Big Four Mafia! Game Over!

[chennisden]

[Blatant Scum]

Lets start with "townblock"
Titus - conftown
yurkin - townlean, he was vanillized and vanillizer is scum role
Eve - obvtown

Now townleans:
Alchemist21 - likely town, gameplay fits PR
Chennisden - townlean, not sure scum woudl claim tracker as he did

Now nulls/ scumreads. Actually, there are 4 left. Heh.
Creature - scumread, wanted to reveal lots of town PRs
YodaVader - null
jjh927 - hasn't done anything towny whole game
Doctor Drew - scum because of being in D1 wagon, slight townlie for that role claim.

My preferred lynchlist:
best lynch
Creature
jjh927
Doctor Drew
YodaVader
Chennisden
Alchemist21
worst lynch
Eve
yurkin

If Alchemist is scum, jjh gets town points for fighting my reads there.

[chennisden]

I still think Creature is a really really good lynch

[Blatant Scum]

Does anyone think that voting Alchemist is a bad idea?

[Alchemist21]

Does anyone think that voting Alchemist is a bad idea?

I do.

[chennisden]

Gee thanks

[Blatant Scum]

VOTE: Alchemist

[gobbledygook]

A lack of critical thinking.

I find that answer vague and unconvincing.

Well, that’s because you’re not critically thinking.

[gobbledygook]

VOTE: Alchemist

Hmm, this seems like a scummy vote.

[Creature]

Likely we'll end voting Alch anyway

[Blatant Scum]

VOTE: Alchemist

Hmm, this seems like a scummy vote.

With my name, I can afford such kind of votes.

[gobbledygook]

I am Kiko Loureiro, guitarist for Megadeth since 2015.
I am a Doctor and a part of this game's Uninformed Majority.

I believe this

VOTE: pisskop

We aren't doing pisskop.

I have mod confirmation Pisskop is town.

Alchemist, this is why you are not critically thinking. You investigated pisskop despite Titus saying this. Then, when you pushed Pisskop on it and he reciprocated those crumbs, you continued your push. You are not this thickheaded to realize that Titus’s comment, pisskop’s reaction, and your result make it more likely that Titus and Pisskop were masons. Any two of those three factors would give someone pause. Any two of those three would make it more likely that Titus and Pisskop were masons. In my humble turkey opinion, you pushed despite clear indications that Titus was telling the truth and that they were masons. That is issue with you. That is why I think you are displaying a lack of critical thinking.

[chennisden]

F

[Alchemist21]

I am Kiko Loureiro, guitarist for Megadeth since 2015.
I am a Doctor and a part of this game's Uninformed Majority.

I believe this

VOTE: pisskop

We aren't doing pisskop.

I have mod confirmation Pisskop is town.

Alchemist, this is why you are not critically thinking. You investigated pisskop despite Titus saying this. Then, when you pushed Pisskop on it and he reciprocated those crumbs, you continued your push. You are not this thickheaded to realize that Titus’s comment, pisskop’s reaction, and your result make it more likely that Titus and Pisskop were masons. Any two of those three factors would give someone pause. Any two of those three would make it more likely that Titus and Pisskop were masons. In my humble turkey opinion, you pushed despite clear indications that Titus was telling the truth and that they were masons. That is issue with you. That is why I think you are displaying a lack of critical thinking.

There have been recent games where people just fake Mason claims to the point where if someone says something like what Titus said I don’t automatically trust it.

I also kept asking Pisskop if he would reciprocate Titus’ hard Townread on him and for a while he wouldn’t. Why should I have interpreted that as 2 Masons?

[Yodavader]

I keep hearing that too much emotion comes off scummy, so I try not to get rash one way or the other.

From who?

Well, I guess I should restate it as seeing it too much. Some of the games that I played on here had hard reactions and they were automatically scumread because "a rational townie wouldn't react that way".

I keep hearing that too much emotion comes off scummy, so I try not to get rash one way or the other.

Why are you so preoccupied with not looking scummy? You have said this multiple times now this game.

Petit: everyone had that thought apparently.

Chennisden, do not lose faith. If we lynch a scum today, I should basically be cleared.

Pedit2:

Yoda, what is your role again?

I am a randomized bodyguard. I choose 3 people and get assigned to one of them. I only protect against nightkills. Any other abilities goes right through me.

[chennisden]

Begrudgingly, I admit Alch actually has a lot of good points

[chennisden]

I dunno.

I don't think Alch would have been able to prepare these answers effectively as scum.

[chennisden]

But also... I feel literally the same way about Drew

[gobbledygook]

I am Kiko Loureiro, guitarist for Megadeth since 2015.
I am a Doctor and a part of this game's Uninformed Majority.

I believe this

VOTE: pisskop

We aren't doing pisskop.

I have mod confirmation Pisskop is town.

Alchemist, this is why you are not critically thinking. You investigated pisskop despite Titus saying this. Then, when you pushed Pisskop on it and he reciprocated those crumbs, you continued your push. You are not this thickheaded to realize that Titus’s comment, pisskop’s reaction, and your result make it more likely that Titus and Pisskop were masons. Any two of those three factors would give someone pause. Any two of those three would make it more likely that Titus and Pisskop were masons. In my humble turkey opinion, you pushed despite clear indications that Titus was telling the truth and that they were masons. That is issue with you. That is why I think you are displaying a lack of critical thinking.

There have been recent games where people just fake Mason claims to the point where if someone says something like what Titus said I don’t automatically trust it.

I also kept asking Pisskop if he would reciprocate Titus’ hard Townread on him and for a while he wouldn’t. Why should I have interpreted that as 2 Masons?

“Let me ask a mason if they are a mason”
“Let me ask a mason who their buddy is”

As a mason, I would not answer that question truthfully either.

[chennisden]

It's very interesting Alchemist didn't target Titus instead. I would've thought the alternatives were Pisskop is FN and Titus is just scum, or both of them are scum - in which case it'd be optimal to target Titus.

[gobbledygook]

I need to see what Alchemist’s Activity Flow was like in coaLition.

[chennisden]

Btw I actualy think we might not be in mylo

[chennisden]

There should've been at least one quickhammer with how carelessly we have been throwing votes around

[chennisden]

Which makes Alch more likely town.

[gobbledygook]

There should've been at least one quickhammer with how carelessly we have been throwing votes around

We’ve only ever gotten to L-4 and Yurkin hasn’t posted during that time. It’s possible they can’t.

14:3 is pretty townsided. 13:4 is more even.