In post 46, northsidegal wrote:hardclaim miller. on phone and haven't actually read very closely but i'm pretty sure this confs one scum in miller claims
I liked the nonchalance of this post at the time. There were 5 miller claims at this point which she has missed. There wasn't any kind of opportunism or reaction to this, just a casual claim and the comment that there's one scum in the millers......except via setup there ought to be two.
I liked this at the time. It felt a bit clumsy in a fairly tonally clean way. Hence it was good enough for an early loltownread.
Given that the cop was in the miller claims I don't think that via setup there had to be two scum in the miller claims; if anything 5 miller claims would make me clumsily go "two scum" before realizing that the cop was in the miller pool.
this game will mostly be review from me i think. sorry if that bothers anyone
Haven't meta checked but I don't think scum!nsg actually tends to make these posts :/ she isn't as present as scum as she is as town, but I think it's out of character and unintuitive for her to draw attention to it as a wolf.
I don't think that's necessarily true but I'm not an expert on nsg meta; i feel like a preemptive defense for her different meta could easily be in character for scum her considering I assume she's self-aware of her meta and would probably want to try to counter it.
I haven't really been paying attention to this thread.....
VOTE: ircger
This gave me pause because like. Let's be real. Look at the player list without any actual play taking place; Ircher is uuuusually lynched d1 on this table unless someone goes hard. Either way net doesn't really impact my read[/quote]
hrmmm
tw wrote:
In post 171, northsidegal wrote:for the record i think ircher is probscum but unless i review a bit and it's really slam dunk will most likely still vote in miller claims
I kinda disliked this it just felt kinda opportunistic :/ actually I'd kinda like nsg to revisit her early tells on ircher when she has a sec if she doesn't mind. I forgot to note that down.
I think it's very clear by my posting but my trajectory on nsg has been:
Early townping, overstated read => read softens but net still somewhat towny. In that time I've also reevaluated all of the active slots leaving {nsg, pine} as the two who need reevaluation just on the basis of absence.
I feel like your 'towncase' showcases more things that are scummy about nsg than townie to be honest lol
Actually would argue your push is making her easier to lynch but harder to sort (her flattened tone and lack of motivation for example kinda makes sense from both alignments right now)
She needs to climb out of the hole if she's town and you're standing at the top dropping rocks on her head
In post 975, CheekyTeeky wrote:We're finally getting some content and you look like nom tunnelling town.
We're only getting content because im squeezing it out of her under pressure
I've had pressure on me for three days, you're getting content because I have the motivation to post content right now. I kind of had a big lull in my play lately stemming around from a couple of bad losses and a stronger interest in modding
ircher feels like ircher and i dont see much scum motivation tbh
oka feels like oka and i dont see much scum motivation tbh
pine is pure null
i can def see a lot of potential scum motivation in azor's posting
In post 474, Ircher wrote: but OkaPoka has >rand chance of scum and cop claimed anyway, so does it matter?
I like to think of my vote as a powerful weapon and only use it when I want something. Right now my vote on OkaPoka wouldn't get me what I want, which is more reads from northsidegal.
that's interesting to me. why me in particular? what about pine?
on the subject of lynching millers vs vts given cheeky's claim, given the chance that she's doing the MU thing where you fakeclaim cop as cover i think it still makes sense to lynch in the millers.
In post 489, the worst wrote:not explaining my nsg read is intentional and tactful tho
(just so you know, if you're trying something where you wait to see if i question you for giving me an easy townread, mathdino tried that one and it didn't work. i guess i'm interested in your reasoning but i usually don't think townreads on me are unwarranted because i usually feel like i've towntold.)
as far as i can see this is like the only interaction nsg has had with azor and i don't see any reads on him from her
azor -> nsg interactions could be early distancing, i see that a lot from scum
i'm like, not as sold on azor scum as i am nsg scum bc pine is very null and ircher/oka give me scummy vibes but they both give me scummy vibes by default, i just don't see how either (especially oka) would be posting like they're posting with a scum win condition in mind, neither really changed their behavior under pressure which means they care about the pressure less
but OkaPoka has >rand chance of scum and cop claimed anyway, so does it matter?