In post 1591, tris wrote:i guess i'll just say a little more on each player.
sheep:
I don't like how all he's been doing is saying he scumreads me. something about it reminds me of when scum has scumread me in the past.
nacl:
i'm still unsure on this. i don't think i'm very good at reading him. somethings he says seem like they might come from town, but i also felt that way in haunted town where he was scum. there's also some statements that seem a little off to me, but that might just come from a different perspective as a player.
AbuHumaid:
hasn't really been doing much. maybe just scum by poe.
pops:
I townread her earlier in the game, but i've been getting the feeling lately that she hasn't really been pushing a town agenda. i don't find much reason to townread her
unwnd:
you keep having posts that feel like they come from town. usually when there's a player i feel this way about, they're town. and this claiming business doesn't seem scum motivated.
dunn:
i remember townreading some stuff from day 1 which i'll have to go look at again. and also like you, i'm trusting DNS's read a bit.
DEB:
i've read a game that had scum!DEB. there, he basically didn't do anything. here, he's actually has SOME opinion (even though it's wrong).
Yeah, I'm worried about
sheep
too. I've been worried about him. The presence he had at the start of his replacement does not nearly stack up to what he is doing now. We have different reference but if he's going to scumread you I don't know why he tries to I dunno, develop it? I would really love to see that more. Do you think Sheep acting the way is indicative of scum or an apathetic townie that doesn't know what to do? This is slightly rhetorical. I think being apathetic has worked well for scum and it's definitely their agenda right now as town is willingly creating the environment to do so. I think the conclusions he makes are essentially uh, not there and if it's a motivation factor then yeah time to speak up or else I'm gonna agree something's up.
NAcL
is a curious case, one I've even talked about it in some form. I think what I felt still remains true, if anything it's been heightened. He's always exhibiting right-time-right-moment behavior where he picks and chooses where he interacts with the thread. I appreciate that he isn't just firing off reads into the ether but at the same time is what he's saying ultimately changing anything? With himself? With others? I don't really think so. I think it's different to say what you're thinking and just saying things just to well, say stuff. I feel like he's just saying stuff to put it simply. I appreciate the thoughts but if they're being made with no goal in mind it lacks town motive. Even if the most braindead and incoherent town
TSE
say things that mean something to them. The reason that I feel it means nothing because it's kinda like he presents his opinions but then they don't come to anything else. I'm certain he's responded to me and I ignored it, but I dunno if me confronting NAcL will do anything though, I would just prefer if he didn't have to be confronted at all yknow? The fact he does to merit more than just a bullet list of opinions he's been giving throughout has me weary.
Abu
is probably just scum. Not gonna bother explaining why it should be obvious to anyone. I think nobody disagrees but perhaps we've been giving his mates a liability to be like 'well he's so obvious so let's try and weed out the other mates' but we're here now and I'm totally fine with lynching him. I can't see this game ever existing where he isn't scum.
I agree with you about
Pops
. I have no reason to townread her anymore and that's unfortunate given her honest effort to like I dunno, be something more than the types I've described earlier. I empathetically townread it but rn I'm looking at it like..what is Pops achieving as well? I townread her strange behavior earlier but now that Weh flipped green I'm just wondering what the next course of action is for her, and seeing Weh flip green makes me look at the previous day a bit differently. I like when people are sure about their scumreads but there really was no flexibility. There hasn't been any flexibility. I find myself concluding a lot of behavior similar to others I have problems with but then it turns into the idea that town really is just that deflated. I like that Pops tries to respond to me or even consider what I'm saying, it's cool to some sort of feedback. I wouldn't mind being on the listening end however if she does happen to be town though.
unwnd
is just stupid and bad!
Dunn
probably town I just wish he didn't scumread me cause I have a pet peeve about players who play like Dunn scumreading me because there is no exact reasoning with them on a fundamental level of talking it out it's just like ok make up your mind.
DEB
I really don't know lol. I need more. I neeeeed moreeee.