Detective Penguin & City of Fogport [Game Over]

[Day One Wagon]

Also, has it even been confirmed if everyone is in a hood?

Not until croag's post right above this was it 100% confirmed. People assumed the four of us were all together, but I believe the only certainty that could be derived from the actual posts in the thread was that I was with kagami and at least one other person.

It was pretty obv Croag was in hood after Kagami asked for prod

The fudge? The hoods don't have daytalk. Why would Kagami be more likely to prod someone in his hood instead of someone outside of his hood?

This sounds like a scumslip from having daytalk with Kagami or Croag

Its not the first time something like this was suggested. Howd you know this is the same for all hoods though?

I don't understand the question

Is it confirmed none of the hoods have daychat?

Yes, it is mod confirmed in first post that only maf PT has daytalk

[Day One Wagon]

chances for Croag lynch in near future is pretty damn high, especially considering how divided everyone are on their lynch preferences and Croag looks like really nice consensus lynch D3/D4

Croag's recent contributions are fairly town. You are not getting your free lynch. Sorry c:

At this point I'm not sure you know how to read

[Chandra Nalaar]

Fucking lol.

[Chandra Nalaar]

Hi everyone else can you help me lynch this

[Day One Wagon]

Please, show me where I said I want to lynch Croag?

[Bingle]

Skimmed, dropping a few thoughts.

1, a single doc from the doc hood had a 75% chance of successfully stopping the kill. Only one of the sanities can't prevent a nightkill, and CPR doc killing kuribo if he was scum fakeclaiming wasn't an issue in the slightest. I don't particularly think the docs not seeing this is AI, because I don't think any of them are particularly mechanically inclined. Similarly the fact that the docs chose to holster and the obvious nk went through unchecked is actually indicative that there IS a scum in that neighborhood, as the scum would know they didn't have to play around a protection.
2, I originally scumread you pops because your shitty spec didn't match expectations from you, you were content to take a backseat and let FL push Perry after he took up your torch, you've been fairly consistently lurking in the background and egging things on instead of being actively involved where you might draw attention. The TMI of knowing Perry was going to flip town instead of just WIFOM-ing you not matching up with the stated confidence in your deathtunnel is just the icing on the scumpops cake.
3, yes I would lynch JJD. No, I will not vote until I'm the hammer.

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

Like, I can "assume" Yes is the answer from ofrhz/D1L/Marquis/Bingle, but I don't want to be putting words in their mouths.

You know, with unkillable hood being addicted, I'm worried to lynch in our hood now - scum has more reasons to kill us and I'd rather not help them, if I'm wrong on you

I'll take this as a no then? Correct me if I'm wrong

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

Alright, here's the deal:

I want each and every player here to state whether they would be willing to vote me today or not.

I'll keep the list public for ease:


[*]ofrhz
[N]PenguinPower
[Y]Croag
[*]Pine
[*]Kagami
[*]Bingle
[N]Day One Lynch
[*]Vecna
[*]chennisden
[*]Marquis
[N]popsofctown
[Y]Chandra Nalaar
[*]Flavor Leaf

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

@Vecna: Can you please confirm your view on this? Are you willing to lynch me today or not?

@Bingle: I am assuming you would, but please confirm this for the record.

[Flavor Leaf]

N

[Day One Wagon]

Like, I can "assume" Yes is the answer from ofrhz/D1L/Marquis/Bingle, but I don't want to be putting words in their mouths.

You know, with unkillable hood being addicted, I'm worried to lynch in our hood now - scum has more reasons to kill us and I'd rather not help them, if I'm wrong on you

I'll take this as a no then? Correct me if I'm wrong

Yes, it's a no from me for today

[Flavor Leaf]

Also, has it even been confirmed if everyone is in a hood?

Not until croag's post right above this was it 100% confirmed. People assumed the four of us were all together, but I believe the only certainty that could be derived from the actual posts in the thread was that I was with kagami and at least one other person.

It was pretty obv Croag was in hood after Kagami asked for prod

The fudge? The hoods don't have daytalk. Why would Kagami be more likely to prod someone in his hood instead of someone outside of his hood?

This sounds like a scumslip from having daytalk with Kagami or Croag

Its not the first time something like this was suggested. Howd you know this is the same for all hoods though?

I don't understand the question

Is it confirmed none of the hoods have daychat?

Yes.

[Flavor Leaf]

@Chandar - who are we lynching now? Did we move off of Kagami?

[popsofctown]

Guys I'm lurking in the background

[popsofctown]

Please prod orfhz and/or Pine

[Chandra Nalaar]

Please, show me where I said I want to lynch Croag?

You literally just offered them as a consensus lynch, and are desperate to have them vigged (you'll then suggest lynching them when FL doesnt listen to you) and I'm quite sure I already pointed out another time when you seemed unwilling to admit croag is looking less lynchable

[Chandra Nalaar]

@Chandar - who are we lynching now? Did we move off of Kagami?

I'd like to lynch D1L. I was never on kagami, but I believe some people still are.

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

Alright, here's the deal:

I want each and every player here to state whether they would be willing to vote me today or not.

I'll keep the list public for ease:


[y?]ofrhz
[N]PenguinPower
[Y]Croag
[?]Pine
[?]Kagami
[y?]Bingle
[N]Day One Lynch
[y?]Vecna
[??]chennisden
[y?]Marquis
[N]popsofctown
[Y]Chandra Nalaar
[N]Flavor Leaf

[Day One Wagon]

Please, show me where I said I want to lynch Croag?

You literally just offered them as a consensus lynch, and are desperate to have them vigged (you'll then suggest lynching them when FL doesnt listen to you) and I'm quite sure I already pointed out another time when you seemed unwilling to admit croag is looking less lynchable

Again, please learn how to read what I say, not just invent what you want to see

I'll suggest simple excercise to you - look at playerlist and try to predict 3 next lynches and how easily you expect for them to be to lynch. Now ask yourself, how likely people would lynch these 3 people you predict without losing their patience and just lynching Croag? Yes, Croag is a tiny bit towny, but you should look at bigger picture - where you put Croag in this playerlist and not just your own opinion, but general read in comparison with rest of the players

[Flavor Leaf]

@Chandar - who are we lynching now? Did we move off of Kagami?

I'd like to lynch D1L. I was never on kagami, but I believe some people still are.

VOTE: D1L

[Croag]

tbh from an objective standpoint im not most scummy/lynch target for next 3/4 days

i would put them on 3 other players over me

imo more scummy players than me are DOL, chenn and bingle

my scum read on pops has all but gone now

[Croag]

also penguin & of have hardly spoken

[Croag]

i just dont think ofhz is scum based on the mini wagon earlier

[Croag]

i put JJD in a high up scum maybe position too

like id be happy with him getting lynched but think the other 3 are more scummy

[popsofctown]

Tinfoil hat, exactly one scum in the doctor hood, scum is informed of the entire neighborhood's sanity spread