Alisae V Pine: Trees Apparently Make Good Treestumps

[Menalque]

fucking shoot me in the face

[Menalque]

suprisingly solid pagetop there

[Alisae]

My pagetop was better -_-

[Pink Ball]

Hahahahahahahahahahahahahaha

[Elsa Jay]

So I'm honored I was invited... As a secondary option.

But I'm here now. So. Uh. Let's solve this.

[Pine]

I came because Pine begged for help. Not my fault guys.

[Dannflor]

HI HOW CAN WE SOLVE THIS GAME

[Menalque]

Kats can I get an answer about why GreyICE v lld couldn’t have been faked that’s not “he’s not emotionally retarded”?

Because if they’re both scum then they could have both been faking that emotion, in which case the whole “he’s not emotionally retarded” argument doesn’t hold any water

I guarantee you from all my years of knowing the both of them, that first off Lexi's emotions weren't faked. I didn't push the lynch hard because I was genuinely concerned for her emotional well-being. Secondly, it's a stupid way of playing scum. I don't know how players play nowadays but there is no way either of them play that way as scum/scum for the sake of "scum theater" when it is wholly unnecessary since you can just play straight up and win in an easier (and more fun) manner.

The whole "OH BUT THEY COULD'VE FAKED IT" is a stupid line of thought if you take everything into account. Tinfoil hat arguments are what scum employ to get mislynches.

can you not see why fmpov this is hard to go with:

okay, you may have known them for ages, and you may think that's right. but for me there are a whole load of questions hanging over it: (1) are you scum and if so are you lying to me about your impression on lld's emotions? (2) if you and gICE

are

both scum (which I don't think you are but which you could be) then actually it's kind of genius bc we're still arguing about it today but it got both of you a shit ton of towncred. so it's potentially worth bussing a strong scum player D1 then letting a couple of the scumteam sit back while others focus on managing the game state (pops, Titus). if the ones who are managing fuck up then you have the players with D1 cred as back up.

also like pine is someone who I wouldn't put it past to do some sort of weird fucking strategy like that

specifically in this game

even if it's normal a solid assumption that tinfoil is scum friendly

plus the fact that we've had a shitload of town die since then without getting any scum

[Jingle]

So I'm honored I was invited... As a secondary option.

I was afraid you'd give some of our older players strokes. Luckily, they're mostly dead now.

[Elsa Jay]

Well I'm not known for giving out handjobs, no.

[Pine]

So I'm honored I was invited... As a secondary option.

I was afraid you'd give some of our older players strokes. Luckily, they're mostly dead now.

Speak for yourself, Jingle. I’d rather play with the precocious newbie (Hi Menalque!)

[Menalque]

Like think about it for a moment

Would you as a friend, let alone as a husband, intentionally play in a manner that results in the least amount of fun derived for someone you like?

same issues as the last post

I wouldn't. but do I think some people would? sure. do I think gICE is one of them? no idea. do I know them well enough to not think it might be fun for them to try faking as much emotion as possible to fool town and then also enjoying that it sets them up to win the game potentially? also no idea.

and you just saying "trust me I have meta with them" doesn't really help because idk if I can trust you

[Menalque]

So I'm honored I was invited... As a secondary option.

I was afraid you'd give some of our older players strokes. Luckily, they're mostly dead now.

Speak for yourself, Jingle. I’d rather play with the precocious newbie (Hi Menalque!)

This actually makes me think I'm on the right track and you wanted elsa here to distract me

[popsofctown]

Please lynch me for giving Jingle flawed imgur links to Pandora's face

[popsofctown]

UNVOTE:

[popsofctown]

9303 is giving me issues (I didn't yet read it as of my posting 9307)

[Pink Ball]

UNVOTE:

You were already not voting anyone. Who do thought you were voting?

[Jingle]

Speak for yourself, Jingle. I’d rather play with the precocious newbie (Hi Menalque!)

Pine, IRL:

[Elsa Jay]

if anyone wants to convince me why we're murdering the Penguin that would be great.

if i win this as [

Insert Role Here

] that would be amazing. its a shitty role but ah well.

[Dannflor]

mena

I'm not looking for an ISO or case

I just want you to say specifically what about her behavior made you think she made the most sense as scum

I feel like this shouldn't be hard to answer or you shouldn't have to go back to "refresh your memory" if she's that big of a scum read. Just like... what did she do?

If it's purely a game state read why specifically does that game state read exist? for what reasons does pops!town make less sense given the gamestate?

[Elsa Jay]

Pine is offering a Watcher fruit. MariaR and Gamma Emerald are bargaining for it.
Pine is offering a Vigilante fruit. Titus, Menalque, and MariaR are bargaining for it.

Is this a legit thing btw or is it flavor?

[Alisae]

A Deal With the Devil

Unlike most coniferous trees, Pine has found a way to produce delicious, fleshy fruit that give the consumer incredible power. Feel free to approach the Great Lord of the Forest for these powers, but be forewarned, Pine is tricky. I can't guarantee that these fruit are safe. The only thing I can say for sure is that Pine will not lie about what the fruit can do. He doesn't have to give them away when asked. Pine creates 2 of these fruit per day. If you would like to request a fruit from Pine, post

Bargain: [Fruit]

. Pine will either grant or refuse your request.

[Alisae]

Pine will not lie about the abilities of his gifts or their mechanics. He may omit information.
A Player may not both use a fruit and use a power in the same phase unless they are Multitasking.

[Elsa Jay]

neato.

if Pine gives me the Vigilante fruit I can probably actually have fun tonight. i saw something about Masons? hope i don't shoot them.

[Alisae]

Oh yeah I have 2 of those