Big Four Mafia! Game Over!

[gobbledygook]

I don’t know. I feel like we gelled in Korina’s game and I don’t feel the gel right now. Who do you think is scum beyond Creature and Alchemist?

[Titus]

That has a usual descriptor Drew.

[chennisden]

I get amazed at this town every day

[Titus]

I get amazed at this town every day

Gove me your solve please.

[Yodavader]

Was Yurkin proven to be a double voter before being vanilllized?

Also, I am pretty sure Chennisden is confirmed town because of TSE.

yurkin was conf doublevoter by VC and vanilized by VC

I'm having a hard time choosing from Alch, Drew, Creature, and Blatant.

Between Alch and Drew, I'm sure one of them is lying. Though I tend to believe investigatives.

I still don't know if I fully believe Blatant. Again, a prime scum kill N1 since he claimed Doc and nothing happened to him. The last time I played with someone who I thought was a prime scum target at night that didn't get killed that night turned out to be scum, so that's what keeps Blatant on my list. I know that this is a different game and all but it still sits on the back of my mind.

I just didn't like the brashness of Creatures claim push. Seems a perfect way to get targets on the most powerful remaining PRs.

But I just don't know who is the safest choice.

These two posts don't seem to be of the same mindset. It's like he forgot BS was the n2 vanilla target.

No, I remembered. I just don't know why scum didn't outright kill him and use the vanilla on someone else. Plus the fact that he hid that he was vanillized until the next day. I would figure that the more info we have about what happened at night, the better it is for town.

[chennisden]

{Creature, Drew, maybe BS, ??}

or

{Creature, Alch, Yoda, ??}

Idk

I think it's obvious no matter which one of Alch or Drew is scum Creature is scum

[chennisden]

Creature is usually pretty obvious as town

He does not feel the same way he does as town

[gobbledygook]

{Creature, Drew, maybe BS, ??}

or

{Creature, Alch, Yoda, ??}

Idk

I think it's obvious no matter which one of Alch or Drew is scum Creature is scum

I agree with this last line, but Drew’s crumb makes sense with his weird ass role, so I believe him over Alchemist.

[chennisden]

I also think role-wise Alchemist makes perfect sense with the neighborizers as false positives. Esp since Creature is scum

[chennisden]

And I think it's obvious we should lynch Creature today, it's likely Alch/Drew can self-resolve anyway.

[chennisden]

If Drew is scum they need to play around Alch and make it so he can't get any more results. Which results in him dying or being vanillaized which kind of is self-resolving. This has to eventually happen right

If Alch is scum that might be harder to resolve but I think lynching Creature will at least help us with that given night shenanigans and stufff

[chennisden]

This dilemma is fairly hard and clearing off of roles

either way

minus hard results is kind of silly. We're basically running in circles

[chennisden]

This game is hard, so many factors to consider
In this town, every player plays a part
There's scum running loose, but we can't seem to deliver
We're running in circles, the timer's tearing us apart!

Will the moon ever shine
Or are we dead by daylight?
The scumteam, on the edge of saying "victory is mine"
Why can't we seem to put up a fight?

I look in your eyes, I implore you,
Catch the Creature in which scum lies
He's a murderer, you know it's true,
So let's see to it he dies
This town has been running around
Making blunder after blunder
But I believe we can astound
We can pull off this wonder

[Yodavader]

Nice. Though I was trying to read that to a Christmas song and it didn't work.

[chennisden]

Vote the Creature, vote the killer
So we can continue this thriller
Vote the Creature, vote the scum
So we can see the next day come
I dare you, look me in the eye
Tell me that we don't have a chance to survive
You wanna die? I thought - not.
If we lose, at least we can say we TRIED

[chennisden]

If you aren't convinced you are a heartless monster

[Alchemist21]

{Creature, Drew, maybe BS, ??}

or

{Creature, Alch, Yoda, ??}

Idk

I think it's obvious no matter which one of Alch or Drew is scum Creature is scum

I agree with this last line, but Drew’s crumb makes sense with his weird ass role, so I believe him over Alchemist.

Why do you believe the weird ass role though?

[Doctor Drew]

Creature, what about Chenn makes you think scum?

[The Baker]

Leather Feather - VC 1.1

Alchemist21 (2): Titus, gobbledygook
Creature (2): Doctor Drew, Chennisden
jjh927 (1): yurkin
Chennisden (1): Creature
Doctor Drew (1): Alchemist21
Not Voting (3): jjh927, Blatant Scum, YodaVader
With 10 alive it takes 6 to lynch
Day 4 ends on December 31st, 2019 at 4:00pm EST in (expired on 2019-12-31 16:00:00)

[Doctor Drew]

What...... totally thought I was voting Alch.

VOTE: Alchemist

[gobbledygook]

And I think it's obvious we should lynch Creature today, it's likely Alch/Drew can self-resolve anyway.

I kinda agree that 1 out of me you alch and crimson has to be scum from a balance perspective b

[gobbledygook]

{Creature, Drew, maybe BS, ??}

or

{Creature, Alch, Yoda, ??}

Idk

I think it's obvious no matter which one of Alch or Drew is scum Creature is scum

I agree with this last line, but Drew’s crumb makes sense with his weird ass role, so I believe him over Alchemist.

Why do you believe the weird ass role though?

He crumbed it. You did not. And you got it wrong when you claimed earlier.

[Alchemist21]

I don’t crumb investigative roles. And it’s clear I have the role I say I do because I knew Pisskop had the PT.

[Alchemist21]

Also anyone can say they’re never getting lynched and mean a wide number of things. That’s something that can very easily be retroactively claimed to be a crumb.

[gobbledygook]

Also anyone can say they’re never getting lynched and mean a wide number of things. That’s something that can very easily be retroactively claimed to be a crumb.

But claiming it as BP and expecting the game to be like “oh yes BP means you’re unlynchable” doesn’t seem to be a scum mindset.