the thread title sucked the whole game

[Skygazer]

pagebottom!

[Skygazer]

fuck almost had it

[the worst]

osuka given reaction to emps there what's your read on Gamma?

[osuka]

osuka given reaction to emps there what's your read on Gamma?

given whose reaction?

[the worst]

osuka given reaction to emps there what's your read on Gamma?

given whose reaction?

yours

[Blake Belladonna]

tn5421, convince me on the worst?

[tn5421]

tn5421, convince me on the worst?

I'd sooner post my role pm than vote the worst

[Blake Belladonna]

Obviously.

I meant convince me that he's town.

[osuka]

osuka given reaction to emps there what's your read on Gamma?

given whose reaction?

yours

i think gamma can be town for now

[bob3141]

I don't think i've posted too much (if at all.) It's only natural.

So from reading the thread who you vote for now and why?

[bob3141]

they havent come up with many original ideas and are very hesitant to give out reads so far. their tone near the beginning of the game felt weird as well.

now that i type this out i realize ive done some of the same things...

Just for reference who was this in regards too

[osuka]

they havent come up with many original ideas and are very hesitant to give out reads so far. their tone near the beginning of the game felt weird as well.

now that i type this out i realize ive done some of the same things...

Just for reference who was this in regards too

gamma i believe

[bob3141]

At first I was 50/50 on now sky being scum or just making a bad read on worst. With the potential of luring a scum player out when they tried to sheep it. But could sky and bella vote could be a scum attempt to preemptively push a counter wagon against one of the players suspecting one of them of being scum.I do feel that if sky flips scum then bella is highly likely scum as well.

What makes you think that, from the 3 players voting you, those 2 are scum?

I work a lot in conditions and groupings. Such an approach often allows me to narrow down the mafia as it takes account of how one slot alignment would affect the alignment of another.

It's how my reads in my mason game managed to identify all 3 scum. Simply from the wagons that occurred on day 1.


My post was thus portraying the first condition I had decided and that is (below)

If sky flips scum then it's most likely that bella is one of her scum partners.


Now this condition itself does not hold itself any bearing the probable alignment of Sky. As it simply identifies that sky scum flip makes it highly likely that Bella is also scum.


And my reasoning is that bella votes from me just after I had Voted sky. On the pretext of reasoning that was very much a stretch. And in fact absent.

With him voting with one of the players that he placed in his bottom 3. That being garmr, me and worst.
Now could she simply be a fellow towny that is misguided in thinking that me and worst are scum. With her thinking that Worst’s vote is simply a bus. With her think that me and garmr trying to lynch sky, while worst sat on bus bandwagon

Or scum trying preemptively create a counter wagon before a full wagon could form on sky and gain momentum. Thus preventing undue pressure being put on her fellow scum early then they would want.

[bob3141]

Now the big question then is. Is sky scum?

Now my original vote was as much to see who would join it jump onto it. As it was due to a slight suspicion of the stretchiness of skys vote for worst. I was hoping that a mafia might try and sheep it. Like what happened in my last game even if I didn't carry though with pushing the player that did. Due to getting distracted by another player.

Now worst voted for elastic after but I can't really see any scum motivation behind it so feel that gambit was bit of bust, in that regards. I guess lightning never strikes twice.


Now I'm not entirely decided if sky is scum or not. As when it was revealed elastic was sky, natural I could compare this to skys early scum game. There certainly is a certain lack of hammyness. But since I don't have an example of her town game the difference could simply be that she was under a lot of pressure early that game so hammed it up earlier than she normally would have.

[bob3141]

Firebringer I see in your ISO that you have posted very little in regards to actual scum hunting. At most little fluff or small pieces of you defending yourself


You voted for emps at the start of the game with no attached reasoning. Although it was teh first day.

However, what back then made you vote for him and what is your opinion of him now?

Do you still think he is scum and if so why? Or why not?

And is there anyone else/ anyone that you currently think is likely scum?

[schadd_]

fire assassin replaces firebringer

[the worst]

i think gamma can be town for now

talk me thru it?

[the worst]

omg what if like
this game has no player flakes
all the replacements are alts

{tw}
{skyg, ico}
{bob, gamma, emps}
{tn, blake}
{arc, garmr, osuka, fire}

kinda wonder how close this is.

[Fire Assassin]

hello everyone,

I am going to do a read through soon.

[the worst]

hi fireass, been a while

[Garmr]

omg what if like
this game has no player flakes
all the replacements are alts

{tw}
{skyg, ico}
{bob, gamma, emps}
{tn, blake}
{arc, garmr, osuka, fire}

kinda wonder how close this is.

If i'm on your scum list it's pretty bad.

[Arcfield]

Wonder how many of Arcfield/tn are scum.

I can probably understand why you think it's me.

I don't think i've posted too much (if at all.) It's only natural.

This pre-emptive defensive stance is just bad tho

VOTE: Arc

But I wasn't being defensive...

[emps]

^^ i dont think that was defensiveness, but it sure as hell was scummy

[emps]

lmao "fireass"

[emps]

is assassin a fb alt?