think this is a real thought btw. townread on Gamma instated.In post 3336, Gamma Emerald wrote:No one ever talked to me about tw I. comparison to The Thread Title Sucked (from what I saw) and now 1 of the 2 who could have helped me there is deadIn post 3331, Alisae wrote:yeah because you made itIn post 3329, the worst wrote:It was like the optimal scum NK you fools
Duh
Fire fucking help explain why tw isn't playing like that game
ur just playing hard to get with me and u know itIn post 3375, the worst wrote:think this is a real thought btw. townread on Gamma instated.In post 3336, Gamma Emerald wrote:No one ever talked to me about tw I. comparison to The Thread Title Sucked (from what I saw) and now 1 of the 2 who could have helped me there is deadIn post 3331, Alisae wrote:yeah because you made itIn post 3329, the worst wrote:It was like the optimal scum NK you fools
Duh
Fire fucking help explain why tw isn't playing like that game
still very ambivalent towards fire
In post 1548, Ankamius wrote:Ankamius
Alisae
Chickadee
Aristophanes
The worst
Firebringer
Greyice
Skygazer
MariaR
Untrod Tripod
Krazy
DrippingGoofball
Xofelf
Pink Ball
Katsuki
Formerfish
PenguinPower
Jjh927
Popsofctown
Gamma Emerald
Iconeum
Dannflor
Mastina
chennisden
Menalque
Lady Lambdadelta
Pine
Roughly where my reads are at atm
1906 is Ank's longest post, and she spends a whole point emphasizing how likely she is to be killed at night, and then immediately follows it with a discussion of Menalque and how difficult it is to read him, specifically calling out Alisae. I'm just saying, given 1906 is Ank's longest post, she wanted Mena basically all day, but she also wanted him gone *in part because she felt he was unreadable* he sounds like someone she would be very inclined to want a mech result on, unlike other people who she only mentioned in passing. Additionally, given her reads list on 1548, there's no reason to think she would have had an incentive to seriously reconsider her reads after LLD's flip.In post 1906, Ankamius wrote:4. I'm pretty much always a nightkill by scum this game as town, most likely in midgame somewhere before I hit my stride and start hitting outright solves. I'd be surprised if scum didn't have at least one person that was aware of this, and Pine has seen a recent enough example to believe it.
5. Alisae, this is specifically to you: I've literally never played with Menalque before. I don't know how he plays. He fits the specific type of player I've been trying to hunt for because the way I'm seeing the game, that specific type is the most likely to hold scum. His response to me was horrific. At best, he has a playstyle that will always result in false positives for me, but I don't actually understand what about him is townreadable unless he just has one of those weird playstyles I can't actually read.
Huh.In post 3000, Ankamius wrote:because pops isn't town
Care to share unsaid reason? Or are you also being coy for a reason?In post 3379, the worst wrote:that's correct but I'm not doing it for no reason :<
I had the same thought but Krazy's Mena case above looks more familiar and I think I kinda agree w people saying she wasn't likely to try and kamikaze I guess *sigh*In post 3381, GreyICE wrote:Huh.In post 3000, Ankamius wrote:because pops isn't town
Gonna have to sell me on NOT doing this.
Vote: Pops
In post 1, Jingle wrote:Hello, [Playername]! I'm Jingle and I'm here to welcome you to Alisae's Revenge! You're a Loyal Retainer to the rightful Lord of the Land, Alisae. Unfortunately, the wicked tree that controls the Dark Forest has been acting up, causing insurrections left and right. Alisae has called an end to this nonsense, and is preparing to ride forth. Some of my messages have been compromised, however, and a few among you were recruited by the terrible monster to put an end to our quest before it even begins!
We must purge our party of those who have no loyalty, or we shall surely fail.
[Special Abilities]
The town win condition is: You win when all of Pine's minions have been killed.
The game thread is here: viewtopic.php?f=3&t=80863
In post 3367, mastina wrote:Hello, mastina! I'm Jingle and I'm here to welcome you to Alisae's Revenge! You're a Bodyguard Loyal Retainer to the rightful Lord of the Land, Alisae. Unfortunately, the wicked tree that controls the Dark Forest has been acting up, causing insurrections left and right. Alisae has called an end to this nonsense, and is preparing to ride forth. Some of my messages have been compromised, however, and a few among you were recruited by the terrible monster to put an end to our quest before it even begins!
We must purge our party of those who have no loyalty, or we shall surely fail.
Abilities:
(Bodyguard) Each night, you may target a player. Any attempts to kill that player will fail. If you successfully prevent a kill this way, you will die instead.
The town win condition is: You win when all of Pine's minions have been killed.
The game thread is here:
I like this theory.In post 3380, Krazy wrote:Alright it looks like there's already been some discussion on whether Ank has a comprehensible crumb. I'm not sure my theory is better than anyone else's but I figure it's at least worth asking about.
In post 1548, Ankamius wrote:Ankamius
Alisae
Chickadee
Aristophanes
The worst
Firebringer
Greyice
Skygazer
MariaR
Untrod Tripod
Krazy
DrippingGoofball
Xofelf
Pink Ball
Katsuki
Formerfish
PenguinPower
Jjh927
Popsofctown
Gamma Emerald
Iconeum
Dannflor
Mastina
chennisden
Menalque
Lady Lambdadelta
Pine
Roughly where my reads are at atm1906 is Ank's longest post, and she spends a whole point emphasizing how likely she is to be killed at night, and then immediately follows it with a discussion of Menalque and how difficult it is to read him, specifically calling out Alisae. I'm just saying, given 1906 is Ank's longest post, she wanted Mena basically all day, but she also wanted him gone *in part because she felt he was unreadable* he sounds like someone she would be very inclined to want a mech result on, unlike other people who she only mentioned in passing. Additionally, given her reads list on 1548, there's no reason to think she would have had an incentive to seriously reconsider her reads after LLD's flip.In post 1906, Ankamius wrote:4. I'm pretty much always a nightkill by scum this game as town, most likely in midgame somewhere before I hit my stride and start hitting outright solves. I'd be surprised if scum didn't have at least one person that was aware of this, and Pine has seen a recent enough example to believe it.
5. Alisae, this is specifically to you: I've literally never played with Menalque before. I don't know how he plays. He fits the specific type of player I've been trying to hunt for because the way I'm seeing the game, that specific type is the most likely to hold scum. His response to me was horrific. At best, he has a playstyle that will always result in false positives for me, but I don't actually understand what about him is townreadable unless he just has one of those weird playstyles I can't actually read.
I say this as someone who spent day 1 mostly townreading Menalque, and I am well aware I could be wrong here. But she was still scumreading Mena late into the day and ultimately I've only played with scum Mena once so I have to consider I was just wrong there.
Obviously other people have theories on what might have been Ank's most likely crumb, but overall I think ignoring Ank's actually likely targets is a bad idea. In any case I do see there being likely opposed candidates for crumbs from later in the day but to me this really looks like a Mena check.
VOTE: Mena
Was this in response to something from this dayphase?In post 3377, Gamma Emerald wrote:Btw I won't be campaigning for a Krazy lynch yet but it's definitely something I'll keep in mind, I kinda expect good things from Krazy
Which of my posts specifically were "disgusting"?In post 3388, Dannflor wrote:I'm still 100% down for a Krazy lynch
his posts at the end of D1 were disgusting
and varsoon made an argument that the rules didn't say he couldn't copy and paste his role pm as reason for why he could do it, btw.In post 3392, Firebringer wrote:mastina, i hope u didn't actually copy and paste your role pm in here, because i don't think that's kosher regardless of mod rules.
varsoon literally got banned a few months ago doing that.
These ones:In post 3393, Krazy wrote:Which of my posts specifically were "disgusting"?In post 3388, Dannflor wrote:I'm still 100% down for a Krazy lynch
his posts at the end of D1 were disgusting
In post 3019, Krazy wrote:oh ok dann is scum
In post 3037, Krazy wrote:Yeah except you've literally only ever pushed me when you're scum, Gamma
The OMGUS reaction was extreme and you refused to engage with me beyond thatIn post 3055, Krazy wrote:town Dann never writes this lolIn post 3015, Dannflor wrote:pedit: also bahahaha this whole "ooh how does fruit work let me bargain for it" the past 10 posts is so fucking fake
Every town role pm is going to be the same thing as that with minor changes, the one i quoted is the sample from the OP and it matches mine and Mastinas, cause they all do and the sample is available to veryoneIn post 3392, Firebringer wrote:mastina, i hope u didn't actually copy and paste your role pm in here, because i don't think that's kosher regardless of mod rules.
varsoon literally got banned a few months ago doing that.
decent point, krazy / LLD didn't feel alignedIn post 3397, Alisae wrote:Scum!Krazy jumping on the LLD wagon since the beginning before I posted endorsing it?
Idunno dude, I’m not exactly sure about that.
Because of things I talked about with Ali in the endgame of another game I had resolved to push you with renewed vigor but later I changed my mind and decided to hold off. As I see it my decision at this point looks to be the right one.In post 3391, Krazy wrote:Was this in response to something from this dayphase?In post 3377, Gamma Emerald wrote:Btw I won't be campaigning for a Krazy lynch yet but it's definitely something I'll keep in mind, I kinda expect good things from Krazy