and 2 names that look bad. As I said, these are only marginally feels, not strong feels.

[Keyser Söze]

Lol even Joan is confused by that post

I think Joan had me confused with someone else

[Mephistophanes 39]

Also.... PP was a weird NK.
We're forced to look at his ISO here. If I'm to take tentative scrutiny of his reads, the following players look retrospectively marginally good:

"I think I like

Shadowless

..."
"

Fakesnek

is prob!town independent of Fire."


These players look marginally bad in hindsight:

"I don't really like

Joan

."
"VOTE:

Mephistophanes

"


Note: this isn't me lining up lynches.. It's looking at all the info in front of us, and putting my personal reads to a side. PP didn't really have any direct/cutting interactions with anyone, so I'm not gonna push hard on these.

First off, why don’t you like Joan and what does your Joan read have to do with us? I think the fact that we have been confirmed to have performed a nullifier on a reckless mislynch would confitown us. However, I find it suspicious that you preface your vote on us with a read on a completely unrelated slot. Unless, you somehow mixed up ours and Joan’s names? Because otherwise, the makes absolutely no sense. Considering the fact that we’re in Mylo, should make you want to seriously think about mislynching us?

I think both your Joan read and vote on us are bad, since I ISO’d Joan last night and I think she’s probably town.

[Tsuchinoko]

And another victim goes to the most confusing post I have ever read

[Mephistophanes 39]

Meditation on Joan - I like where his heart is regarding Fire-slot’s unforgivable D1 actions but he’s gnawing too much on Firebringer’s ankles for my own liking right now (allowing Firebringer-head the easy route of defending himself: ‘it was Enter-head!’).

What?

[Mephistophanes 39]

And another victim goes to the most confusing post I have ever read

He was scum in Starcraft Mafia 1, so I’m looking at his ISO to see how it compares to that game.

Being both confusing and wooden, could possibly be a scumtell for him, based on that.

~N

[Tsuchinoko]

Wat

[Dunnstral]

wooden?

[Tsuchinoko]

No the post is confusing due to the lack of quotes and it just being poorly designed, not because of any of the content.
If you get past all of the blatant formatting issues which makes that post so confusing, it just looks like he thinks PP was shot becuase reads so he’s bringing those up

[Dunnstral]

I don't like how quick Meph is to try to jump on Keyser here, and I'm thinking Keyser is likely town soooo

[Mephistophanes 39]

And another victim goes to the most confusing post I have ever read

He was scum in Starcraft Mafia 1, so I’m looking at his ISO to see how it compares to that game.

Being both confusing and wooden, could possibly be a scumtell for him, based on that.

~N

viewtopic.php?f=3&t=77970&user_select%5B%5D=25845

I had trouble reading his posts in that game as well.

[Dunnstral]

I didn't have trouble reading his post - it did not, in fact, lack quotes, it just didn't use quote tags

Your personal problems with the way he formats his posts are NAI at best, this push is weak and scummy. Does he format posts differently as town/scum or something

[Mephistophanes 39]

I don't like how quick Meph is to try to jump on Keyser here, and I'm thinking Keyser is likely town soooo

I’m not jumping on anyone. He says Joan is bad then votes us, which is a bit strange, don’t you think? I questioning if other people think his posts in both games are similar. I find it easiest to try to sort players I have prior meta with, so I disagree that my posts are a good reason to alignment lock him either way. Read both ISOs on their own merits and make up your mind on that. Alignment reading him, one way or another soley based on my posts, is dumb.

[Mephistophanes 39]

I didn't have trouble reading his post - it did not, in fact, lack quotes, it just didn't use quote tags

Your personal problems with the way he formats his posts are NAI at best, this push is weak and scummy. Does he format posts differently as town/scum or something

Speaking of “jumping”, if anyone is doing that, it’s you. This is the first game since Minuet, you have incorrectly read me. You sr me this fast for entirely NAI reasons is kind of bizarre to me.

[Dunnstral]

He says Joan is bad

No he doesn't

I just told you his post didn't lack quotes

[Tsuchinoko]

I didn't have trouble reading his post - it did not, in fact, lack quotes, it just didn't use quote tags

Your personal problems with the way he formats his posts are NAI at best, this push is weak and scummy. Does he format posts differently as town/scum or something

Speaking of “jumping”, if anyone is doing that, it’s you. This is the first game since Minuet, you have incorrectly read me. You sr me this fast for entirely NAI reasons is kind of bizarre to me.

He’s trying to sort you you don’t need to act like its the end of the world.

[Mephistophanes 39]

I didn't have trouble reading his post - it did not, in fact, lack quotes, it just didn't use quote tags

Your personal problems with the way he formats his posts are NAI at best, this push is weak and scummy. Does he format posts differently as town/scum or something

Speaking of “jumping”, if anyone is doing that, it’s you. This is the first game since Minuet, you have incorrectly read me. You sr me this fast for entirely NAI reasons is kind of bizarre to me.

Where are you getting ANY of this nonsence from? Point me to where I’ve said I have “personal problems” with his “formatting”. Do you have any more fiction you want to add to this?

Because if you’re going to falsely accuse me of something, at least have the decency to quote me on it, than make up stuff I never even said.

[Dunnstral]

Being both confusing and wooden, could possibly be a scumtell for him, based on that.

I had trouble reading his posts in that game as well.

You say you have trouble reading his posts

I don't

Sounds like a personal problem

[Mephistophanes 39]

He says Joan is bad

No he doesn't

I just told you his post didn't lack quotes

"I don't really like

Joan

."
"VOTE:

Mephistophanes

"

When did I say it did? I’m asking why he votes us after negatively commenting on Joan?