Mainstream Mafia II: D&D Edition [FIN]

[Menalque]

I think I’m ?

Maybe ??

TRing ???

Nero ???????

[Menalque]

Idk, is Nero good at scum?

[Nero Cain]

im ok

[Hectic]

Hectic awoke with a start. His dreams had been filled with cults and bus drivers, and the transition into wakefulness took longer than normal.

His eyes adjusted to the surroundings and he groaned. It was a groan of a man who knew he had truly

fucked up

. The clock on the wall read 1pm.

1pm.

What did that mean? Well, it meant he was going to be late to the mafia game of course. He could only imagine the bulky bandwagon that would've formed outside his door. This wasn't going to be fun.

He sighed and leapt off the bed, strolling with feigned confidence - just in case there were any hidden cameras - towards the desk on the opposite end of the room. Speaking of the room, it was clinical and extremely clean. Almost

too

clean for comfort. Did that mean he was a doctor this time?

He peered down at the dusty role PM that lay upon the desk. This was the moment of truth. He reluctantly picked it up, accepting whatever fate that the Old Gods had in store for him.

Bulletproof Lynchproof Town 10-shot Day Vigilante.

For a moment, Hectic simply stared at the sheet of paper. He hadn't recieved a role PM in many years and this one could very well be his last.

Finally, he set the PM down. It wasn't great, but it wasn't his worst either. Most importantly, it was something he could work with.

[Menalque]

This amrun wagon feels weird.

I might be biased but I feel her case on me comes from town.

Okay why?

I should add: I did consider this, but overall it feels more like a scum thought process “this person has done things that are not towny, therefore I will look towny if I push them and if I point out the non-towny things they did other people are more likely to vote them and to believe that I’m town”

Like I certainly have a tendency to do this as scum, whereas I think when I’m town I’m more open to thinking “okay, that’s antitown, but is it actually scum?”

[TrueSoulEnergy]

you can ISO me for Gamma

.

I don't like the fake post restriction and I think that's somewhat likely to come from scum. And they aren't doing much of anything.

Why would you think the unbolded was about you and not the bolded?

Why would you rely on someone else to ISO you can complain that they didn’t think you meant for them to actually do it?

Gamma and I have a lengthy back and forth. There was no way I was gonna requote it myself and I didn't want to type a lengthy post b/c ya know effort. So telling him to read what I've already wrote seems like a perfectly good thing to do.

Why did you vote me over Cephir? Why have you called everyone that suspected you scum (me, chen, chem) but not cephir?

So Gamma was too lazy to read it himself yet YOU decide to request someone else to do it?
Also “everyone who suspected me scum”
Not at all.
Chemist maybe, but Chunn didn’t suspect me but I Scum Read Him for the way he choose to make his Decision.
And I don’t like the way you made Cephir’s vote on me look better then it actually was.
Like Cephir was like “I’ll vote TSE because Gut scummy”
You made it seem at least to me that he had a really good reason to vote me.
Which I feel is scummy. So I voted you.

[TrueSoulEnergy]

Idk, is Nero good at scum?

Anyone can be good at scum TBH.

[Menalque]

I might mod a game in the future where everyone is post restricted to only write as a noir PI

[Menalque]

Idk, is Nero good at scum?

Anyone can be good at scum TBH.

Not rly answering my question

[Firebringer]

This amrun wagon feels weird.

I might be biased but I feel her case on me comes from town.

Okay why?

Her reaction to me in the initial phases was pretty natural even if it was wrong approach to take. I don’t think scum fake that path to go for a scumread. She basically interacted with me to my expectations of someone who hasn’t played with me and who has the personality of amrun has (at least as much of her personality I can analyze thus far)

I also generally don’t think scum actually go for “lynch baity” players as scum. I find scum argue a town is going for someone who is lynch baity more often than the scum to be doing it. So I am weakly in the town amrun camp right now.

Even though I don’t like her approach to me and think she is playing kind of low level while she probably thinks she is doing higher level analysis.

[TrueSoulEnergy]

I dunno if I should be scumreading TSE or just annoyed.

I just didn’t like what you do.
Why would you scum read me for finding your post scummy?
Do town credit posts or your def a lynch option for me.

[TrueSoulEnergy]

She could be scum. Idk. I want to know why she scum read every one that called her scum except the person that voted her.

I’m a Guy.

[TrueSoulEnergy]

Dose the name “Seth” sound like a female to you?

[Menalque]

This amrun wagon feels weird.

I might be biased but I feel her case on me comes from town.

Okay why?

Her reaction to me in the initial phases was pretty natural even if it was wrong approach to take. I don’t think scum fake that path to go for a scumread. She basically interacted with me to my expectations of someone who hasn’t played with me and who has the personality of amrun has (at least as much of her personality I can analyze thus far)

I also generally don’t think scum actually go for “lynch baity” players as scum. I find scum argue a town is going for someone who is lynch baity more often than the scum to be doing it. So I am weakly in the town amrun camp right now.

Even though I don’t like her approach to me and think she is playing kind of low level while she probably thinks she is doing higher level analysis.

What did you think of the post I wrote simultaneously to you writing this one explaining why I’d had similar thoughts but still thought her post seemed more like “finding someone to lynch” rather than actually sorting

[Menalque]

She could be scum. Idk. I want to know why she scum read every one that called her scum except the person that voted her.

I’m a Guy.

P sure this is about amrun?

[TrueSoulEnergy]

or

I'm not sure if Chem and Chen called her scum but I know she called them scum and called me scum and voted me b/c I said I was waffling on my read.

But the person that's voting her and calling her scum isn't treated the same way? It's kinda funky.

Also the main reason I Scum Read Chemist isn’t that he scum read me.
It’s

How

he scum read me. Or rather what he said to throw shade on me.

[Menalque]

Oh or maybe not

[TrueSoulEnergy]

She could be scum. Idk. I want to know why she scum read every one that called her scum except the person that voted her.

I’m a Guy.

P sure this is about amrun?

But if you look below that post it talks about me.
And it’s also by Nero.

[Menalque]

Thought Nero was responding to fb’s comment about the amrun wagon seeming funky

[TrueSoulEnergy]

Thought Nero was responding to fb’s comment about the amrun wagon seeming funky

TBH it could easily be a miss Lynch.
From my experience the best Lynch is to do it in the middle of near the end of Day 1.
Usually pulling and pushing a lynch from there can hit scum.
Most first pushes of Day 1 is either a miss Lynch, joke vote or a scum bus.

[Nero Cain]

I thought TSE was a girl, sorry.

[Firebringer]

This amrun wagon feels weird.

I might be biased but I feel her case on me comes from town.

Okay why?

Her reaction to me in the initial phases was pretty natural even if it was wrong approach to take. I don’t think scum fake that path to go for a scumread. She basically interacted with me to my expectations of someone who hasn’t played with me and who has the personality of amrun has (at least as much of her personality I can analyze thus far)

I also generally don’t think scum actually go for “lynch baity” players as scum. I find scum argue a town is going for someone who is lynch baity more often than the scum to be doing it. So I am weakly in the town amrun camp right now.

Even though I don’t like her approach to me and think she is playing kind of low level while she probably thinks she is doing higher level analysis.

What did you think of the post I wrote simultaneously to you writing this one explaining why I’d had similar thoughts but still thought her post seemed more like “finding someone to lynch” rather than actually sorting

I can see that argument there’s like lots of weird certainty in amrun that makes me go “okay are you like thinking about this in depth or just reacting here” but at same time I don’t think it’s literally just find someone to lynch even though it feels flimsy with all her pushing and reads.

Right now I am just in the camp her kind of way of sorting just makes these kinds of reads where she takes a post and makes a big leap on them without doing a heavy amount of counter thought to it.

Does that make sense?

Like everything she has done could come from scum just trying to look like sorting but it doesn’t feel like it is. These feel like her actual thoughts and responses it’s just that they suck.

[Nero Cain]

So Gamma was too lazy to read it himself yet YOU decide to request someone else to do it?

mena asked me about my Gamma read. I think its a perfectly reasonable reply to tell him that I've already typed a bunch of stuff up and he can go read it if he wants. Whether he does or not is irrelevant.

And I don’t like the way you made Cephir’s vote on me look better then it actually was

back in the election stage, I said that I wasn't scumreading you. I have an unexplained reservation about your slot but I'm not gung ho about it so I was being open and honest about my feelings.

[Firebringer]

I am doing way too much analysis for a meme game someone slap me

[InsideJob711]

Alisae

locktown