Role Call I (Game Over)

[Almost50]

Oh jesus. I thought my modifier was unique. Carry on. I'm so embarassed.

Who told you? I don't suppose you "suddenly" decided to look at the OP at this point, so "someone somewhere" must've pointed it out for you.

[Almost50]

wait gross now it's a townslip not a scumclaim

I wanted free d1 scum

No it's not. It's a slip alright, but still scum indicative.

[Gamma Emerald]

Oh jesus. I thought my modifier was unique. Carry on. I'm so embarassed.

Actually this is a town post. Scum practically always have the teams' roles posted in the PT. So no way they don't realize their roles aren't unique.

[popsofctown]

Oh jesus. I thought my modifier was unique. Carry on. I'm so embarassed.

Who told you? I don't suppose you "suddenly" decided to look at the OP at this point, so "someone somewhere" must've pointed it out for you.

It largely depends on whether you see town!apthet visiting the OP in reaction to post 999.

I bought that but I see less than 100% equity in that and some equity in her figuring it out the other way.

[popsofctown]

I often don't see the role pms posted in the OP. This setup subverts the point of the feature so it's quite possible CJF did not post the (duplicate) role PMs into the PT

[apthet]

It was because of that "bastard mod" comment actually. I don't want to talk about it. I feel so stupid I could cry :,(

[Gamma Emerald]

I often don't see the role pms posted in the OP. This setup subverts the point of the feature so it's quite possible CJF did not post the (duplicate) role PMs into the PT

Hmm didn't think of that. Still, how do scum let that happen?

[apthet]

the first thing I did was think "what role would my original role synergize with the most" and I think that anyone who isn't vanilla would also think of that)

The original softclaim, by the way.

[Oversoul]

It was because of that "bastard mod" comment actually. I don't want to talk about it. I feel so stupid I could cry :,(

I didn’t mean to make you cry Apthet. I’m sorry if I did.

[Almost50]

I feel so stupid I could cry :,(

Don't. I know someone in this game who never reads the OP too. Oh, I'll stop at that so it won't become personal. Just remember that

not reading the game mechanics makes you feel bad and look stupid

in the future.

[Titus]

Agency captured can town, sure, so I'm more suspicious of your progression on me. Not sure why town!Titus is giving me credit for an a50 stance I haven't taken and not sure I'd buy the shift even if I had actually done so.

I thought it was you who said A50 might be scum. Ugh.

[Titus]

I feel so stupid I could cry :,(

Don't. I know someone in this game who never reads the OP too. Oh, I'll stop at that so it won't become personal. Just remember that

not reading the game mechanics makes you feel bad and look stupid

in the future.

Oh wow A50 does nothing but attack people for misreading mechanics. However he treats A different than me. Wonder why that is? Oh wait, I am calling A50 scum and highlighting active lurking.

[Oversoul]

If it makes you feel any better you should look up Bumi and Homestuck mafia. I accidentally faked a guilty on a town PR and got them lynched. It was v tragic

[Titus]

A50, who is scum? Who is town? Talk about something other than mechanics.

[Titus]

If it makes you feel any better you should look up Bumi and Homestuck mafia. I accidentally faked a guilty on a town PR and got them lynched. It was v tragic

We all have bad games. Sucks.

Doesn't mean A is town because she asked for a pity party.

Even if you disagree, can we play mafia now?

[popsofctown]

None of Titus's read progression seems authentic. She's as of now suspicious of both a50 and apthet even though those slots are very much in opposition to eachother. I don't know what HH or Vecna see in this slot.

[Almost50]

I feel so stupid I could cry :,(

Don't. I know someone in this game who never reads the OP too. Oh, I'll stop at that so it won't become personal. Just remember that

not reading the game mechanics makes you feel bad and look stupid

in the future.

Oh wow A50 does nothing but attack people for misreading mechanics. However he treats A different than me. Wonder why that is? Oh wait, I am calling A50 scum and highlighting active lurking.

I dropped your name out

so as not to make it personal

, yet you're insisting that I should be calling you out.

This is the first time I play apthet, so it's not like I see her doing this "I don't read the OP, I don't read upon replacement, I am sick, I am drunk .. etc" all the time. Someone else does all that periodically, and it makes me feel they have no respect for the players in the game (and since I am a player in the game

I am

taking it as a personal insult everytime you say one of those things).

[Almost50]

A50, who is scum? Who is town? Talk about something other than mechanics.

I'll only respond to someone who treats me with respect, not be drunk everytime they talk to me.

[popsofctown]

A50, who is scum? Who is town?

[callforjudgement]

Just a reminder: feel free to criticise/attack people's actions, but try to steer clear of attacking the person in their own right. (Note that I post these reminders when I think a line might be crossed in the near future, they don't necessarily indicate that a line has been crossed yet.)

[Almost50]

A50, who is scum? Who is town?

I am not sure who scum is. I am suspicious of apthet still, but I can see it being poor town play.
I am most suspicious of the HH hydra (but again; what's new? I can't remember the last time I TR'd Maria playing under ANY of her alts).
I am not liking Titus, but I sometimes get some town pings from her .. err.. hard-headed reads and opinions.

I am most confident in momo, Oversoul, Iconeum, Vecna, you (pops) all being town, and I have a moderate town read on Gamma, Cheeky, LUV & Nero.

This limits my D1 lynch pool to just Titus, Apthet, HH or Saudade.

[popsofctown]

I have this weird feeling the game is probably 1 deepwolf 2 obvscum, because otherwise the proposals would have either butterglided or hardbounced.

Am I crazy?

[Almost50]

No, you're not. It could very well be the case. I don't even know what scum would do here though. Like, if you were scum, what would you be fighting for? Would you be content lynching one of your own? Would you be content NOT lynching one of your own? Would you go for certain roles?

At the start of the game I made a list I keep referring to every now and then:

Scum will give to Town:

Compulsive Quitter:
Timid: Banned from proposals
Night 1 Universal Backup:
Inactive (Passive): For the rest of the game, proposals that give you a Day or Night action are invalid.
Vanilla:

Scum will give to Scum:

Day 3 King: Only D3 proposal is yours
Inventor (Night): 4 Nights of 1-shot
Bodygaued/Friendly Neighbour (Scum Visitor)/Activated Hero (switches Quitter with who proposed it to you)/Announcing Mailman (Messenger)

Scum will give one to each:

Neighbour:
Neighbour:

No Idea

1-shot Gladiator (Day): when no proposal is being voted on, ("Challenge: player"). All proposals that day are invalid unless they give the Compulsive Quitter role either to you, or to the player you challenged.
Day 5 Innocent Child (Passive): If you are Town-aligned
Macho:
Miller: Appear scum regardless of alignment
Odd-Night Motion Detector:

As such, I already have 3 roles that I think scum would give to scum (King, Inventor & 1 Neighbor). If I apply my theory in a vacuum (i.e. not including my reads), Oversoul should be clear based on his draft. If momo is scum then you and Vecna are his likely partners based on his preliminary proposal, but we can switch Vecna with Icon based on his second draft (less significant).

Applying the same to Vecna's proposal he gave Inventor to Icon, gave King to momo and out you in the Neighborhood.

Then YOU proposed (momo+Vecna+pops have proposed so far) and you gave momo King and yourself Inventorm and while Vecna is a UB that could easily be remedied by shooting one of the Neighbors on N1. You were the only one to give Iconeum a useless role (Timid). If you didn't I would have suggested the scum team to be of FOUR members.

But that all goes against what I see from your posting (all 3 of you). If the team is literally pops+Vecna+momo I'd tip my hat to all 3 of you and I'd concede right now.

[popsofctown]

Would you be content NOT lynching one of your own?

Yes especially if you are a flying black dragon

[popsofctown]

I'm criticizing iconeum for its action of lolwhatever approving proposal1 with no critical thinking not criticizing it for being a black dragon that is ok I won a prerelease with Skithryx the Blight Dragon once it was very strong please don't modkill me callforjudgment