Detective Penguin & City of Fogport [Game Over]

[Marquis]

I don't know if it's because it's Ceph or because it's Chandra, but I find myself disagreeing with a LOT of what they say.

Historically speaking that's 50-50 town-scum odds.

[Day One Wagon]

Our hood didn't get night 0 talk so I don't think mafia would have either.

I find this bit weird - mafia is confirmed to have daytalk in their PT

Thanks I forgot about daytalk lol


I feel like if I want to analyze that correction from DOL it's gonna lead me down a WIFOM path.

Well, we have different opinion on Pop and your opinion was kinda relying on fact that maf had no daytalk, so after my correction, you still believe Pop is scum and would act same way with having knowledge about other hoods?

[Marquis]

what. no.
I know my hood had no night 0 talk. I assumed scum weren't in conversation either.
Given scum are probably actively daytalking and setup specing, I actually think it makes more sense that pops' reaction could have come from scum collectively knowing more about the setup than town do, both from the outset and having each other to freely bounce setup/role/wincon ideas off of.


OK I'm also pretty sure DOL isn't an alt now. I'm slightly more confident in a scumlean?

[Gorkington]

i think they are a secret alt
otherwise i dont understand their comment at me

[Marquis]

it reads like someone who started 3 months ago but i get that too

[Day One Wagon]

I'm a "secret" alt - I'm so secret that I'm even chose avatar similar to my main

And here we go. Gork, I told you that people are scumreading me, when I scumhunt

[Gorkington]

threaten to beat people up if they dont wagon pine that way theyll be too scared of your fists to vote you

[Day One Wagon]

Nah, Pine is all yours, I'm just helping you and waiting to see where it goes with hopes to get something AI

[kuribo]

i can already tell it's gonna be one of THOSE games.

I'm not much on setup speculation, but this game is almost assuredly balanced around negative utility and dayplay. ie, the caffeine addiction mechanic, the multitude of millers, the counterbalances, it all tells me that FakeGod probably intended to mitigate how much benefit both sides get from night actions. In fact, knowing what I know from my own role, and from what's been claimed / the ruleset, I'd say this setup actively PUNISHES town for relying on nightplay.

[kuribo]

Day-one Pine wagon is such a 2012 thing

[Gorkington]

its retro and back in now

[Chandra Nalaar]

Do people not try during the day in any game

Sounds bad

[kuribo]

its retro and back in now

true, I mean, Stranger Things is basically a 1980s circlejerk

[kuribo]

I'm good on calling Bingle town right now

I've never met Vecna but I like his style

I have some thoughts about the Miller neighborhood, but like... okay: Are you guys specifically millers? Or do you all have the miller modifier? See, the latter is important because if you have, say, X number of people in a neighborhood who have a miller modifier, the mod would simply say "Everyone in this neighborhood investigates guilty." Which would include people who are not millers and are simply mafia. If this is the case, and all of the millers were informed of that fact, it makes outting the millerhood way less useful in finding which ones are town. I guess I can elaborate if need be, but please don't fucking make me. I just woke up.

All jokes about 2012 aside, Pine's not gonna do shit unless we poke him.

I don't know who or what an RCE is but okay

[Gorkington]

so what youre saying is
we should poke him?

[FakeGod]

VoteCount 1.2

Gorkington [1] - Fish Monger
Marquis [3] - Pine, popsofctown, Flavor Leaf
Fish Monger [1] - Chandra Nalaar
Pine [2] - Gorkington, Day One Lynch
popsofctown [2] - ofrhz, Marquis

Not Voting [8]

- PenguinPower, Croag, Kagami, Vecna, Judge Joseph Dredd, kuribo, Perry Pelican, Bingle

With 17 alive it takes 9 votes to lynch.

Countdown to deadline: (expired on 2019-08-31 20:00:00)

[kuribo]

so what youre saying is
we should poke him?

Now you're thinking with portals

Vote:Pine

[Chandra Nalaar]

VOTE: Pine

[PenguinPower]

Oooh fun.

[PenguinPower]

VOTE: Marquis

[Chandra Nalaar]

What I liked about the pops ramble was the way in which it was delivered

That may be more important to me than a post's content

[Chandra Nalaar]

Fuck I mean that IS more important

[Gorkington]

im done for the weekend all pls lynch the scum before i get back

[Chandra Nalaar]

I'm pouring some salt around my pentagram and tonight under cover of darkness I'm gonna summon kagami

[Perry Pelican]

I'm good on calling Bingle town right now

I've never met Vecna but I like his style

I have some thoughts about the Miller neighborhood, but like... okay: Are you guys specifically millers? Or do you all have the miller modifier? See, the latter is important because if you have, say, X number of people in a neighborhood who have a miller modifier, the mod would simply say "Everyone in this neighborhood investigates guilty." Which would include people who are not millers and are simply mafia. If this is the case, and all of the millers were informed of that fact, it makes outting the millerhood way less useful in finding which ones are town. I guess I can elaborate if need be, but please don't fucking make me. I just woke up.

All jokes about 2012 aside, Pine's not gonna do shit unless we poke him.

I don't know who or what an RCE is but okay

Good morning. This question kind of answers itself. If mafia is in one of these neighborhoods they know it doesn't explicitly consist of millers since...well, they can't be a miller.