Mini 2090 CYS: AtmosFEAR of Terrors

[Gamma Emerald]

VOTE: Pine
Hooray now I'm a mafia expert!

[Katsuki]

CONGRATULATIONS

[Pine]

I'm not performing.

Think about it from my perspective for a sec - I got a really large, serious wagon on me for a bullshit (but kinda valid) reason right out of the gate. I was excited for a funky game with people I like, but then get practically policy lynched. That hurt, and I did take it personally. Ever since I've been trying to recover and get to work, but it's not easy.

I actually think GreyICE is faking his restriction. I don't know why, but Occam's says "for lulz"

I do actually think Kats is a Lyncher. It's by far the best explanation for his behavior, and has literally (not figuratively) done absolutely nothing so far but attack me, despite having the fourth highest post total. I think he's ballsy enough to claim it, thinking he won't be taken seriously. This is bastard mod, remember? With explicit third party? Lyncher satisfies that.

[implosion]

pine's iso is just performance art

i'm just not sure what subgenre thereof

WHEN WAS THE LAST TIME YOU SAW SUCH PERFORMANCE ART FROM TOWN?

Never.
Last time from scum, also never.
I guess that makes him third party.

[implosion]

I do actually think Kats is a Lyncher. It's by far the best explanation for his behavior, and has literally (not figuratively) done absolutely nothing so far but attack me, despite having the fourth highest post total. I think he's ballsy enough to claim it, thinking he won't be taken seriously. This is bastard mod, remember? With explicit third party? Lyncher satisfies that.

this is actually incredible

[Katsuki]

HOW CONVENIENT THAT THE GAME HAPPENED TO PROVIDE ME A WAGON ON MY LYNCHER TARGET PG4 HMMM

pine's iso is just performance art

i'm just not sure what subgenre thereof

WHEN WAS THE LAST TIME YOU SAW SUCH PERFORMANCE ART FROM TOWN?

Never.
Last time from scum, also never.
I guess that makes him third party.

IDK WHAT GAMES YOU PLAY TO HAVE NEVER SEEN THIS FROM SCUM

[Katsuki]

Think about it from my perspective for a sec - I got a really large, serious wagon on me for a bullshit (but kinda valid) reason right out of the gate. I was excited for a funky game with people I like, but then get practically policy lynched. That hurt, and I did take it personally. Ever since I've been trying to recover and get to work, but it's not easy.

I KINDA FEEL FOR YOU THAT YOU'RE DYING EARLY IN A GAME WITH AN AWESOME PALYERLIST WHICH SUCKS AND IS MOST UNFORTUNATE
BUT NONE OF THIS PRECLUDES YOU FROM BEING SCUM

[Katsuki]

WHICH IS TO SAY

YOU ARE SCUM POTENTIALLY TELLING THE TRUTH ABOUT YOUR FEELINGS
ITS SAD AND WHAT NOT
BUT AT THE END OF THE DAY YOU STILL CHOSE SCUM AND ARE GETTING LYNCHED FOR YOUR SCUMMINESS
(AND APPARENTLY DUE TO THE MISFORTUNE OF HAVING DRAWN THE STRAW FOR MY LYNCHER)

[Pine]

What's really frustrating me is that "nuh-uh" is an invalid defense to the assertion you're making about my choices here.

I actually do enjoy playing Town once in a while, and thought that picking scum would be suicidal.

Guess that concern was right.

[implosion]

did you think picking town would save you from the onslaught of "pine will definitely pick scum" arguments?

[Katsuki]

YOU'RE NOT SCUM BECAUSE OF YOUR INCLINATION TO PICK SCUM
YOU'RE SCUM BECAUSE OF THIS

[implosion]

but katsuki that's so many posts how am i supposed to know which one makes pine scum

[Pine]

I didn't think they'd be this intense...reputation or not, my actual preference for scum is pretty mild. I did think it would help me enjoy the game a bit more - I'm gearing up for the third installment of the Revenge series, and I don't need that "hunted by competent people" stress in my life, especially during camp season.

I'm actually rather shook that a WIFOM argument like "Pine always chooses scum" is holding water with people this experienced. That's why I smell a rat.

Also, I somehow have the black key again, despite the rules of it suggesting that Alisae should have it. Someone's using shenanigans to move it around. I'm going to hold onto it for a bit, because I'm not a dick.

Implosion, do me a favor. Throw out the "Lynchers don't exist" preconception you have, and ISO Katsuki. Show me one post - just one - which doesn't fit a Lyncher.

[Pine]

Scum was actually my third pick this game.

Shake things up a bit.

Quote things like an adult.

[Pine]

YOU'RE NOT SCUM BECAUSE OF YOUR INCLINATION TO PICK SCUM
YOU'RE SCUM BECAUSE OF THIS

312 in response to this.

[Pine]

did you think picking town would save you from the onslaught of "pine will definitely pick scum" arguments?

Sorry, wrong button. In response to this.

[implosion]

Implosion, do me a favor. Throw out the "Lynchers don't exist" preconception you have, and ISO Katsuki. Show me one post - just one - which doesn't fit a Lyncher.

this argument in isolation is also just deeply, deeply hilarious.

there's no onus on me to prove that someone isn't a lyncher.

[implosion]

and you know damn well there's no single post that katsuki has made that it's impossible for katsuki to have made as a lyncher. that's a meaningless assertion. There's no goddamn reason to lyncherhunt.

[implosion]

sorry, you know damn well that i know that, and that it's meaningless.

There isn't a single post *you* have made that's inconsistent with you being a lyncher either.

[Pine]

Let me rephrase

Show me any Katsuki post where he does anything a non-Lyncher Town scumhunter would do.

PE: Of course there is. I've gone after several people so far. That's inconsistent with a Lyncher. Katsuki HASN'T

[kuribo]

The fact that you jump right to lyncher instead of scum worries me more

[kuribo]

sorry, you know damn well that i know that, and that it's meaningless.

There isn't a single post *you* have made that's inconsistent with you being a lyncher either.

I feel like asking someone to prove they aren't lyncher would be trying to prove a negative and you're right in that you can't exactly do that re: lynchers

[Pine]

I didn't. It took me a while to get there.

If Katsuki had been pursuing a couple of targets and not looking at possible Town or w/e, I'd say scum.

We're in a flagged-as-bastard game with acknowledged third party, and Katsuki HAS NOT posted ANYTHING except attacks on me and deflections about himself. Nothing. Not one single opinion about anyone or anything else. No setup spec, no scumhunting, no Townreading, not even any banter. Single-minded attacking of a single target, plus unprompted and repeated claiming of Lyncher.

Any other game or situation, I'd agree with you. In this game, Lyncher isn't only possible, but actually kind of likely.

[GreyICE]

The last thing I want to do in this setup is give out townreads like they're candy.

If I end up TRing scum, it could be disastrous.

Play resistance to know this pit
It is so utterly incredibly shit
the fun of sharing
is to show caring
hiding makes us not trust you one bit

[Katsuki]

but katsuki that's so many posts how am i supposed to know which one makes pine scum

ALL OF THEM