Mini 2084: Pokemon Ruby Mafia - Game Over

[Elements]

the solve doesn’t seem great? Like I thought there would be a lot more

A solve to me means "x, y, z are mafia and here's why..." Not "I think these people are town"

[Menalque]

A solve to me would be a reasoned explanation with evidence for why every player is the alignment you think they are

Unless it’s already clear with multiple cases on people that don’t need re-explaining on which case I think it should just include the others

[Menalque]

in which case*

[EspressoPatronum]

HOW DO WE SOLVE THIS GAME?

That should have been bigger tbh

Is anyone online?

no

We can start by lynching the person who won't contribute anything tomorrow. He also happens to be scummy.

[Menalque]

I could lynch chem

But I want gamma

Partly because I’m lazy and I have ideas on the implications of scum!gamma and town!gamma

I don’t really know what town!chem or scum!chem would mean

Partly because of everything I’ve pointed out about gamma

[Menalque]

If chem gets to L-1 I would hammer tho

[EspressoPatronum]

You can sell us on chemist if you want

I'm not sure how to read chemist. He just wagon hops to whatever lynch the townleader wants. He did it to tim day1 and he did it to me day2 and it made me townread him.

Have you developed more of a read on Chemist since then? What is your opinion on the ellitell?

Because I don't get your creature read even using your own standards.
...

Vote Pine

Pine is just scum.

Pine is calling creature town because he's scum who knows creature is town or they are buddies and right now I'm leaning towards the former.

I could see this. I'll join you in a Pine push tomorrow if you join me on Chemist today.

[EspressoPatronum]

I could lynch chem

But I want gamma

Partly because I’m lazy and I have ideas on the implications of scum!gamma and town!gamma
...
Partly because of everything I’ve pointed out about gamma

You've raised some good points on Gamma so far, but I think you're overlooking his towny reactions to being pushed twice. Aside from the PB argument, he was pretty calm through the whole thing. He also actively contributed to scum hunting even when it looked like he was going to get lynched.

Compare that to Chemist, who's gone full troll mode in response to his push.

The difference is night and day.

[Gamma Emerald]

the solve doesn’t seem great? Like I thought there would be a lot more

A solve to me means "x, y, z are mafia and here's why..." Not "I think these people are town"

A solve to me would be a reasoned explanation with evidence for why every player is the alignment you think they are

Unless it’s already clear with multiple cases on people that don’t need re-explaining on which case I think it should just include the others

What's wrong with PoE solving, and also I just said I was perfectly fine explaining my reads.
EP I'll expand on later but I've read his past games and he feels consistent with them, as well as showing some behaviors I'd expect from newb!town in general. Creature and Pine I have talked on a little, unfortunately I won't be give a specific analysis of which posts I like from Creature but if you really care I'm certain you can find them.

[RedPanda]

You can sell us on chemist if you want

I'm not sure how to read chemist. He just wagon hops to whatever lynch the townleader wants. He did it to tim day1 and he did it to me day2 and it made me townread him.

Have you developed more of a read on Chemist since then? What is your opinion on the ellitell?

Because I don't get your creature read even using your own standards.
...

Vote Pine

Pine is just scum.

Pine is calling creature town because he's scum who knows creature is town or they are buddies and right now I'm leaning towards the former.

I could see this. I'll join you in a Pine push tomorrow if you join me on Chemist today.

not at all. I think it could be used against worst players.

I can join you on chemist but my vote would be just policy.

[Chemist1422]

HOW DO WE SOLVE THIS GAME?

That should have been bigger tbh

Is anyone online?

no

We can start by lynching the person who won't contribute anything tomorrow. He also happens to be scummy.

or maybe

I actually could not be online after that point

[Creature]

ffs I just want to lynch scum today

[Creature]

I'm more confident on Pine being scum.

[Gamma Emerald]

I'm more confident on Pine being scum.

I just don't understand why he posts some things as scum, they make him look so bad

[Creature]

I keep flipflopping hard on players

[Creature]

Like, I think you're town but everybody keeps thinking you're scum.

[Creature]

I think this town lacks balls to vote someone like Menalque

[Gamma Emerald]

Those last 3 posts by Creature are why he is town btw

[Detective Pikachu]

Mena can go, his tunnel has shifted into him using his personality to counterpush everything town is doing. I still think he's town though and I don't want to lynch him just because his play is fostering the apathy killing town rn, but I'm pretty over his gamma tunnel and continued shading of creature

[Creature]

I'm at Pine + Menalque rn

Leaning RedPanda as the third.

[EspressoPatronum]

I would join in a Pine vote today.

I'd like to give Mena some time to get out of the Gamma tunnel.

[Chemist1422]

Those last 3 posts by Creature are why he is town btw

They’re a good summary ye

[Creature]

idk how should I read EP rn :/

[Creature]

If I can get to townread EP, this game is basically a lock if we don't get swayed too much.

[Chemist1422]

If I can get to townread EP, this game is basically a lock if we don't get swayed too much.

What