Greatest Idea VIII - Game Over

[Elsa Jay]

I coulda used your

intelligence

stupid affection for TRing me

back then.

Fixed that for ya!

Dang. Ya got me.

I still recommend you lynch me instead of dayvig me, but I can't say why.

[Shadowlesscloud]

I'm townreading A50 because of his from-the-start analysis.

786 is a good case against Elsa Jay... so...

VOTE: Elsa Jay

No. Dayvig EJ and lynch this. Preformer is next top scum

VOTE: TemporalLich

@shadow
@vedith
@pintu
How do you read Dave?
@almost why is davesaz a townread?

He hasnt stood out like some others have. Woudl need more content

[Irrelephant11]

I coulda used your

intelligence

stupid affection for TRing me

back then.

Fixed that for ya!

Dang. Ya got me.

I still recommend you lynch me instead of dayvig me, but I can't say why.

Ah, but then you’d know that I’d know that you’d know that I’d know that YOU would put the wine in front of ME

[TemporalLich]

I'm not sure if I have more info to add that won't just get me lynched or NKed.

[Irrelephant11]

I was gonna ask why Irrelephant would counterclaim if he didn’t have the card and then I remembered Lyncher exists.

FWIW I think this clears Alchemist from being a Lyncher
A true Lyncher would remember that the Lynchee is based on the order of the playerlist (one above or one below), so this suggestion that I’m an Elsa Lyncher just wouldn’t happen I don’t think.

Not like a huge deal to figure this out but Alch isn’t a lyncher.

[Irrelephant11]

I'm not sure if I have more info to add that won't just get me lynched or NKed.

Maybe a believable scumcase besides Elsa?

[Performer]

a50 if your stances are still like this when you finish catching up we're gonna have a bad time

A50 & I are very aware that you're good at scum (and I suspect you highly prefer it?)
shotgun reads from you please.

someone wanna explain why elsa

He's surrendering.
But we're mostly waiting on TTTT to see if we rather shoot Elsa lynch someone, or shoot someone and lynch Elsa (most likely the former)

I read giving up as NAI. The counterclaims & interactions were the condemning things for me.
-------

Shadow, if this is your first game, how do you know a50 and are so familiar with other people I talked about? This keeps bothering me.

[Shadowlesscloud]

a50 if your stances are still like this when you finish catching up we're gonna have a bad time

A50 & I are very aware that you're good at scum (and I suspect you highly prefer it?)
shotgun reads from you please.

someone wanna explain why elsa

He's surrendering.
But we're mostly waiting on TTTT to see if we rather shoot Elsa lynch someone, or shoot someone and lynch Elsa (most likely the former)

I read giving up as NAI. The counterclaims & interactions were the condemning things for me.
-------

Shadow, if this is your first game, how do you know a50 and are so familiar with other people I talked about? This keeps bothering me.

I dont know a50, I was asking if others did since they all were greeting him like they were.

And wym?

[Performer]

@micc please replace me.

I'm in the middle of probably accepting a new job and just cannot keep up, it's only going to get worse at the end of the week when I anticipate starting on my two weeks notice.

Wow! Congrats!

Also, my townread on brass was because he mentioned setup b & alien. I also chose alien in setup b , so I based my townread of him on that (his truth tell). However, based on what people have been telling me, other people could've gotten multiple cards so what if they got alien as an option too for setup b? So I put brass back at null/no read.

[Performer]

now I seriously regret discarding the Nurse role

Wouldn't have done us any good if we don't have a Doctor in-play.

I can't tell if this is a joke or not but I really, really doubt Micc would do something as insane as that. That would mean if I chose Nurse, I would just a VT if there's no Doc. Anyway, my point was if I was protective, I'd target you immediately on n1 .

A50 can testify to this, and he knows better than me why scum would leave alive FL of all people AND as an innocent child.

He was scum IC for most of the game. That's until he decided to SR me and solve the game.

You...joke around too much...

[Performer]

And wym?

What is wym?

[Shadowlesscloud]

now I seriously regret discarding the Nurse role

Wouldn't have done us any good if we don't have a Doctor in-play.

I can't tell if this is a joke or not but I really, really doubt Micc would do something as insane as that. That would mean if I chose Nurse, I would just a VT if there's no Doc. Anyway, my point was if I was protective, I'd target you immediately on n1 .

A50 can testify to this, and he knows better than me why scum would leave alive FL of all people AND as an innocent child.

He was scum IC for most of the game. That's until he decided to SR me and solve the game.

You...joke around too much...

You thought Micc woudlnt allow a mafia vigilantee as well and we showed you that was wrong..

You think that if you picked nurse that micc would have forced someone else to pick town and doctor even if they choose other cards? Really?

[Shadowlesscloud]

And wym?

What is wym?

What do you mean with "are so familiar with other people I talked about?"

[Xtoxm]

now I seriously regret discarding the Nurse role

Wouldn't have done us any good if we don't have a Doctor in-play.

I can't tell if this is a joke or not but I really, really doubt Micc would do something as insane as that. That would mean if I chose Nurse, I would just a VT if there's no Doc. Anyway, my point was if I was protective, I'd target you immediately on n1 .

A50 can testify to this, and he knows better than me why scum would leave alive FL of all people AND as an innocent child.

He was scum IC for most of the game. That's until he decided to SR me and solve the game.

You...joke around too much...

Its greatest idea, of course it's possible. I find it hard to believe you don't know what you've signed up for ?

[Shadowlesscloud]

now I seriously regret discarding the Nurse role

Wouldn't have done us any good if we don't have a Doctor in-play.

I can't tell if this is a joke or not but I really, really doubt Micc would do something as insane as that. That would mean if I chose Nurse, I would just a VT if there's no Doc. Anyway, my point was if I was protective, I'd target you immediately on n1 .

A50 can testify to this, and he knows better than me why scum would leave alive FL of all people AND as an innocent child.

He was scum IC for most of the game. That's until he decided to SR me and solve the game.

You...joke around too much...

Its greatest idea, of course it's possible. I find it hard to believe you don't know what you've signed up for ?

Honestly this. Twice now youve doubted the host would allow something when the entire set up is based around its craziness.

[Xtoxm]

Perf the cards are dealt randomly. Anything is possible. Only certain cards are duplicated, it's all in the list micc gave us.

[Performer]

OK, so are waiting

The way things are right now, we have had 33 pgs of content with multiple stances taken.
The downsides are that we've got lurkers like tt, notyour, doubting (can't remember others atm), and 4 claims already (I don't like that so many came out on d1 ).

I want reads from tt, notyour, doubting, GE replacement, & brass replacement.


*I secretly wish Jingle would replace in. We'd break open this setup so fast

[TemporalLich]

]Maybe a believable scumcase besides Elsa?

Sakura's vote without a case (799) just seems OMGUSy.

And davesaz's ISO is completely devoid of info.

[Performer]

@shad I don't expect Micc to be that unreasonable. With that in mind & this being my first greatest idea game, I wouldn't think he'd unreasonably put a Nurse without Doc in the game. The guy moderates newbie queue which is as vanilla as setups go ...

As for other people, I was referring to imp & jingle. Your posts sounded as if you were dishonest and DID know these 3 people: a50/imp/jingle. But w/e, that's a moot point now.

[Xtoxm]

My shotgun reads are town for irre, sakura, shadow, alchemist, 4t.
Scum for Elsa.
That's all ya getting right now.

[Shadowlesscloud]

@shad I don't expect Micc to be that unreasonable. With that in mind & this being my first greatest idea game, I wouldn't think he'd unreasonably put a Nurse without Doc in the game. The guy moderates newbie queue which is as vanilla as setups go ...

As for other people, I was referring to imp & jingle. Your posts sounded as if you were dishonest and DID know these 3 people: a50/imp/jingle. But w/e, that's a moot point now.

ITS RANDOMIZED

HE DIDNT PUT ANYTHING IN HIMSELF

[TemporalLich]

I can also say Performer's ISO is completely devoid of info.

And idk what shotgun reads are.

[Xtoxm]

And, I don't prefer scum. I just have more success as scum than town. Even if I did, I'm aware of the meta from the previous game, that town is more likely to win. At any rate, I was only offered town cards in this setup. My claim should be enough for you to have a fairly solid tr on me.

[Xtoxm]

I can also say Performer's ISO is completely devoid of info.

And idk what shotgun reads are.

Quick fire, unexplained reads, basically.

[Sakura Hana]

Sakura's vote without a case

without a case

Considering you call this a "case":

No need to post anymore but hopefully getting some claims out helped the scum team. See ya later.

I'm astounded!!!! I had you down as a Hider/Commuter trying to bait the NK (see my post quoting posts #63 & #76 which are the card numbers for Hider & Commuter respectively, as well as "something I made you before" referring to the role I gave you in OK 1)

OK.. so EJ was scum and is a safe lynch because he isn't Judas, but I think Day-vigging worls best since we still have the lynch of the day.

My naked vote might as well be one.