Open 762: CK9++ [Over!]

[Persivul]

The outed doctor? Wow, shocker that scum killed the outed PR instead of the “cop.” You ALWAYS kill informed town first. Gamma says that he got roleblocked and scum killed doctor. But that’s idiotic on scum’s part. Why would they not roleblock the doctor and kill a cop if they thought they knew where it was?

It makes no difference which one they block and which one they kill.

[James Brafin]

Scum obviously didn’t, since he’s not DEAD.

No, if scum have an RB they could just block there and kill elsewhere. The NK proves nothing.

I’m going to be honest, that is the DUMBEST thing I’ve ever heard. As I’ve said before, scum always kills informed town. If they really had thought Gamma was the cop, they would have shot there. If that was actually what scum was thinking, someone was not being smart, to put it kindly, and neither was their partners.

[James Brafin]

The outed doctor? Wow, shocker that scum killed the outed PR instead of the “cop.” You ALWAYS kill informed town first. Gamma says that he got roleblocked and scum killed doctor. But that’s idiotic on scum’s part. Why would they not roleblock the doctor and kill a cop if they thought they knew where it was?

It makes no difference which one they block and which one they kill.

Why not?

[Persivul]

And you trying to pass it off as Gamma being alive being proof that Gamma is scum just goes to show your scum plan like an open book.
And it also shows that you got no actual reasoning to back up you being a cop over Gamma.

You're arguing that this is a scum plan, and it's a bad plan. Does it make sense that after talking with two other scum overnight, they'd come out with this plan? IF gamma claims cop, THEN you CC him, even though we know you didn't lay crumbs. That of course doesn't prove anything, because people do dumb shit all the time.

[Persivul]

Oh and using NKA as an Absolute.

Oh and if he was a real cop he wouldnt forget about the 1S tracker.

What's an unconfirmed 1X tracker got to do with it?

[Persivul]

Also I freaking breadsliced d2 with my "secret reasons to trust Sakura". Following Gob's derp how does that slip by?

Why did you make such an obvious crumb? Weren't you afraid that scum would be onto you, especially after the 1X tracker claim?

Frankly considering the crumb and then this:

Like I'm not confirming or denying it but it's anti town so to do that after your "confession" makes no sense if you're trying to townside in your last efforts.

I thought you might be VT trying to draw the NK.

[Persivul]

And where is your crumb, because I can’t see it. All I see is you trolling.

Once gob called him out I looked for a crumb, and it's plain as day. Like REALLY obvious.

I was looking at d1, not d2. :p I see it now, but my point stands.

No, your point doesn't stand. Gamma crumbed an inno and that's what good cops are supposed to do. I get that it's possible you're cop and didn't feel comfortable doing it. It took me a few times roling cop before I did so. But truth is the crumb appears real, and that's in his favor. That said, in my first game here the scum IC dropped crumbs for all the PRs, so I don't put a lot of stock in them.

[Persivul]

I’m going to be honest, that is the DUMBEST thing I’ve ever heard. As I’ve said before, scum always kills informed town. If they really had thought Gamma was the cop, they would have shot there. If that was actually what scum was thinking, someone was not being smart, to put it kindly, and neither was their partners.

That's ridiculous. If scum have a full RB, it makes no difference whether they block doc and kill cop, or block cop and kill doc. Not one bit.

[Persivul]

Why not?

Because either way you end up with one person dead and no investigation performed.

[Rick Dalton]

Guys, I have no clue

[Gamma Emerald]

You know what the initial big claim post I think makes it more likely Gobb is SK over scum
VOTE: SkyG
I guess go on with this one? Also wdym lying about "one of the three"?

Out of idle curiosity, how does THIS come from cop?

Why wouldn't it? Cops play the day game too.

But as already asked I would like Gamma to explain this, and why he didn't pick up with it at the beginning of today.

What did you think needed explaining in that post?

[Gamma Emerald]

Why did you make such an obvious crumb?

Because I figured at the time of it would be brushed under by the fact Sakura said a similar thing. Basically contextual camouflage.

[Persivul]

What did you think needed explaining in that post?

Why did you vote sky? I don't see a reasonable foundation for you to vote her in that gamestate.

What did you mean by "go on with" it? There hadn't been a sky wagon going.

[Gamma Emerald]

I meant "go on with" as in "go on with why Sky is scum". And I voted Sky because I wanted to leash Gob.

[Sakura Hana]

And you trying to pass it off as Gamma being alive being proof that Gamma is scum just goes to show your scum plan like an open book.
And it also shows that you got no actual reasoning to back up you being a cop over Gamma.

You're arguing that this is a scum plan, and it's a bad plan. Does it make sense that after talking with two other scum overnight, they'd come out with this plan? IF gamma claims cop, THEN you CC him, even though we know you didn't lay crumbs. That of course doesn't prove anything, because people do dumb shit all the time.

It's possible.
If the intent of the NK was framing someone. Which is why i always brush off NKA as WIFOM.

[Sakura Hana]

Oh and using NKA as an Absolute.

Oh and if he was a real cop he wouldnt forget about the 1S tracker.

What's an unconfirmed 1X tracker got to do with it?

Doesnt the existance of the 1S tracker confirm the existance of a cop? Although i didnt realize this:

Btw there's no way both our claims are real

Actually there is - if chem's claim is false. I don't think that's the case, but it should be put out there.

[Sakura Hana]

ugh i feel like this is colors all over again.

[Gamma Emerald]

No. Me and James both claimed full cop, not one shot.

[Sakura Hana]

I think im pretty bad at these kinds of setups.

[Gamma Emerald]

I'm not that good either, I practically have to check the setup every 5 minutes in any setup otherwise I say something absolutely stupid.

[Chemist1422]

Cop/tracker is Gamma by the way

Also since Gob is a FUCKING MORON I might as well claim. Yes I am cop and I got Sakura town n1. Got no result last night on Persivul which is why I'm so pissed at Gob.

Also this doesnt look like a fake reaction.
Even gob noticed Gamma was an investigative of some sort.

Scum obviously didn’t, since he’s not DEAD.

>doctor died

The outed doctor? Wow, shocker that scum killed the outed PR instead of the “cop.” You ALWAYS kill informed town first. Gamma says that he got roleblocked and scum killed doctor. But that’s idiotic on scum’s part. Why would they not roleblock the doctor and kill a cop if they thought they knew where it was?

Because there was a chance that Gamma didn't flip cop

[Chemist1422]

Btw there's no way both our claims are real

Actually there is - if chem's claim is false. I don't think that's the case, but it should be put out there.

That is not how it works

[Chemist1422]

Cop/tracker is Gamma by the way

Also since Gob is a FUCKING MORON I might as well claim. Yes I am cop and I got Sakura town n1. Got no result last night on Persivul which is why I'm so pissed at Gob.

Also this doesnt look like a fake reaction.

That wasn't his initial reaction. He initially said he'd neither confirm nor deny it. This came after he had a night phase to consider it.

Even gob noticed Gamma was an investigative of some sort.

What do you mean by "even gob"? No one has more incentive to PR hunt than an SK.

Yes because an investigation-immune SK cares about whether a cop is alive or not

[Chemist1422]

Guys, I have no clue

mood

[Korina]

>