Undertale Mafia (Endgame):

[Dannflor]

I disagree. I don't think he's done anything AI for him yet. I think it will be more telling what the first thing in the game is that he chooses to really bite his teeth into.

[nomnomnom]

Hot Lightning votes are better than Vedith votes rnow

I disagree. HL's focus on non-posters comes from town more often than Vedith's bad questions.

I FEEL IT IS HIGHLY HYPOCRITICAL TO BE MINDFUL OF NON POSTERS WHEN YOU HAVEN'T POSTED MUCH YOURSELF.
IT WOULD FEEL LESS AWKWARD IF LIGHTNING FRIEND GAVE THEIR THOUGHTS ON ONGOING EVENTS PRIOR TO SAYING THIS!!!

[RadiantCowbells]

Mercy is currently at 7 .[/color] Undertale Mafia Votecount 1.09: Skygazer (4): Wiisp, Brown Eyes, Shiidaji, Sofa King Game of Throws (2): Skygazer, Team RWBY Hot Lightning (2): Dannflor, nomnomnom Sofa King (1): Hot Lightning Team RWBY (1): Game of Throws Dannflor (1): Vedith Vedith (1): Papyrus Wiisp (0): Shining Dreamers (0): Reasonably Clever (0): Shiidaji (0): Pink Ball (0): Something_Smart (0): NeenieKit (0): nomnomnom (0): Brown Eyes (0): Papyrus (0): Not Voting: Shining Dreamers, Reasonably Clever, Pink Ball, Something_Smart, NeenieKit With 17 alive it's 9 to lynch. The day ends (expired on 2019-04-21 00:00:00).

[Team RWBY]

Hi! I'm just checking in!

VOTE: Pink Ball

-Blake

[mastina]

Ego to say RC is lazy; didn't get a role PM on my main so it's against the rules for me to play until I log in onto our hydra to retrieve the role there. (Can't play if I don't know our alignment, kinda explicitly against site rules to do that.)

[Vedith]

Hello Mastina \o/

[Dannflor]

Hi! I'm just checking in!

VOTE: Pink Ball

-Blake

Why?

[Team RWBY]

phonepost

ank is trolling, but i want to see PB post

also wisp, why are you just now taking issue with my opening post and not in 136 or 137?

~yang

[Wiisp]

phonepost

ank is trolling, but i want to see PB post

also wisp, why are you just now taking issue with my opening post and not in 136 or 137?

~yang

what?

[Team RWBY]

in post 151 you tear my opening catchup apart in post 122

but you never mentioned the fallacies you found in 136 or 137 when you just clarified that you scumread this hydra at that point

~yang

[Team RWBY]

in post 151 you tear my opening catchup apart in post 122

but you never mentioned the fallacies you found in 136 or 137 when you just clarified that you scumread this hydra at that point

~yang

151 122 136 and 137

I dont like typing post links on phone but here it is for your convenience

[Team RWBY]

/barn Dan
good with votes on any of these 3, Hot, Sky, Rwby

Hot and Sky I don't feel it.
RWBY, I can work with that.

oh and btw we are right here bby

come @ us instead of searching for people who would hop on our wagon with you

~yang

[Vedith]

Nah I'll let others put the work in and just hammer you.

[Wiisp]

The thoughts were always there, I just didnt bring them up, till one of your heads decided my lack of reasoning equal'd that the reasoning didnt exist

[Team RWBY]

oh so you were waiting to find a good time to push the notion that we are scum?

(ie, when i stated my grievances with 136 and 137)

like, what am i to deduce from the above and all of this?
your vote has been the same since 14
even though you are fine with seeing

GoT

die in 136 you're content with pushing us as more like scum (we're also more widely suspected, so thats an easy read to attach to)
and you give 2 other options for votes in 189 aside from

sky

while you keep your vote on the highest number wagon

one of the few notable townleans you have is

brown

, someone who has agreed with and supported your opinions in the game and you havent even directly responded to them. 138

none of this looks like a thought process geared to gamesolving and looking beyond surface-level ideas to focus on.

even if you think this slot is scum, why not entertain my thoughts or resolve them? you have yet to do that before you ever stated a read on the slot

also, i dont think i ever stated your said doesnt exist, it just wasnt clarified, and reasoning on what again? this is what i mean about clarity.

lets not continue with walls, thatll make this more frustrating and incomprehensible than it already is

im done with thread for now, this game is either too easy or town is shooting at itself

~yang

[Team RWBY]

I agree with Papyrus that this sounds a bit more like scum vedith, but I'm not certain on that yet. A bit jarring that I'm not mindmelding with Dann on slots like Vedith yet though so... *shrug* I'll get breakfast and think about it some more later.

@Wiisp, your thing about adverbs is more a style choice. Saying "probably" all the time is a way to hedge your reads. You can accuse me of overconfidence if you like

-WS

[Wiisp]

@Yang
so do you think I am scum? cause it's getting to the point where I am not very fond of told my thought process is not geared towards game solving.
I am a very surface level game solver

"like, what am i to deduce from the above and all of this?" idk you tell me, you have done naught to help your hybrid slot so far
my vote has been the same, and ive stated several times why, try again
I was ok with either of you dying for the sake of seeing a hybrid account
so you are going to argue that you are an easy read to attach to, that's like playing bad, and then arguing that it makes you towny and me scummy for pushing on it, it says nothing about your alignment
and I've stated my reasons, you have yet to call them anything but a surface level

what did #138 have to do with me, do I need to respond to every post?
I entertain everyone's thoughts, including my scum leans, and you have yet to give entertain me with thoughts that I can work with

[Wiisp]

I agree with Papyrus that this sounds a bit more like scum vedith, but I'm not certain on that yet. A bit jarring that I'm not mindmelding with Dann on slots like Vedith yet though so... *shrug* I'll get breakfast and think about it some more later.

@Wiisp, your thing about adverbs is more a style choice. Saying "probably" all the time is a way to hedge your reads. You can accuse me of overconfidence if you like

-WS

there are town ways to hedge and scum ways to hedge, as the uninformed majority, there's nothing wrong with confusion, or being little lost
let's agree to disagree that, "Is town" and "is probably town", are just style choice, this early in the game

also how am I suppose to agree or disagree with meta reads in my first game on this site, they are just obnoxious
I gave you my reasons why I think vedith is town, none because of meta, so why are you unsure about vedith, thats not meta?

[Wiisp]

lets not continue with walls, thatll make this more frustrating and incomprehensible than it already is

anyways I agree i want to hear from the 1-posters

[Team RWBY]

That's a good question. You could try reading Vediith's first 10 posts in anime upick and his first ten posts in merchant's ball round 2 and decide which he sounds more like (try not to read his flip before saying which you think he is more like). Since we're just talking a tone meta read from day 1 that should be enough for you to engage on meta points there.

Sorry, usually try not to make meta arguments so early. The reason I'm uncertain is that my first game with town vedith was mastina's dance game, but I have since decided that's just not representative of his townplay generally. You could read his first few posts there too if you want to understand why I second guess myself on Vedith a lot.

-WS

[Vedith]

I'm killing you tonight.

[Team RWBY]

[Hot Lightning]

The vote seemed fine to me.

I didn't like the suggestion to waste a cop confirming a miller.

Not sure why you find problem with this.

-m

[Hot Lightning]

VOTE: GoT

yay I have a lotta town reads

Is this a random vote? Multiple people are jumping on GoT on the first 2 pages, but I don't understand why. They had 1 post that was a gif.

-m

[Hot Lightning]

Welcome to the world of Nancy posting!

In Story Revisited he had a 1-shot parity cop gated behind a role whose only job was to enable the parity cop.

So I wouldn't say he goes really heavy on early cop actions as a rule, but we have no way of knowing the overall power level of the game this time.

In other news, what did you think of 12, Cerb?

-Weiss

The conclusion of "early miller claim is likely town" is reasonable enough? I don't agree with it in any role madness/theme type game. but the basic theory is sound. The mechanical observation that a miller claim being true is more likely than not is a fairly obvious one to make. I appreciate that they were the first person to actually respond to what was probably the most significant thing stated that far, but the actual content was underwhelming.

I...don't think I've played with skygazer enough to say if they're someone who tends to state the obvious. Anyone who knows her should weigh in on that.

@miller claim, whoever you were: elaborate on your millerness, is it just cop checks, do you get tracked to the kill, if there's some other thing to check to be determined effectively guilty(say a gunsmith type role) do you show as guilty to that too, etc.

-Cerb

Pedit:

"...miller claim being true is more likely than not if a cop exists..."

-Cerb

Disagree. How would a Miller know there's a cop before claiming? Obviously, optimal play for a Miller is to claim straight away. They'd have no knowledge of cops at that time.

-m