the thread title sucked the whole game

[the worst]

talk me thru what you're seeing emps?

[emps]

Is the gamma read just based on recent stuff? I think their d1 play was pretty townie

[emps]

oh yeah duck you forgot to answer why you think blake/garmr is t/t

ill do the bob thingy rn

[DrDolittle]

Garmr I think your POE is unexciting because theres still so many people alive, another chance you're wrong on at least one or two of them is extremely high. I'm also not fully convinced at your historic townhunting ability such that PoE is the right approach?

[the worst]

mmmm soulread
they were both being kinda silly in different ways but they both felt earnest and legitimately annoyed with the way each other was responding
garmr comes off like, technically townier from it ig but t/t wouldn't surprise me at all

[DrDolittle]

@Emps yeah.

[the worst]

Is the gamma read just based on recent stuff? I think their d1 play was pretty townie

idk what this is referring to sry
i think he's been reasonably consistent

[the worst]

actually okay yeah

treating gamma as town

[emps]

Ah trying to read bobs iso is pain reading long posts is hard lol


But he seems to be questioning/actively creating interactions. however hes slightly laid back though. most of the time its NAI and im too lazy to do a meta check thing

[Fire Assassin]

DDL, you only have one scumread?

Interesting question. I'm entertaining the idea that Fireass is scum. Otherwise, I have a weak scum read on gamma

Why gamma?

[Fire Assassin]

fb have you played with me? how do you know i dont do jack shit every game

Yes, I have played with you. Last time you basically didn't do anything but sit in the corner and say you were town while people voted you. And you were town.

[emps]

woah thats some top level townplay

[the worst]

Ah trying to read bobs iso is pain reading long posts is hard lol


But he seems to be questioning/actively creating interactions. however hes slightly laid back though. most of the time its NAI and im too lazy to do a meta check thing

consider scum knows that questioning and actively creating interactions looks towny
scum also don't have motivation to actually follow through on the content they're creating
scum also don't have any urgency wrt reacting to things and pushing their lynches

i'd argue bob is trying to look like he's town but doesn't actually give a toss about solving this one

compare to his towngame for example where his solves are a lot more erratic and reactive; here he kinda takes a back seat in generating content

might be wrong but he smells like scum fmpov

[schadd_]

replacing tn

[Gamma Emerald]

I think your opinion on rn you quoted from before was biased that way, though you're welcome to prove me wrong.

Doesn't say much his jump on me was pretty scummy but other than it's nulish. I don't mind if We lynch TN today.

There's a reason why he was listed as null and not scum. I thought the jump on me was scummy but not really enough to scum read him. The reason his on my lynch list is because of POE.

Do you disagree with the POE side of things?

I'd have to look into that more, but for now your point is proven

[emps]

Ah trying to read bobs iso is pain reading long posts is hard lol


But he seems to be questioning/actively creating interactions. however hes slightly laid back though. most of the time its NAI and im too lazy to do a meta check thing

consider scum knows that questioning and actively creating interactions looks towny
scum also don't have motivation to actually follow through on the content they're creating
scum also don't have any urgency wrt reacting to things and pushing their lynches

i'd argue bob is trying to look like he's town but doesn't actually give a toss about solving this one

compare to his towngame for example where his solves are a lot more erratic and reactive; here he kinda takes a back seat in generating content

might be wrong but he smells like scum fmpov

so basically bob reads like scum trying to get townread to you?

[the worst]

yeah. there's not enough content/trajectory from his slot that I feel like "GOTCHA" but it's where I'm at.

it's a bit of an applied read but like when I thought "what could his town motivation be for this play?" I was like.... maybeeeeee.... and when I thought "what could his scum motivation be?" this clicked for me pretty intuitively.

[Iconeum]

Dolittle, you say emps is scum for having lazy reads

But you scumread me for pushing your lazy reads

what's up with that?

You say you originally scum read DrD over his lazy reads on emps but has you read on him changed over the course of his answers. As his posts so far, this game has given me the slight feeling to me that he is fellow townie.

So, if DrD is town or even if I am wrong on him and is in fact scum. Who do you think would be the other there/two scum (respectively) or even just a short list of who you think have the highest equity of being scum?

I've posted everything I wanted on DDL, and it was more then just lazy reads. What you quote isn't about the actual laziness of things, it's that he scumreads me for pushing him on a tell that he used to scumread emps on. I reallllly dislike your defence of DDL here. Do you townread him that much (and explain me the townread then), or are you trying to steer me away from your buddy? In which case don't worry, you can easily be next.

[Iconeum]

DDL/Bob is where i'm at for scumteam right now

Open question: is anyone not townreading emps?

[Iconeum]

yeah. there's not enough content/trajectory from his slot that I feel like "GOTCHA" but it's where I'm at.

it's a bit of an applied read but like when I thought "what could his town motivation be for this play?" I was like.... maybeeeeee.... and when I thought "what could his scum motivation be?" this clicked for me pretty intuitively.

What do you think of bob's attempt at directing me away from DDL?

[Garmr]

If bob is scum fire ass has to be scum. Since claimed a power role that clears him.

[Iconeum]

And something that I feel has to be resolved sooner rather then later: Fireasses claim.

It really stings me that there's supposedly a power role with the ability to clear 2! town on night 1.

At the very least I wanna hear from him his motivation on selection of targets

[Garmr]

Meh i dont want to speculate to much but the fact we have a back up makes me feel like other town roles are limited in some why or have the weak modifer.

[Fire Assassin]

We can talk about my claim tomorrow. I feel I have a good chance of being here tomorrow, and should have another clear. Not sure if I will have 2. I kind of lucked out with getting 2.

[the worst]

Open question: is anyone not townreading emps?

i go back and forth, and settle on town