I'm pretty sure everyone agreed after the fact that mislynching me was dumb and town should not have done it.In post 4322, Krazy wrote:Hmm while this may be a fair point, for people who were dead during the debate (i.e. ank) do you think ita possible yo have the opposite takeaway?
*nod nod* You're right. Although what does that have to do with this game?In post 4326, popsofctown wrote:Ank said she wanted to set up town to win Starry Night, then die, because she thought getting paranoia mislynched was inevitable. MariaR was a good partner for that because she wouldn't be as flighty as, like, Creature ended up being, and probably jammed with her some in the PT, I believe that was part of it. MariaR would increase the chances of getting paranoia mislynched but that wouldn't matter with regards to the strategy she was planning to follow.
I have no idea where you're going with this question but there you go. MariaR understood her reasons in the first instance and remembered them better, I'm sure.
She didn't state X-shot, I'd rather she not directly address your postIn post 4329, Something_Smart wrote:Unlimited-shot?
I have never.In post 3577, DrippingGoofball wrote:It's the outrage - it rings fake.In post 3547, Titus wrote:What did mastina lie about?
Like I said.In post 3586, GreyICE wrote:I can't shake the feeling that Pops watcher of Maria was designed to catch town power roles more than it was to catch scum.
In post 1083, Ankamius wrote:My playstyle is basically the scientific method; start with the conclusion and test it until I either disprove it or reach a point where I won't be able to anymore and need to confirm it completely via flips to continue
The goal isn't to lynch scum every day but to give myself enough information to properly narrow down who CAN be scum to put town in an unloseable situation
This is exactly how I played starry night
In post 3783, Aristophanes wrote:As I say, I quoted this one for 2 reasons. First was that I thought maybe Starty Night might have been a crumb. I checked and found nk shenanigans in that game so threw it out.
0/10
The second is what I meant earlier with the xof reasoning. Ank knows how to play and wasn't gunning for scum with this shot! They were aiming to "properly narrow down who can be scum" and got unlucky. Picking a dead null slot is a really good place to start on that front as town and scumreads both present problems, like death and redundancy. Picking xof makes so much sense and it is explained to us right here why they did so! Scientific method ftw!
Well I'm thinking about 1083 and how Ari chose to interpret 1083. My first thought was that 1083 has some things that could maybe go either way. But Ari seems to think 1083 is basically a slam dunk for it not being Mena --In post 4326, popsofctown wrote:Ank said she wanted to set up town to win Starry Night, then die, because she thought getting paranoia mislynched was inevitable. MariaR was a good partner for that because she wouldn't be as flighty as, like, Creature ended up being, and probably jammed with her some in the PT, I believe that was part of it. MariaR would increase the chances of getting paranoia mislynched but that wouldn't matter with regards to the strategy she was planning to follow.
I have no idea where you're going with this question but there you go. MariaR understood her reasons in the first instance and remembered them better, I'm sure.
Like "extremely misguided" is interesting language mostly because I've never seen Ari be this feisty before. Like, he feels a bit different here than Story Revisited, but that was long enough ago that maybe his playstyle changed. But this also is the second time Ari has started really pushing back against someone I scumread this game so I'm cautious.In post 4242, Aristophanes wrote:This is extremely misguided and I've already said why.
Really like this post btw and it increases my already large townread on Chickadee.In post 3600, Chickadee wrote:Mine looks like Mastina's copied role pm. Does yours not?In post 3383, Gamma Emerald wrote:Aren't role PMs supposed to be insanely customized or some shit? Mastina quoting hers is extremely ehhhhhhhAgain....does your role pm NOT follow the standard script?In post 3417, Gamma Emerald wrote:Okay I guess the "personalized role PM" thing never happened
I checked Ank's flip and the role wasn't woven in the flavor in any way
But there's the fact that Mastina had that available to just change to a bodyguard role PM so I'm not convinced by usage of the role PM to prove anything
My biggest thought is that DGB has a small, opportunistic ISO.
VOTE: DrippingGoofball
Technically speaking: I did land a shot; I correctly called that Ank would die.In post 3624, popsofctown wrote:I'm hesitant to lynch a bodyguard, but admittedly it'd take a long time for her to land her shot in a large.
I believe this but part of me wishes that more of your rage was faked
This^In post 4310, Something_Smart wrote:I would assume so I can gain history on what fruits were given out, and when, and why.In post 4308, popsofctown wrote:Why would you suggest he read Pine's iso?
Ecchhh. I already jumped down a rabbit hole in joining this game in the first place. I ain't jumping down another one quite yet.In post 4343, Chickadee wrote:Just because pine is scum doesn't mean we can't learn anything from him.
I mean, to you it is, but even if Ari believes your watch results I still don't see why he wouldn't take a look at Starry Night and at least think about what it means that she danced with Maria. Again, I'm not saying I think Ank checked Maria, I'm trying to figure out why Ari would go into 1083 specifically looking for crumbs and *not* come up with Maria lol. Like if he was just ruling it out because of your check then I would presume he would have said so because that's a deeper thought process than just ignoring how the dance worksIn post 4342, popsofctown wrote:ftr Krazy you do know it's mechanically confirmed that Ank did not hide with MariaR right?
He is a strong townread for what it's worth.In post 3631, popsofctown wrote:I think I'm never voting GreyICE this game.
I follow, it was just a ftr matter-of-fact thing, thought it was possible not to infer because sometimes I think of hider as in a weird and intangible state when they're hiding, but they would actually generate a watch result.In post 4345, Krazy wrote:I mean, to you it is, but even if Ari believes your watch results I still don't see why he wouldn't take a look at Starry Night and at least think about what it means that she danced with Maria. Again, I'm not saying I think Ank checked Maria, I'm trying to figure out why Ari would go into 1083 specifically looking for crumbs and *not* come up with Maria lol. Like if he was just ruling it out because of your check then I would presume he would have said so because that's a deeper thought process than just ignoring how the dance worksIn post 4342, popsofctown wrote:ftr Krazy you do know it's mechanically confirmed that Ank did not hide with MariaR right?
VOTE: Aristophanes.
Pretty much, yes.In post 3671, GreyICE wrote:In post 3662, Aristophanes wrote:Ank crumbed Xof pretty obviously imo. Also I'm at daystart so if this has been said in the last 20 pages or if the subject has moved on then I apologize.The hider obviously hid behind Xof.
Who knows what killed them? I'm down for a mastina wagon!
...
COULD YOU BE SLIGHTLY MORE OBVIOUS ABOUT BEING SCUM
Vote: Aristophanes
NO
