Mainstream Mafia II: D&D Edition [FIN]

[chkflip]

election count 1.4

No Governor -

Bingle, xofelf, Cephrir, davesaz, Gamma Emerald, Iconeum, InsideJob711

Menalque -

EspressoPatronum, Menalque, Dr Easy Bake, Elements, gobbledygook, AaronFrost, RCEnigma

Untrod Tripod -

Untrod Tripod, zoraster, Wooper

Hectic -

Elements

Nero Cain -

Nero Cain

Firebringer -

Firebringer

Amrun -

chennisden

With 40 Alive, it takes 21 to elect a Governor.
You have (expired on 2019-11-16 22:00:00) left in this phase.

@MOD: Can one use the Governor ability on oneself?

No.

[Doctor Drew]

election count 1.4

No Governor -

Bingle, xofelf, Cephrir, davesaz, Gamma Emerald, Iconeum, InsideJob711

Menalque -

EspressoPatronum, Menalque, Dr Easy Bake, Elements, gobbledygook, AaronFrost, RCEnigma

Untrod Tripod -

Untrod Tripod, zoraster, Wooper

Hectic -

Elements

Nero Cain -

Nero Cain

Firebringer -

Firebringer

Amrun -

chennisden

With 40 Alive, it takes 21 to elect a Governor.
You have (expired on 2019-11-16 22:00:00) left in this phase.

@MOD: Can one use the Governor ability on oneself?

No.

I, for some reason, am voting for Menalque.

[chkflip]

Every vote prior to post 185 was not counted.

[Doctor Drew]

Every vote prior to post 185 was not counted.

Well shit.

At least now I don't have to vote for him.

[Amrun]

VOTE: amrun

I really don’t want to be governor. It’s garbage.

Theory-crafting wise, Bingle is right. That’s kind of boring though and this game has 40 players so idgaf really in the end. Kill some fuckers off.

[Amrun]

If xofelf or chemist turns out to be scum, they are not scum together. I don’t know xofelf but she seems a little clueless/confused for her join date but I can’t tell if it’s a tell or not since I don’t know if it’s normal.

xof doesn't play mafia very often and was very lynchbaity in AlivPine recently.

I can confirm that me arguing optimal townstrats is my bread and butter as both alignments.

Mena seems very unconcerned with being vocal and thus killed for a 3p.

On the first two counts, I figured as much.

About mena, I agree. It’s odd. There is no one I want LESS to be governor.

Why do you think governor nets us information, btw?

I never said it did.

It could, or it could be wasteful. This was addressed to me, I think, but was it supposed to be addressed to someone else? I didn’t previously comment on the governor role at all.

[davesaz]

@MOD: can we have counts in the VC in addition to the list?

Doesn't matter a whole lot yet as it's obviously way fewer than 21, but it would be a good habit to get into for later.

[Firebringer]

RCEnigma is town because i can't think of a game he was scum in.

scummy reason (no opinion on the read obv)

ok

[Bingle]

Jesus, this game.

Some kind soul want to sum up what has happened so far?

Well, first the earth cooled and the dinosaurs came. And then a bunch of people were all like "Governor isn't terrible for town regardless of who gets it" and "Giving scum a potential advantage is going to give us INFORMATION!" And then Eminem locked Dr Drew in his basement. Or was it Dr. Dre? Iunno, all Dr. D's are pretty much the same.

[Formerfish]

Bingle, dance with me.

[Bingle]

VOTE: Untrod Tripod for Governor.

Having a 1-shot governor be able to stop a lynch out of 40 people is fine, pro-information, and voting no governor gets nothing.

Zoraster is town. (Long time no see btw). His thoughts basically echo mine. I had no idea game started.

Thoughts?

[Bingle]

Bingle, dance with me.

[chennisden]

looks like I didn't read the game...

VOTE: no gov

[Amrun]

VOTE: Untrod Tripod for Governor.

Having a 1-shot governor be able to stop a lynch out of 40 people is fine, pro-information, and voting no governor gets nothing.

Zoraster is town. (Long time no see btw). His thoughts basically echo mine. I had no idea game started.

Thoughts?

Shared above. Technically, the correct thing to do is no lynch. That is boring and not fun. There are also too many people in this game so thinning the herd makes me happy in my soul. Theoretically, any flip would add information. In practice, it may not, especially in a game so big where some people have said nothing, or little of substance. My heart says yes but my brain says no. Zoraster’s opinion doesn’t make me think he’s not town, though, if that’s what you were asking.

[Formerfish]

Bingle, dance with me.

Is that you taking me up on my offer?

We have things to discuss and they are very relevant to the game.

[Amrun]

VOTE: Untrod Tripod for Governor.

Having a 1-shot governor be able to stop a lynch out of 40 people is fine, pro-information, and voting no governor gets nothing.

Zoraster is town. (Long time no see btw). His thoughts basically echo mine. I had no idea game started.

Thoughts?

I just realized you thought I agreed 100% with everything he said. I specifically was talking about the fact that early posting could be a very minor indication of scummishness, or at the very least, him having the exact same experience as me (being like wtf, game started?) made me feel like he was town since I related. I also think that experience would be unlikely to happen for scum.

[Firebringer]

looks like I didn't read the game...

VOTE: no gov

vote me for president mr chennisden

[chennisden]

no mr fb

[Firebringer]

why not

[Iconeum]

why are there players voting elsewhere then No Gov?

unless ya'll wanna be recruited?

[Bingle]

I just realized you thought I agreed 100% with everything he said. I specifically was talking about the fact that early posting could be a very minor indication of scummishness, or at the very least, him having the exact same experience as me (being like wtf, game started?) made me feel like he was town since I related. I also think that experience would be unlikely to happen for scum.

Oh, I realized that you could have only agreed with one of the two things he said. I just wanted to see how you responded there, tbh. I also vaguely agree that the thought of "Person saw game unreasonably fast and is thus slightly more scum equity" is townish.

[Bingle]

Why do you think governor nets us information, btw?

@Zor:

This question.

[Bingle]

We have things to discuss and they are very relevant to the game.

Things, Mr. Man? What things be those?

[Iconeum]

Ok after reading that, these are my off the cuff impressions:

If xofelf or chemist turns out to be scum, they are not scum together. I don’t know xofelf but she seems a little clueless/confused for her join date but I can’t tell if it’s a tell or not since I don’t know if it’s normal.

UT seems town to me so far. He is usually an easy read for me, from years ago.

Melnaque seems to have an ulterior motive, but not necessarily scum. Maybe third party.

Bingle is pushing his agenda hard. My gut says that’s a personality trait that he’d do as any loyalty but I’ll wait and see.

Zoraster is town. (Long time no see btw). His thoughts basically echo mine. I had no idea game started.

Bbmolla is acting scummy (for him)

Nero Cain seems town - doesn’t seem concerned with his appearance or how his posts will “seem”

Full disclosure: I have a 60hr/wk job and a 1 year old toddler. I am extremely busy. I’m not sure what my presence will be like in such a big game. I won’t disappear but I won’t be available Willy nilly- maybe one or two dedicated short time periods per day for this game, period, at least until it gets smaller and moves slower. But I will do my best to be active enough to make an impact. It’s been a long time since I’ve played.

nice shotgun reads

[Iconeum]

@Amrun

Wrt Bingle, I see Bingle pushing an agenda solely related to the banning of an anti-town role. Why the shade?
Wrt Bbmolla, got anything concrete other then 'he is scummy for his doing'?
Wrt Menal, how are you even managing a third party read at this time?

Can we vote to lynch already or?