Dance of the Title Thread: Resurgence in wild?

[vonflare]

NOM mcmemo for 'no title'

[Errantparabola]

nth emotion picture & still reeling

nom plotinus for

Kitten Caboodle

1. we in the titling community love puns (?)
2. cats
3. sort of alluding to the thoroughness of plotinus posting
4. going back to the "categories" discussion that only me and keely had earlier (from the newbie games)
5. cute title

[CheekyTeeky]

Oh yes please give Plot a cat title

"Purrfection" could be an ode to his modding high standard, experience and cats!

[CheekyTeeky]

Kitten Caboodle sounds cute but I don't really understand what it means. Happy to nom there if it gains traction.

[CheekyTeeky]

Oh...kit and caboodle means having everything.

nth Kitten Caboodle

[mastina]

One way to find out

Nom Psyche for "it"

As a title for Psyche,

ick

.

[mastina]

nom plotinus for

Kitten Caboodle

1. we in the titling community love puns (?)
2. cats
3. sort of alluding to the thoroughness of plotinus posting
4. going back to the "categories" discussion that only me and keely had earlier (from the newbie games)
5. cute title

Plotinus absolutely deserves a title, sure, but I'm not sure that this is the one. It feels incredibly forced to me, and while I'd love to have Plotinus be titled, trying to force a title onto Plot won't generate a good title.

[Enter]

One way to find out

Nom Psyche for "it"

As a title for Psyche,

ick

.

Spoiler: Please? At least give him the chance to reject it

One way to find out

Nom Psyche for "it"

nth "it"

nth

nth

Nth it

nth it

Nth

nth it

[Errantparabola]

i was not forcing a title
it was just an idea that i had

[the worst]

i actually like kitten caboodle more as i think about it

[SleepyKrew]

It feels incredibly forced to me, and while I'd love to have Plotinus be titled, trying to force a title onto Plot won't generate a good title.

anyway here's Schrödinger's Deepwolf

[mastina]

i was not forcing a title
it was just an idea that i had

Not trying to force a title doesn't mean the title doesn't look forced. What I more or less mean by this is,

sort of alluding to the thoroughness of plotinus posting

This justification of, "it kinda sorta alludes to this one aspect of Plotinus", is the only part which makes me feel like the title nomination has anything to do with Plotinus at all, and it's a little bit tacked on. I know Plotinus frequently has an association with kittens and/or cuteness, but when I look at the title "Kitten Caboodle", I don't think of Plotinus at all and if it were given to Plotinus, I wouldn't really understand why Plotinus had that title.

i actually like kitten caboodle more as i think about it

Then can you give a more indepth explanation as to why? Because the above is more or less my problem with it. Even knowing that Plotinus has an occasional association with kittens/cute things, if Kitten Caboodle were put as Plotinus's title, I would have no clue why that was Plotinus's title, no way of associating the title with Plotinus on anything more than that superficial level.

To put it another way: it doesn't feel like it's a title special to Plotinus's presence on-site. It's not a title which feels like it is specific to Plotinus; it feels like a title you could plop under the username of any scummer who has an association with kittens and have it be equally fitting for them.

I'd be happy to be convinced otherwise, but you will need to

convince

me it's something special to Plotinus and appropriate to Plotinus's presence on-site.

[the worst]

i actually think plotinus' posting pretty regularly radiates thoughtfulness and thoroughness. like his modding style is incredibly detailed and immaculate and his perspective in discussion forums (from what i've seen) seems to be regularly really well considered with a pretty detailed thought process - the whole "kit & caboodle" wordplay is something i think resonates pretty well

other than that plot pretty regularly carries the kitty avis and a love of cats is definitely something i associate p heavily with ploti

i guess it comes back to the calibre of title you're seeking, and i'm not going to wave my stick any harder than this post. i don't think that there's this spectacular multilayered resonating truth under this title, no. but i don't think there are spectacular multilayered resonating truths under many titles at all. it's appropriate to plot's onsite presence, notes his love of cats, and is cute/punny. that's about it. not a great title, but few titles are. it's a good title.


snuggly duckling is probs a reasonable comparison; it reflects my fluffy posting style / approachable/friendly nature i project onsite and references my love of ducks. this isn't me insinuating "you must pass it because my title was passed" or w/e, just like, a comparison for perspective

[mastina]

That is in fact rather convincing.

Title doesn't have five nths yet tho so am going to wait for more people to chime in before I approve it.

[the worst]

for posterity...

nth Kitten Caboodle

[Jingle]

irony is dead

Irony, being made of iron, was never alive and thus cannot be dead.

NOM mcmemo for 'no title'

Promising. Can we instead just leave a blank line where the title would be?

nth emotion picture & still reeling

nom plotinus for

Kitten Caboodle

1. we in the titling community love puns (?)
2. cats
3. sort of alluding to the thoroughness of plotinus posting
4. going back to the "categories" discussion that only me and keely had earlier (from the newbie games)
5. cute title

Puns? PUNS!

Nth. Totally for his thorough and meticulous modstyle and not because I'm a shameless lover of terrible humor.

One way to find out

Nom Psyche for "it"

As a title for Psyche,

ick

.

You're gonna need to sell me on this.

ick

seems a bit mean for a title, even if Psyche's prickliness is one of his most endearing features.

[Pine]

McMenno 'no title' is good in a tongue-in-cheek way

ick

does seem a bit rough for a title, maybe if it were de-italicized?

[Jingle]

ABOMINATION! PINE HAS BEEN REPLACED WITH A RESPONSIBLE ADULT, WHO MODERATES THINGS. I WILL NOT STAND FOR THIS.

[Pine]

I've been a responsible adult for at least two years, Jingle.

[Psyche]

someone call guinness

[Equinox]

nth Plotinus for Kitten Caboodle

[Aristophanes]

Nth kitten caboodle

[Gamma Emerald]

Psyche-ick
Psychic
Checks out as a username pun
Not a good title at all though imo

[Psyche]

Psyche-ick

man what did i do to you

[Gamma Emerald]

Nothing I was just pointing out how it read when you put it that way