Detective Penguin & City of Fogport [Game Over]

[Vecna]

^ another towny post

[Vecna]

VOTE: JJD

Whatever.

Either this flips scum, or it flips town meaning that Chennis can CPR-vig FL tonight. (I hope)

Pretty sure its either FL + bingle or PP + JJD.....

And the former is just more towny as a whole than the latter two by a decent margin. Even with all the scummy shit attached.

[Vecna]

I guess theres some very low outside possibility its PP + Chennis though.

Hmm

[Vecna]

FL

lol, nah

[Vecna]

VOTE: FL

[Vecna]

Hmmm, maybe I should vote Bingle to make things interesting?

[chennisden]

im not using my ability and getting caffenated.

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

i wasnt gonna check anyone who asked me to check them anyway lol

You don't have that many options though. We are 6, and 3 are untargetable, so 5. Two are you and PP, so 3. You already checked chenn, so that leaves either me of FL to check tonight, and FL is a Miller anyway, so the Naive Cop gets a clear and the Sane Cop gets a Guilty either way.

Bottom line, you can check me, myself or I!!!

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

VOTE: JJD

Whatever.

Either this flips scum, or it flips town meaning that Chennis can CPR-vig FL tonight. (I hope)

Pretty sure its either FL + bingle or PP + JJD.....

And the former is just more towny as a whole than the latter two by a decent margin. Even with all the scummy shit attached.

Mate, I am literally the only target the Cops can target tonight. Other than me, chenn can always CPR FL for reals if that's what you really want. So why don't we all lynch MARUIS who is both untargetable AND already caffeinated?

Scum will always try to shoot a COP here, but it's 50-50 they hit the sane cop. Right? So there is a 50-50 chance you get a solid inno on me (unless they don't shoot a Cop and then you 100% get an inno on me).

Meanwhile, FL is dead (unless scum want to waste their NK shooting him with chenn on him, which would bring us back to an ODD number )

If Marquis is scum and FL is his partner the game is OVER. If Marquis is scum and I'm his partner I am lynched tomorrow. If Marquis is scum with Bingle we get to a 3 players LyLo with you, Bingle and chenn.

If Marquis is Town you can do the math again, but you will get a better view still with the flips.

If I get lynched the Cops are both out of work anyway, and if FL is lynched then I am the only valid CPR shot when the Cops also have no one else to check but me!!

Do the math, Vecna. Mechanically it should be Marquis (even over Bingle) because he is already caffeinated, yet -uinlike myself or FL- he can neither be Copped nor killed by the CPR Doctor.

[Flavor Leaf]

Just kill Marquis. He’s obv scum

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

I mean, lynching Marquis is the right bloody move for the right bloody solve no matter what!

And now that chenn announced he isn't acting makes it even better. One more town slot for the scum to shoot, so they may leave the Cops alone.

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

VOTE: Marquis

[Bingle]

From town JJD's perspective, Marquis is conftown. JJD IS SMART ENOUGH TO FIGURE THAT OUT. JJD is pushing us to lynch Marquis first.

Therefore: JJD is scumlordz.

[Bingle]

Logical clear trains:

If JJD town -> Marquis town.
If PP & Croag town -> chenn town.

That's literally it. And somhow, JJD is arguing the sole lynch that he as town WOULD KNOW TO BE A MISLYNCH.

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

From town JJD's perspective, Marquis is conftown. JJD IS SMART ENOUGH TO FIGURE THAT OUT. JJD is pushing us to lynch Marquis first.

Therefore: JJD is scumlordz.

Explain this to me like I am 3 years, 5 months and 14 days old.

[Bingle]

I also don’t believe Fish was Vig killed. CprDoc killed him, and Marquis is covering for the CPR doc.

Which is why Marquis/JJD is possible.

But if chenn is scumCPR doc, one of the cops has to be covering for him thus scum, and Marquis would have to be town.

Alternatively, if CPRdoc didn't kill Fish, Marquis p much has to have. And again, he knew there were 2-3 town cops in a hood, a claimed town vig and 6 other roles of unknown power, and he supposedly CHOSE to shoot Fish for towncred. That's literally the hoop that JJD is jumping through here to justify a scumread on Marquis that doesn't involve JJD being scum first.

From town JJD's perspective, Marquis is conftown. JJD IS SMART ENOUGH TO FIGURE THAT OUT. JJD is pushing us to lynch Marquis first.

Therefore: JJD is scumlordz.

Why the fuck haven't I gotten this lynch yet? I've only been shouting for it for a month and a half.

I've explained it. Several times. You've quoted those explanations to say that the potential for Kuribo to be a PGO was laughable. Chenn has accused me of preaching a narrative, when said narrative is either you or marquis is responsible for the Fish kill. If you killed Fish, you're scum. If Marquis killed fish, Marquis is town. Ergo If JJD Town, Marquis Town.

[Flavor Leaf]

Logical clear trains:

If JJD town -> Marquis town.
If PP & Croag town -> chenn town.

That's literally it. And somhow, JJD is arguing the sole lynch that he as town WOULD KNOW TO BE A MISLYNCH.

Pp/Croag can be scum without Chenn.

[Bingle]

@Mod: please prod Marquis.

[Flavor Leaf]

Zero part of me believes Marquis killed Fish.

[Bingle]

Yes, the logical clears are one directional.

Our options here are Marquis killed Fish. JJD CPR docced Fish. Kuribo killed fish. Someone is fakeclaiming not having killed fish as town when we have confirmation on most roles.

I talked about why I don't believe 3. 4 would actually be gamethrowing. If Marquis is scum, it's with JJD, so we lynch JJD first.

[Bingle]

I suppose I should add chenn's theory. Marquis is a 2 shot scum vig who shot his own partner N1 because bussing.

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

Well, my theory is Marquis + BINGLE are scum, so with 2 untargetable scums they can literally bus the other 2 without having to worru about being caught.

And yes, I am saying 2 now because if there are 3 still alive you would have gone for about ANY mislynch you can get to win the game right here and now.

"JJD is smart enough to know Marquis should be cleared by now, yet he -JJD- is dumb enough to keep pushing in that direction". Are you nuts?

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

@Dingle: what's the name of the character in your avi?

[Bingle]

Who killed Fish in your proposed universe JJD?

[Bingle]

@Dingle: what's the name of the character in your avi?

Binky Barnes