Alisae V Pine: Trees Apparently Make Good Treestumps

[Iconeum]

what does scum!kats have to gain from that claim?

[Iconeum]

for the record, I think it's a bullshit claim 100%

[Wooper]

I think so too but it's Ali's call to make

it's an antispew claim, don't think he needs to gain anything from it other than just not needing to play lylo

[Alisae]

is anyone defending it?

not sure ico had fully registered

you realize if no one is defending it its likely town right?

[Wooper]

for a literal scumclaim?
who is gonna defend that

[Wooper]

I legit don't see a way to defend Kats
like I couldn't fake one if I was scum here
if this is his scum strat I don't see the benefit of defending him here
if this is his town strat..... ?_? none of it really checks out to me

[Alisae]

for a literal scumclaim?
who is gonna defend that

me

[Wooper]

alright do it

get out of your armchair and explain town!kats to me

[Alisae]

seems like a mislynch myguy

[Wooper]

get out of your armchair

[Wooper]

I don't give a shit if you think at a theoretical level you think no one defending him means he's >rand town

I don't give a shit about your gamestate read because I'm reading it perfectly backwards

throw me a case. throw me something. like fmpov he's extremely clearly scum

[Iconeum]

ok ali

not kats

then who?

[Alisae]

I honestly care more about who is town atm then who is scum
let's start building a townbloc
SS, MariaR, Kats
lets start with those 3 for the foundation of our townbloc

[Wooper]

alright whatever Ali, good luck with the game and all, I'll be here if you endorse a lynch. still think Gamma's more than likely town. Ico might actually be town after all.

[Alisae]

one thing I am really having issue with is his town motivation for whatever it is he did today

[Wooper]

Or why Jingle gives a beloved princess to someone who's going to be here lategame in a townsided role allocation. or why kats has used it as a method to duck being lynched rather than trying to actually play his negative utility.

like his play makes 0 sense for a negative utility town role and I don't really think jingle assigns it to him over someone who's more likely to be lolnk'd given he's townsiding and it's a negative utility

I can see one like potential town motivation but it's dubious

I'll bbl

[Alisae]

okay but there's 4 other scum

[Iconeum]

we can totally ignore kats for now if that's what ali wants

[Alisae]

please I really feel like he's being set up just to have people dogpiled on him
tw, what's scaring me right now is that there's 4 other scum even if you scumread Katsuki, and you seem like you're putting your eggs into 1 basket here

[Iconeum]

I actually understand the duck on that. We are never finding the entire scumteam today (let alone a large enough towncore), and if we are to salvage this game we need to start with a scumlynch and work from there

[Alisae]

I mean I am parking my endorsement on Dannflor because I personally feel like that's safe for me.

[Iconeum]

kats/fire/dann/pp

would lynch in here and in that order, too

probably not based on enough actual material, but it is what it is

[Alisae]

Why firebringer
Why PP

[Alisae]

I'm sorry if I seem like some bad guy for asking for explanations for why you scumread people
but I'm actually not considering the circumstances.

[Iconeum]

I think pp's claim would fit a scumteam. FB seems content with the current gamestate and is posting to just be here?

Not the best cases or anything, but it's what I think. All based on my readthrough from today.