large normal 219: COOL NEW ANIMALS (done!!)

[Saudade]

Because there are a lot of players and I cant pay attention to them all

[Saudade]

Shame you named two players that I like =[

[Nero Cain]

y do you like them?

[Saudade]

unvoting you might have been a mistake

[Saudade]

BoB is mega cool and the other guy was assigned the town role in my memory

[Nero Cain]

unvoting you might have been a mistake

Are you really that surprised that 2 ppl that I was already calling scum I still think are scum?

[KidAmn]

That is an unheard of level of consistency for you to be fair /s

[Nero Cain]

That is an unheard of level of consistency for you to be fair /s

IKR!


Performer
TheWizard
bob3141
Sickofit1138
EeveeLution Army

is kinda where I'm leaning.

VOTE: EeveeLution Army

[bob3141]

Do y'all care to unpack your reasons

why you're voting her?

I feel like if it's an infowagon, there are better ones, but that may be just me

it's my RVS

, what are these better info wagons?

I mean, I'm quoting the question that I was being asked in the post that I'm responding to so I felt it was pretty obvious.

And I also felt like 155 was pretty obvious. I'm not certain that I believe that you honestly missed these posts although scum that knew why I was voting nom and intentionally ignoring 143 and 155 faces considerable backlash and that might not be a thing scum does. Am I just over thinking this?

Who is scum, Bob?

Dont forget I've only just started playing mafia on this site 5 days ago. So i think i can be forgiven for only just noticing that when you make quote it references the forum post it was from. You can imagine it migth be bit hard to find what your quote "my RVS" was refering too

Added to that i made all my posts as i read through the thread so hadnt got past page 3 at that point

What I dont get is why you did quote the hole of post 143.



(Will answer teh second bit in seperate post)

[Nero Cain]

What I dont get is why you did quote the hole of post 143.

b/c I didn't think it mattered.

"it's my RVS" was the relative portion of the post that answers your question/proves you wrong.

"what are these better info wagons?" had nothing to do with what you asked and was directed @ sickofit.

I don't really understand why you care if I quoted the whole post.

What is your mafia experience?

[bob3141]

The only real town fleeing I have is I feel that nom is town just due to how she went about defending axe when he was being pressured. It wasn’t like a scum trying to defend there scum partner but an absolute insistence that axe was town and that she would never consider voting for axe. So she must know something.

I just can't see scum doing something so blatant. So i am leaning towards both axe and nom being town.

[bob3141]

What I dont get is why you did quote the hole of post 143.

b/c I didn't think it mattered.

"it's my RVS" was the relative portion of the post that answers your question/proves you wrong.

"what are these better info wagons?" had nothing to do with what you asked and was directed @ sickofit.

I don't really understand why you care if I quoted the whole post.

What is your mafia experience?

about 8 games or so. one or two years ago. Some who played mafia games introduced them to a browser game with a small population (50 or so) and 15 or so of us played mafia games there for bit before people started to quit due to teh mismatch between teh pace differnt players played at. Some 1-2 posts a week and soem 10 a day

[Nero Cain]

yeah, it's kinda obvious. Its rare but scum have fakeclaimed masons b4.

[bob3141]

That experince is why the few players that are lurkign are makign me uneasy. The games often resulted in a lurkign slugfest with 1/2 that were active either turnign on teh lurkers and them turnign out town or turnign on each other and it would turn out soem of the lurkers were mafia.

[Nero Cain]

that's p much what goes on here too. Scum are usually lurkers but the catch is that not all lurkers are scum and active scum can and will push lurkers.

let's talk about your scum reads.

[NotAnAxehole]

yeah, it's kinda obvious. Its rare but scum have fakeclaimed masons b4.

Uhmm did I miss something? Who claimed Mason?

Also, funny story, we claimed masons d1 in my last scum victory

[NotAnAxehole]

Also, Nero trying to pocket Bob is really weird if he's town... Hrmm

[bob3141]

No major scum feeling at the moment but that's mostly because i keep feeling uneasy about the lurkers and really want to hear more from them before deciding. I keep remembering in those last games i played where we lynched the active players and days end up dragging out to 30 plus days

Of those lurker can I can get bit of judge on (below)

I'm not liking the wizards roleblocker role claim. Can't tell from the stage in the game if the person was actually being serious. I can't think why a townie would rolecliam so early and unforced at that.

And then in post 167 it seems he just did a reactionary vote. Only 30 min after Axe’s post. I can't see him as town at the moment as i can't imagine a townie contributing so little yet being aware enough to react to being mentioned in someone’s scum list.
And then nothing until today were he just says something about who believes in lists. I can only assume he is referring to be listed as scum by axe again. Seems again a bit reactionary with no real reason why anyone shouldn’t think he is scum


____


Cant see more than one post of substance were he says he thinks axe is town just because he posts a lot. Which is a bit meaningless as you can encounter mafia players that talk the most. One of my first games the guy who was an experienced player lead the entire town like a shepherd after i got Nk early. He was very critical of us after .

Feels very much like player wanting to be seen but not actually scum hunting. And thus be harder to place or could ultimately a lazy player.

[EeveeLution Army]

it seems to me you scumread wizard

[bob3141]

it seems to me you scumread wizard

This is exactly the sort thing im talking about. Poping up with a superficial comment just to make it look like your are contributing.


P.s. the last bit of my last post was about eve

[nomnomnom]

The only real town fleeing I have is I feel that nom is town just due to how she went about defending axe when he was being pressured. It wasn’t like a scum trying to defend there scum partner but an absolute insistence that axe was town and that she would never consider voting for axe. So she must know something.

Huuuuh no.

Axe is just town, it's fairly obvious.

[rosterfoster]

Why?

Also Nom I thought you gave reasons

[EeveeLution Army]

it seems to me you scumread wizard

This is exactly the sort thing im talking about. Poping up with a superficial comment just to make it look like your are contributing.


P.s. the last bit of my last post was about eve

you gave so much evidence for him being scum but didnt call him scum its just weird is all

[rosterfoster]

VOTE: Eevee

Hey look I have a vote!

[bob3141]

it seems to me you scumread wizard

This is exactly the sort thing im talking about. Poping up with a superficial comment just to make it look like your are contributing.


P.s. the last bit of my last post was about eve

you gave so much evidence for him being scum but didnt call him scum its just weird is all

It was kinda of implied. That i was leaning towards thinking wizard is scum.