Kerset NK strikes me as interesting by the way. I was actually slightly scumreading them while catching up so it came as a surprise. IMO Mack came off as fairly townish & I am surprised by all the people screaming Mackscum. When you combine the two I get the feeling that he is scum's choice mislynch - otherwise the game might have gone down a different path, a path where Mack is obvtown & would have been a good target for the night.
In post 624, Aisa wrote:@Dongempire are you fully caught up? What has your discussion with Rob told you?
@Rob what has your discussion with Dongempire told you?
A lot of it comes off as pointless playstyle discussion tbh. I mean, I'm all for discussing playstyle but there
is
a separate section of the forum devoted to just that...
Not really, and i dont intend to. I'll read parts of the game as necessary but from what i gather reading the previous posts is unneccesary and we can advance with whatever we discuss here.
Provided that people play that is...
As for the discussion, it cleared up a few things. Its a pointless question though, if i need to say something i will, if i dont im not going to post fluff. For now i do not believe i need to elaborate on what i gathered since it would be considered shading.
Age of Empires Elo: 1500 something in DE, 1800 in HD
Formerly Dongempire
At this point indon't really have much to add, i think me and rob were good potential mislynch and kerset was giving us the best deductions. Im still gutted as at one point i was with him on the Cyrus situation. Fact is i think his lynching was his own fault and he made it easy for scum to get by first night.
Rob im not reading as scum despite his aggro play, doc is probably still my biggest scum, and not really because he came straight for me at the start of be day. I dont like his whole play, appearing randomly, not offering anything and ignoring any questions i pose to him.
Still my vote will remain, while its possible claimnow has 85 posts in a pt after 24 hrs, i think the fact that someone has a confirmed private section gives us the best probability of scum.
I dont like bossing people around, but you should unvote. Plenty of time and with plenty of inactive players that could be scum. Rushing a lynch and flipping town, hell even flipping scum is beneficial for mafia since we'll be in the dark tomorrow.
Instead of tunnelling one guy, let him post more and fos him if you need to.
Age of Empires Elo: 1500 something in DE, 1800 in HD
Formerly Dongempire
In post 626, Robbnva wrote:I want to hear from doc. I want to see dong make a case on somebody. I’d like something original from Mack.
The others can probably make cases also. If people want to not rely on a scum slip, let’s see you rely on something else
You can too. You seem to be coasting today.
I'll make a case on someone when i can actually engage with someone, all day i could only talk to one person. Not gonna dig up 20 pages of cyrusposting and one liners, both since its not as important as discussing 1 on 1 and because im not gonna sludge through that especially if the town seems intent on not playing.
Age of Empires Elo: 1500 something in DE, 1800 in HD
Formerly Dongempire
Alright i'll read up to last days lynch and make associations then. Still not going to make a case on anyone until im confident but more fruitfull posts coming
Age of Empires Elo: 1500 something in DE, 1800 in HD
Formerly Dongempire
In post 634, Donempire wrote:Alright i'll read up to last days lynch and make associations then. Still not going to make a case on anyone until im confident but more fruitfull posts coming
Right I took a look at Doc's other games. In this game they were town, and it's troubling how they were being vague about their read on a player, and inactive but promising to contribute more. Sigh. I was trying to make a case.
Now not keeping into account some instances of being inactive or vague, what still looks suspicious to me is
In post 80, Doctor Drew wrote:If Cyrus would stop tunneling me with bad logic we get somewhere here.
In post 116, Doctor Drew wrote:I still think seems town Cyrus to me, I am not gung ho about it though.
Mackenzie, how many games of mafia have you played?
Pre Edit: I consider him the ultimate stream of consciousness player.
In post 504, Robbnva wrote:I don’t see any examples in any of claim’s other games that he has a notes PF. I don’t think he created one for here and I definitely don’t see content that matches 85 post made in his forum.
I can only think this is the only thing that makes sense to me.
Makes sense......but what is your opinion on Mackenzie?
Obviously an attempt to get people to vote Mack, but why? Does he just expect results without having to explain his read?
In post 538, Doctor Drew wrote:I am not buying Claim is scum, I get where you are coming from Robb......but I think in fact you have different reasons for calling this a scum play.
Come join me on the Mackenzie wagon and we will talk.
In post 630, Mackenie wrote:At this point indon't really have much to add, i think me and rob were good potential mislynch and kerset was giving us the best deductions.
Im still gutted as at one point i was with him on the Cyrus situation. Fact is i think his lynching was his own fault and he made it easy for scum to get by first night.
His last post was a prod dodge. He’s posted elsewhere on site this weekend.
After the dive into his previous games I'm not sure sure anymore lol. It is annoying that he has posted elsewhere, but I think I'd prefer Claim at this point.
In post 599, emps wrote:"jacking off into the sunset" lmao wut
claim, wanna explain ur mack scumread?
How sure are you that Claim is scum? Is that who you're intent on lynching today? Is that why you haven't been active?
im pretty confident claim is scum. yes, i can compromise on doc tho. nah not really mostly just tired from rl stuffs
"I guess gay erotic fanfics are the key to healthy game discussion." -HoldenGolden
"making friends is dangerous emps. always be on guard." -the worst
"Children are sticky." -MaryJoLisa
"What if a guy and a girl meet online, and then face to face, and have children. Are their kids real?" -MaryJoLisa
