Detective Penguin & City of Fogport [Game Over]

[Flavor Leaf]

Who was his target?

I actually feel like I remember him specifically stating he didn’t claim his target.

I think he accidentally killed Fish, though.

[Flavor Leaf]

I came clean with all my other stuff, it’s time for everyone to do the same if they’ve been lying.

I only do that fake claim stuff early game. It all comes out when it’s time to solve.

[Bingle]

Lynching you is pretty reasonable

Why

Why not?

What have they done that would make it unreasonable to you?

If you want a case I may even provide one, though I'm not sure what the point is when no one cares what I think.

Actually you know what I don't like the DOL slot that much

But yeah I want an outline sort of

VOTE: Chennisden

No! You were so close. Vote the cheeky scumfuck who I've been telling you to vote for literal eternities.

[Bingle]

Marquis, Vecna, Bingle are probably masons that have a post restriction that they can’t claim they are masons, and joining into the neighborhood i’ll be able to see they are masons, though.

Which is why they’re all caffeinated, meaning there’s 4 caffeinated alive players.

Meaning the CPR doctor is scum.

I'm not caffeinated.

[Day One Wagon]

Who was his target?

I actually feel like I remember him specifically stating he didn’t claim his target.

I think he accidentally killed Fish, though.

He claimed in hood last night, but I leave for him to decide, if he want out here or not

[Bingle]

I was just curious how Bingle knew there was 3 vigs D2 and made some theory

I didn't. Technically, I still don't. I trust FL's claim, he didn't set it up the way he does gambit claims (as I mentioned). I trust Marquis's claim there's no way he risks the cc for no reason when he's already this far behind. I trust the dead townie. I trust that the doc hood isn't collectively lying about the mod confirmation that there's a CPR doc.

Dead vig + fish kill + CPR doc who didn't act is 3 vigs.

Dead vig + FL claim + CPR doc killed fish is 3 vigs.

With my D2 knowledge, it was basically assured there were 3 vigs.

With my current knowledge, it's pretty likely there's 4 vigs.

[Bingle]

He claimed in hood last night, but I leave for him to decide, if he want out here or not

Why would a spent 1 shot doc who didn't save anyone not want to claim their target? That's bullshit to stop himself from being analyzed.

[Bingle]

who was that and why they lyingggg

Vecna. I don't actually care why he made the obvious lie.

I'm not caffeinated. Marquis was caffeinated N1 when he shot Fish by his claim.

[Flavor Leaf]

Hmm.

[Day One Wagon]

He claimed in hood last night, but I leave for him to decide, if he want out here or not

Why would a spent 1 shot doc who didn't save anyone not want to claim their target? That's bullshit to stop himself from being analyzed.

He wasn't trying to protect, he tried to kill, but his target survived

[Bingle]

That's not better.

[chennisden]

let me make it really clear - i'm not going to tolerate people setting up my slot by discrediting it for their own machinations.

[Day One Wagon]

That's not better.

I'm not saying it's better, but this perspective makes his claim way less believable

[gobbledygook]

I was just curious how Bingle knew there was 3 vigs D2 and made some theory

I didn't. Technically, I still don't. I trust FL's claim, he didn't set it up the way he does gambit claims (as I mentioned). I trust Marquis's claim there's no way he risks the cc for no reason when he's already this far behind. I trust the dead townie. I trust that the doc hood isn't collectively lying about the mod confirmation that there's a CPR doc.

Dead vig + fish kill + CPR doc who didn't act is 3 vigs.

Dead vig + FL claim + CPR doc killed fish is 3 vigs.

With my D2 knowledge, it was basically assured there were 3 vigs.

With my current knowledge, it's pretty likely there's 4 vigs.

Who is the dead Vig?

[Flavor Leaf]

Pelly Perican is a dead Vig.

And D1L makes a lot of sense with that actually. I like that.

[gobbledygook]

Derp. I knew that.

[gobbledygook]

Setup spec dictates that 1 of the Reflexive neighbors is scum. But I don’t want to think about that.

Anyway, I’m bored and just gonna let the cat out of the bag. Scum is {Ofhrz, JJD, Flavor}

VOTE: Ofhrz

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

I fully believe Chandra and Fish were meant to be endgame and FL was scum who took advantage of his fakeclaim meta to push a lunch through on someone he believed to be an actual town vig

Sorry, nut I have to point this out: If FL is scum then HE is the designated scum to end the game. As such, ANYONE could have pushed that mislynch. Anyone who was NOT Flavor Leaf, that is.

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

Scum absolutely knew I didn’t shoot.

Meaning people, like JJD, who were acting like I did shoot Fish gain a lot more scum equity.

Sorry, but I'm too dumb to wrap my head around this one. Can you simplify it for me?

[Vecna]

Really, were going to vca scum into arbitrary piles now? Can we not waste our time on such pointless exercises?

AWESOME!!!

This means my VCA is likely pretty decent.

I dno, this is again starting to feel desperate

Which proves you are surface level with no accurate measurement of my scum play meaning all your comments on anything related to skill level is irrelevant because you talk whilst uneducated.

And i have a super chill demeanor with these past few pages. You’re just throwing desperate in to throw the word in, which is again, surface level of you.

Just because you use a lot of words to describe a simple concept dont make you some advanced player.

saying you wouldnt do somethibg as scum, simply means you would do it while applaying 3rd or 5th level wifom.

This does not make you a wizard.

[Vecna]

PP claims to act N2, not N1, I don't see problem there. He never claimed to act N1, he simply didn't denied assumption that he acted N1 and it's smart, scum wouldn't consider him as a target, if they think he already used his ability

Have you played with town A50? I'm really curious why you so hung up on fact that he isn't lying about acting N1. I've seen him flipping his claim as town in the past, so I take that as a NAI

Also I see you finally noticed that there was 0 people caffeinated at the start

This has already been discussed. It doesn’t matter.

Day 3 has 4 caffeinated.

Bingle
Vecna
Marquis
PP
JJD

Like drop Night 1 from your mind. It’s still accurate.

Also, talking about surface level play, and then making these posts as a foundation for something is just hilarious.

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

Note: ofrhz hasn't posted in 2 days 18 hours

[Vecna]

I was just curious how Bingle knew there was 3 vigs D2 and made some theory

I didn't. Technically, I still don't. I trust FL's claim, he didn't set it up the way he does gambit claims (as I mentioned). I trust Marquis's claim there's no way he risks the cc for no reason when he's already this far behind. I trust the dead townie. I trust that the doc hood isn't collectively lying about the mod confirmation that there's a CPR doc.

Dead vig + fish kill + CPR doc who didn't act is 3 vigs.

Dead vig + FL claim + CPR doc killed fish is 3 vigs.

With my D2 knowledge, it was basically assured there were 3 vigs.

With my current knowledge, it's pretty likely there's 4 vigs.

So you think FL would really waste a vig shot to get in on our secrets?

[gobbledygook]

Note: ofrhz hasn't posted in 2 days 18 hours

And when she has posted it’s been very scummy.

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

Fish flipped Ninja Watcher.

Show me where that was said. I now believe this is a scumslip of the TMI type. HOW do you know Fish was a Watcher??

WOW OMG I REALLY SHOULD HAVE READ THE END OF THE DAY PHASE!!!!

This is 100% ScumJJD calling out his own partner’s scum slip for town creed, because you kinda gotta.

Like; I genuinely do like you as a person and a player that I can't for the life of me tell you to "go shove it", but seriously.. what the freak are you on? All scum!me would have had to do is pretend they didn't see it. FFS, I do miss the OBVIOUS stuff sometimes, so why not one bloody word that had already been partially hidden with 2 subsequent posts??

Like, me bussing chandra would make much more sense if Scum hadn't already lost Monger on N1. Scum Cop is certainly not much of a Role, although I would still argue it would have been mice to know which of the other Cops to shoot based on whom they were targeting, but.. yeah.. maybe not that much of value in it.

But are you suggesting I bussed chandra after we lost Monger when I was the prime push of Bingle's (and knew that 2 of my own hood were willing to vote me on top of that)??

If your plan is to get me to snap and replace out, let someone else do it cuz I'm laughing at you rn. If you're serious though, stop smoking that stuff. It ain't good for your mental health (judging by the effect it has on you now).