Mini Normal 2111 [Game Over!]

[Wake1]

that's exactly what I would say if I was mafia

Eh, is she wrong though?

[Wake1]

Luckly I took a break and there's not that many people who lost to scum me in the house

Out of curiosity if you were Scum this game what would I be looking for?

[Wake1]

I dont understand the dunn wagon

VOTE: garmr

Caught up.

I dont particularly like fl, garmr, or tictac. I dont like the wagon they're pushing

Pedit lol hi saudade

I actively explained why I voted Dunn, and if you look at my past votes, it’s a fine vote. I don’t scum read Dunn, I’m neutral.

Has this changed at all?

It's a bitch trying to get a read on him.

[Wake1]

she replaced into an obvtown slot though
that was a town repout

I agree, except for the replacement part. Robb does stuff like that regardless of alignment.

Garmr’s reaction and general ‘tude is townie methinks. It’s not the most appreciated,obvi, not the most popular, but Garmr is townie.

I'm not willing to just give that slot a free pass because Robb walked out.

I agree with FlavorLeaf on this.

[Wake1]

Town?

-

Townlean

Garmr
tictac
Flavor Leaf

Null

skitter30

Skellen
Saudade
january
Sujimichi
Gamma Emerald
UnaBombaH

Dunnstral

Scumlean

MariaR

Scum?

-

*Up to #175.

[skitter30]

i don't think i've had any super flashy scum wins this year, but my scumgame's improved loads

have you officially been nommed for don carleone?

if this is your improved scum game how bad was it before?

this is my lazy towngame, ty

[skitter30]

I'm going to igore robb, i think
Garmr feels a little weird on the first page, not sure i can articulate why tho

Also wanting to know how you've developed this since my absence.

he's scummy

Townpings on fl
(Super not confident tho)

also scummy, his claim is p bad, as is his progression on me

From here I'd like to know what you're currently thinking (still reading through).

Even if it is too early, i don’t see a reason not to act like we aren’t just coming to the right conclusion.

Out of all of us, I’m inherently the ‘scummiest’ thus far, but I’m here to talk with people so they can accurately read me as town.

Actually no, this is bad

But why though?

answered in a post you quote a few posts down

[skitter30]

Townpings on fl
(Super not confident tho)

From here I'd like to know what you're currently thinking (still reading through).

whoops i messed up the quote ... he's scummy too

[skitter30]

Garmr just dealt with ScumMe recently, so he should have a fresh intake on scumMe.

I also would like to see your input on this one Garmr.

I town read him day 1 but latter it was complicated I scum read his play in latter days but his claim made me think he was town as he claimed doc with a whole bunch of town macho and ascetic roles. His real role let him fake claim doc if caught.

... so you have expereince with him fake-claiming too ...

[skitter30]

Question is, does he also have them if he's Scum?

yes

[Wake1]

My way too early predictions for scum:

Gamma Emerald, MariaR, Dunnstral, Skellen, Unabombah, tictac

This list likely contains all the scum.

Because as it stands, Boon just reeks of scum to me.

OK. Why?

[Wake1]

promise i'll try to make real reads... eventually

Does this mean you've had fake reads so far?

[Garmr]

Garmr just dealt with ScumMe recently, so he should have a fresh intake on scumMe.

I also would like to see your input on this one Garmr.

I town read him day 1 but latter it was complicated I scum read his play in latter days but his claim made me think he was town as he claimed doc with a whole bunch of town macho and ascetic roles. His real role let him fake claim doc if caught.

... so you have expereince with him fake-claiming too ...

Difference is he doesn't feel scummy to me but if he is fake claiming then his real role would revolve around his fake claim.

[Wake1]

January/Una/Maria is my early game solve.

Has this changed much?

[Wake1]

I wish people wouldn't be so in favour of voting for me just because they lost a game to scum me

This came out unprompted, was anybody voting you?

Mason sounds like the kind of guy who teabags 14 y/o children on call of duty

The numbers, Mason, what do they mean?

I'm going to igore robb, i think
Garmr feels a little weird on the first page, not sure i can articulate why tho

Ok this slot is town
Don’t see scum saying that about their predecessor

This is dumb reasoning IMO

Only if they did realize who they replaced
Which I have no reason to believe rn

Don't people usually know who they replaced...?

The real question though is whether or not it's indicative of alignment. If not, it's irrelevant.

[Wake1]

Btw @january what’s your take on Robb’s replace out?

answered this already

i think skitt/robb's slot is probably town, mostly because of rob's replace-out and less because of skitter

I don't like this.

This is Robb we're talking about. Robb of either alignment could get mad and replace out.

Do you agree or disagree with that, and if not I want to know exactly

why

.

[Wake1]

I’m a cop. Gtfo.

*Sigh*

[skitter30]

Wake what's the point of asking questions like 'has this read changed much' about things that happened literally hundreds of posts ago

[Wake1]

We lynch in those 4 today. Never the first option.

I will investigate one of the others.

“Cop” is in my role title, but that’s not the only part of it. I also am Loud, so I’ll be able to prove it eventually.

So "Loud Cop," Flavor?

[Wake1]

promise i'll try to make real reads... eventually

i'm just reacting to things and trying to get interactions i guess

FL can you respond to 145 whenever you have time

Your posts are very sweet january but being reactionary is a scum tell

I see I wasn't the only one who noticed that.

[Wake1]

MariaR made a good point in post 117

I like this.

[Wake1]

Robb replace out is NAI, and actually could even be Scum indicative if anything.

Rb replaced out in a very similar fashion against me once when he was scum early Day 1.

Robb is just as aggro. Don’t let skitter coast of that if she is scum

Dude

no

. Him replacing out in a huff is NAI at all.

[Wake1]

So after reading this in one go the one thing that strikes me as odd is the high amount of people that waves the Robb/skitter slot through with townreading Robb's rep-out but on the same time bothering to outline not for skitter's play.

One thing I wonder is what the individual reads of those people is on skitter herself? (Garmr aside as I remember his read)

I also agree with FL actually that Robb's rep-out itself is pretty nai. Like last time I played with him he ragequitted too as town, but back then he said things that clearly would only come from town while his rageposts here were pretty neutral imo. What makes this rep-out so townie? I think the only one who actually explained it a bit more was january with doubting scum!Robb would react like that to an early push.

I feel a bit iffy about this, but more about the people who hand out these easy townreads than the skitter slot. Eventually I will look at that later when I have more time.

This post I'm Townreading.

[skitter30]

I think wake is scummy

[Wake1]

January/Una/Maria is my early game solve.

Also why particularly Maria? For inactives PoE you could as well have taken me for that spot or any other with low profile.

+2.