Undertale Mafia (Endgame):

[Team RWBY]

Can we end this conversation please

-Blake

sure, quite sure that slot is still scum though
And I'll apologize to you if my post came off as an attack

I wasn't offended dw

-Blake

[Vedith]

Ignoring the fact that she said Vedith twice, the read itself is kinda weird and strikes me as the "odd one out" of all those town reads. If Sky flips scum then Vedith is a very likely partner, especially with Vedith randomly throwing Sky into his list of "no lynches."

Did you get scum?

[Dannflor]

I don't think so

[Vedith]

VEDITH!! \o/

PB \o/

[Vedith]

I don't think so

Then stop acting like you did.

[Reasonably Clever]

You right, they aren't significant and can't be proven in the slightest, so that to me is just shade on my slight. Is it wrong for me to assume based on what I'm seeing this game, that maybe they aren't competent? I'd say yes and no, because attacking the player, is wrong, but Im not attacking the player, I'm attacking their thought process which is on the same level of attacking their play, which is allowed and no where near close to ignorance

Allowed, yes obviously but accurate, not really. Especially considering D1 lynches are more often than not mislynches, for precisely the reasons Ank stated.

[Dannflor]

I don't think so

Then stop acting like you did.

Sure thing boss

[Papyrus]

I don't like all this talk about lynching town. Anything less than a lynch on scum is a failure on D1.

[Reasonably Clever]

Scum have fakeclaims and while it is unlikely for nom to be faking the post restriction I still wouldn't imply the slot is "basically conftown" albeit that slot still isn't really in my lynchpool for today.

I think the last two pages is more based on Cerb expecting Blake to come out with some tryhard gamesolve posts on day 1 just because she usually does on later days in other games. Wiisp took Blake saying she wasn't going to rush an unreliable solve as an indication she wasn't going to try at all with 950, which let's be clear, is a very pretentious post that reads awful lol. But yeah it wasn't a personal insult to Blake.

-ws

Not you too, Krazy. How can you guys not be able to tell my posts apart from Cerb’s yet?

He signs EVERYTHING.

[Papyrus]

This game feels mostly solved at this point. I'm guessing three to four scum in Sky, Wiisp, Vedith, Shidaji, SS, & Hot.

[Reasonably Clever]

I don't like all this talk about lynching town. Anything less than a lynch on scum is a failure on D1.

+1

I learned from RC in DnD game, how town tends to want to lynch the lhf in general then the less obvious scum. I kind of disagree with Cerb that I still think Wiisp is town. His frustration reads genuine to me. I think that he just relies on too many generalities.

[Reasonably Clever]

This game feels mostly solved at this point. I'm guessing three to four scum in Sky, Wiisp, Vedith, Shidaji, SS, & Hot.

What is your case on Vedith? He’s still a nullread for me.

[Papyrus]

I think everyone in this game is severely underestimating what Wiisp is capable of as scum. He reminds me of someone like Flavor Leaf, who spams the thread a lot to the point where you eventually townread something he says but none of it's actually town when you look closer. I'm okay putting him aside for the moment but I disagree with everyone who townreads him.

[Something_Smart]

I think it's a PoE, I doubt anyone scumreads me on what I HAVE said.

(And it's an alarmingly large one at this point.)

[Papyrus]

I don't know how to read Vedith.

[Reasonably Clever]

This game feels mostly solved at this point. I'm guessing three to four scum in Sky, Wiisp, Vedith, Shidaji, SS, & Hot.

What gives you that degree of certainty?

Elaborate on the last four(mainly because I haven't paid all that much attention to them).

I don't like all this talk about lynching town. Anything less than a lynch on scum is a failure on D1.

+1

I learned from RC in DnD game, how town tends to want to lynch the lhf in general then the less obvious scum. I kind of disagree with Cerb that I still think Wiisp is town. His frustration reads genuine to me. I think that he just relies on too many generalities.

Tsk tsk my other head, I'll have you know that I haven't actually expressed a read on a single slot yet in this game(and this is for the entire playerlist, but I'm likely just going to 100% sheep Nancyheads reads on D1 barring some ridiculous scumslip/obvtowning). Wiisp just asked me what I could take away from that post, and there's essentially no possible town spin to it, but there are possible scum spins...but it's all very weak, too weak to draw conclusions from.

-Cerb

[Something_Smart]

I've never played with scum-Vedith but I think town-Vedith has the pretty common towntells of read flipping and lack of a consistent agenda. I'm recalling one time where I correctly read him after much agonizing as the deciding vote in LYLO and that was part of it.

[Dannflor]

I think it's a PoE, I doubt anyone scumreads me on what I HAVE said.

(And it's an alarmingly large one at this point.)

I think it's more what you haven't said.

I understand you're a slow player but you had a fair amount of interaction with Wiisp, thoughts on that slot?

[Reasonably Clever]

This game feels mostly solved at this point. I'm guessing three to four scum in Sky, Wiisp, Vedith, Shidaji, SS, & Hot.

I don't know how to read Vedith.

The fuck?

If I were a voting man, I would think about voting you for this.

It feels like, as SS said, this must be like 90% based off PoE.

If that's the case, I think you really need to give compelling reasons for townreading the rest of the game, since your'e basically saying there is at most 2 scum in the other 11 slots.

-Cerb

[Papyrus]

I've never played with scum-Vedith but I think town-Vedith has the pretty common towntells of read flipping and lack of a consistent agenda. I'm recalling one time where I correctly read him after much agonizing as the deciding vote in LYLO and that was part of it.

Yes, I agree 100% that when Vedith's town I usually get to townreading him based on how he changes his reads. I didn't want to say that openly for obvious reasons but now that you've said it I guess it's out there. Town Vedith has these incredibly clear & towny trajectories in how his reads develop but I haven't seen those in this game yet.

[Reasonably Clever]

I think everyone in this game is severely underestimating what Wiisp is capable of as scum. He reminds me of someone like Flavor Leaf, who spams the thread a lot to the point where you eventually townread something he says but none of it's actually town when you look closer. I'm okay putting him aside for the moment but I disagree with everyone who townreads him.

Well his scumread on Brown was really wtf. I really really dislike his playstyle but that doesn’t make it necessarily scummy. Gun to head, I still lean bad town.

[Something_Smart]

I think it's a PoE, I doubt anyone scumreads me on what I HAVE said.

(And it's an alarmingly large one at this point.)

I think it's more what you haven't said.

I understand you're a slow player but you had a fair amount of interaction with Wiisp, thoughts on that slot?

Well yeah that's the whole point, I'm assuming the scumreads on me are based on the fact that I've done virtually nothing.

I don't really think my interaction with Wiisp was indicative of her alignment, unfortunately, it was more of a theory disagreement. Wiisp seems like the type of player that you need experience with to read with any accuracy.

[Papyrus]

Well his scumread on Brown was really wtf. I really really dislike his playstyle but that doesn’t make it necessarily scummy. Gun to head, I still lean bad town.

Why are you assuming bad town instead of scum?

[Reasonably Clever]

This game feels mostly solved at this point. I'm guessing three to four scum in Sky, Wiisp, Vedith, Shidaji, SS, & Hot.

What gives you that degree of certainty?

Elaborate on the last four(mainly because I haven't paid all that much attention to them).

I don't like all this talk about lynching town. Anything less than a lynch on scum is a failure on D1.

+1

I learned from RC in DnD game, how town tends to want to lynch the lhf in general then the less obvious scum. I kind of disagree with Cerb that I still think Wiisp is town. His frustration reads genuine to me. I think that he just relies on too many generalities.

Tsk tsk my other head, I'll have you know that I haven't actually expressed a read on a single slot yet in this game(and this is for the entire playerlist, but

I'm likely just going to 100% sheep Nancyheads reads on D1

barring some ridiculous scumslip/obvtowning). Wiisp just asked me what I could take away from that post, and there's essentially no possible town spin to it, but there are possible scum spins...but it's all very weak, too weak to draw conclusions from.

-Cerb

Nooo, don’t sheep my reads rn. I have no idea who to vote for yet.

But if there is some obvious scumslip, I’ll be very likely to catch it. I’m really good at that.

[Vedith]

This game feels mostly solved at this point. I'm guessing three to four scum in Sky, Wiisp, Vedith, Shidaji, SS, & Hot.

4 of those names are most likely town.
Don't feel too embarrassed though.