Mini Normal 2068: Cat Art! [Game Over]

[Akarin]

Vote Count 1.5

Chezburger Gothic

votes

Creature [3]

: Sheldon Cooper PhD, Shiidaji, Sashaddin

insomnia [2]

: DrDolittle, wilky

wilky [1]

: BrightEyedFish

Shiidaji [1]

: Creature

Sashaddin [1]

: Carmen

Sheldon Cooper PhD [1]

: TTTT

Ankamius [1]

: RadiantCowbells

RadiantCowbells [1]

: Ankamius

Carmen [1]

: Macabre

DrDolittle [1]

: insomnia

Not Voting [0]

:

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch

The Day 1 deadline is in

: (expired on 2019-04-13 12:44:08)

[insomnia]

good morning!

Ankamius we’ll get along just fine

[Ankamius]

UNVOTE: RadiantCowbells

[insomnia]

VOTE: Ankamius

I lied

[TTTT]

Yeah well excuse me for not believing my read when literally everyone town reads my guy, at least I can let townies scum hunt other people. I know it doesn’t make him town but my tunnel was not backed up at all, my reads are rarely followed. Ofc I still scum read BEF but I said I town read him because me pushing someone that is being town read by everyone doesn’t achieve anything. My tunnel would go nowhere.

My instinct says he’s scum but my case on him is from day one and it is probably exaggerated. I don’t have more info that incriminates him yet. I’m not a town leader and so I won’t push and let you all do the job.

I don’t scum hunt first day, things are usually more clear to me day 2 and above, that’s why I doubt my read

It’s not even the fact I’m afraid to be wrong, it’s that people don’t push with me.

this is scum

[Ankamius]

would you like to explain?

[Ankamius]

that was to insomnia sorry

[insomnia]

reasons

[insomnia]

Yeah well excuse me for not believing my read when literally everyone town reads my guy, at least I can let townies scum hunt other people. I know it doesn’t make him town but my tunnel was not backed up at all, my reads are rarely followed. Ofc I still scum read BEF but I said I town read him because me pushing someone that is being town read by everyone doesn’t achieve anything. My tunnel would go nowhere.

My instinct says he’s scum but my case on him is from day one and it is probably exaggerated. I don’t have more info that incriminates him yet. I’m not a town leader and so I won’t push and let you all do the job.

I don’t scum hunt first day, things are usually more clear to me day 2 and above, that’s why I doubt my read

It’s not even the fact I’m afraid to be wrong, it’s that people don’t push with me.

this is scum

vote me then

[Ankamius]

would you like to go into those reasons?

[TTTT]

VOTE: insomnia

[insomnia]

no, if i make scum cases i'm even going to be more suspicious if anything

i've got the whole lobby on me, for context

[TTTT]

sorry insomnia
I'm not buying the nobody listens to me and I don't scumhunt day1 act

[insomnia]

VOTE: insomnia

oh yaes

[insomnia]

it's cool, you'll buy it post-flip. you've genuinely made my reads bad as fuck. you and rc. thanks for undermining my reads

[Ankamius]

well you also just got your scumspect replaced by a player who both has a strong history of reading suspicion against their slot correctly AND is strong at shielding townreads from being lynched

so

[insomnia]

and if you aren't reading it correctly does that mean you're scum? asking for post-flip analysis

[insomnia]

well you also just got your scumspect replaced by a player who both has a strong history of reading suspicion against their slot correctly AND is strong at shielding townreads from being lynched

so

you've also replaced in a slot that rc scum read

you won't get out of this game unlynched xD

[TTTT]

@insomnia
why do you think I voted BEF?
what do you make of the DrDo and Shiid quickly moving votes after that?

[Ankamius]

well you also just got your scumspect replaced by a player who both has a strong history of reading suspicion against their slot correctly AND is strong at shielding townreads from being lynched

so

you've also replaced in a slot that rc scum read

you won't get out of this game unlynched xD

I don't care what RC's read of this slot is atm

I care about the reasoning for yours.

[insomnia]

with that post it somewhat gives me more confidence in drdo/shid/bef team i guess

either that or you and rc saying my case is shit made them move their votes

i'm indecisive in between these two options

[insomnia]

well you also just got your scumspect replaced by a player who both has a strong history of reading suspicion against their slot correctly AND is strong at shielding townreads from being lynched

so

you've also replaced in a slot that rc scum read

you won't get out of this game unlynched xD

I don't care what RC's read of this slot is atm

I care about the reasoning for yours.

i found the rep out odd

her readslist was bad, having me and sash as scums when we were the ones heavily suspected, although she didn't give any opinion or try to engage with any of us

little stuff like that

[Ankamius]

quick peek @ MJL's history she hasn't played in any games with factional daytalk yet that I can see. after my 514 I was waiting for her to ask about it similar to how she asked about insomnia being unlynchable.

since the ruleset here is pretty curt about it and doesn't explain the meaning it makes me feel that she could be scum that's already aware of it in the first place and glanced over it. Ya'll know her better lmk if you think it's indicative.

In all of the newbie games, scum have factional daychat. I did play scum once, so I had factional daychat one time.

What was I supposed to ask about in your post 514?

solely from this alone, it's obvious that MaryJoLisa is a very new player, at least relative to the rest of the playerlist.

do you think that's more indicative of newbscum than newbtown?

[insomnia]

Spoiler:

<3 RC

sheep

i can go into self-meta as well but i don't find that to be necessary right now. mjl, wanna sheep my vote? how do you see my analysis on bef?

if you sheep me i promise you that i'll defend you even if you're scum, i need votes, nobody is voting with me

Can you summarize your case on BEF because all i've got so far is that he sees merit in scum hunting in RVS and you do not. What's the case against fish?

misrep of my case

MJL is town, I think?

the case on BEF is awful.

I agree. I'm not seeing a case on BEF.

Sorry insomnia, if i'm sheeping anyone this game, it's going to be RC or TTTT in that order.

sheeping again, misreping again

bef wagon seems rly dumb to me

Why is it dumb from your POV?

looks like she's trying to sort rc when she stated she'll sheep rc, therefore she town reads him. no need for sorting. tries to look like she's game solving / engaging in "productive" conversations.

This is a tough one for me because I’m in an unfamiliar environment going up against a bunch of new faces in a blind setup and I don’t know the extent of what’s possible. What I think I understand is that there are 3 scum and 10 townies and I have no idea what PRs are in play. And that’s not a PR fish, for the record. It’s just a statement to give you guys some idea of where I am in terms of my own comprehension of the game.

Additionally, some of you are playing on alts, but more confusingly is that some of you are lying about some seemingly innocuous information about your personas. The first question I’m asking myself is “who is lying about who they are?” I don’t know the culture around here well enough, but I might accidentally scum read someone because they're trying to lie about their RL personas or circumstances to conceal their alt rather than their alignment.

Full disclosure:

If I think you’re on an alt and I decide that you’re trying to hide your main, one will be assigned to you and I will hold you fully responsible for that other person’s meta good or bad. (This might actually carry some weight to it if I knew who any of you were.)

In order to expedite my sorting process, if your name is @RadiantCowbells, would you please level with me and tell me if you’re town or scum? I’m not looking for any power roles or anything. Just a simple “town,” or “scum” would be perfect. You can put it behind spoilers so it doesn't ruin the game for anyone else. Kthx, much obliged.

Town leans:

TTTT, RadiantCowbells (pending confession), Sheldon Cooper PhD, BrightEyedFish, Dr.Dolittle, Creature

Who even is this??:

Wilky

Maybe a little suspicious:

Carmen, Shiidaji, Macabre

Scum:

insomnia, Sashaddin

her town leans are unjustified, ttt didn't spew himself town at all, he didn't post shit. sheldon as well, he was memeing when this list was up. she read BEF null now she's town leaning him. DrDo was memeing and posting fluff. creature...is creature. i wouldn't give him anything more than a null.

her scum reads as well are yuck.

Part 1:

Town:

RadiantCowbells and Creature. That was the cutest little TvT match I’ve seen since… well since about 48 hours ago! I won’t town read you for this again, RC, so enjoy it while it still feels authentic.

More Town:

TTTT seems like he’s playing his usual game, so nothing suspicious there.

Yeah, I’m going with Town:

Macabre’s posts are either wasted space or voting in ways that I either agree with or can at least make a logical case for.

Null/Town:

Wilky has made 4 posts so far, but their last post seemed townish. Waiting for more content.

Null:

DrDolittle – K, I got a problem here. See the thing is, I agree on the insomnia push on insomnia’s merits alone. But it seems like a possible avenue for scum to take to grab an easy mislynch. I like the insomnia push, I just dislike the confidence in that push. I need to think more about this.

Null:

Carmen – Up from scummy to null. I was expecting this player to following a particular template with their day one votes. They’re off that template, so I’m more or less waiting for more information from them. Last post was on 4/2, so just waiting.

Null:

BrightEyedFish isn’t really doing any game advancing stuff. I recognize that. (more on this in part 2)

Null-to-culturally-offended:

Sheldon Cooper PhD – Upon further investigation, they are in fact RPing the part. Lame. Meemaw is what the character on the TV calls his grandmother. THAT’S A CHEAP SHOT, SHELDON! (I’m not really culturally offended, but I don’t have a read on this player and when in doubt, lean scum).

she null read bef again but she didn't push it and she town read him earlier.

i made this for you ankamius cuz you deserve it, i shouldn't be game solving in this lobby that is trashing my reads mhm

[TTTT]

@RC
updated read on MJL slot please?