Masochist Mafia II [Game Over]

[Gamma Emerald]

Oh shit! I just reread my role pm and I could have sent someone fruit last night.

Uhhh okay

[Gamma Emerald]

Well that happened

[Ramcius]

Nancy, why Postie is town? Joined wagon late, sketchy miller claim

Claiming Bulletproof Miller Vig

Well. first thing comes to mind is we can investigate this. I didn’t realize this but it could possibly explain one of the kills if legit. @Postie, who did you vig and why? However, that still leaves one unexplained one. By right, if she vigged Titus with her powerful role, she might deserved to be Pl’ed for that, only half serious.

Her IC seems pretty townie but if I am wrong on either Karnage or Overkill11 being Salad’s partner, she is my least confident tr. Prior to D2, she claimed to tr me and suddenly I’m her #1 living sr? Like how?

Another thing is we have no claimed cops - allignment otherwise, to confirm miller being in the setup and miller minus allignment cop is highly unlikely.

Also she hard tr Jingle and is now hard tr you. Are you seeing that as some kind of pocket? I do think she probably is a vig but generally hard claims like this, tend to come from town.

Well, if you had read this thread, you'd know that Postie retracted her vig claim after I questioned her

Am I not towny enough to have tr from Postie? Considering you agree with that read

Funny how you bring her tr on Jingle, but what's with you defending Jingle from me D1 yet refusing to tr him? It felt like you wanted keep tension between us as you never really tried to debunk my pushes and prove me wrong, so I had no real reason to stop

[Nancy Drew 39]

Oh shit! I just reread my role pm and I could have sent someone fruit last night.

Uhhh okay

Well that happened

I honestly thought I was just a vt. Who can remember after 7 months +?

[Nancy Drew 39]

Nancy, why Postie is town? Joined wagon late, sketchy miller claim

Claiming Bulletproof Miller Vig

Well. first thing comes to mind is we can investigate this. I didn’t realize this but it could possibly explain one of the kills if legit. @Postie, who did you vig and why? However, that still leaves one unexplained one. By right, if she vigged Titus with her powerful role, she might deserved to be Pl’ed for that, only half serious.

Her IC seems pretty townie but if I am wrong on either Karnage or Overkill11 being Salad’s partner, she is my least confident tr. Prior to D2, she claimed to tr me and suddenly I’m her #1 living sr? Like how?

Another thing is we have no claimed cops - allignment otherwise, to confirm miller being in the setup and miller minus allignment cop is highly unlikely.

Also she hard tr Jingle and is now hard tr you. Are you seeing that as some kind of pocket? I do think she probably is a vig but generally hard claims like this, tend to come from town.

Well, if you had read this thread, you'd know that Postie retracted her vig claim after I questioned her

Am I not towny enough to have tr from Postie? Considering you agree with that read

Funny how you bring her tr on Jingle, but what's with you defending Jingle from me D1 yet refusing to tr him? It felt like you wanted keep tension between us as you never really tried to debunk my pushes and prove me wrong, so I had no real reason to stop

Oh so she redacted it? I will have to reread it then. Do you recall which post?

I wasn’t playing the game until now. Now that there’s actual flips, I now actually have something to work with. I tr you for a lot of reasons like being opposed to UTL lynch, for example. It’s like 97% Salad and unless one of my tr are off, probably between Karnage and Overkill11 for the partner.

I’ve never played with Postie before. I should probably check out some of her games. @Postie, if you’re reading this, please link me to a town and scumgame of yours, kthanx.

[the worst]

Can I have an avocado?

[Ramcius]

Oh so she redacted it? I will have to reread it then. Do you recall which post?

I wasn’t playing the game until now. Now that there’s actual flips, I now actually have something to work with. I tr you for a lot of reasons like being opposed to UTL lynch, for example. It’s like 97% Salad and unless one of my tr are off, probably between Karnage and Overkill11 for the partner.

I’ve never played with Postie before. I should probably check out some of her games. @Postie, if you’re reading this, please link me to a town and scumgame of yours, kthanx.

Yes, as a joke
I didn't think there would like ?3 actual vigs in the game

That was her answer, when I asked about vig claim

But why you didn't said anything about FA meta D1 and let UTL wagon exist?

[Ankamius]

TIL my reads are more memorable to Nancy than her own role

[Nancy Drew 39]

Can I have an avocado?

Will this do?

[Nancy Drew 39]

Oh so she redacted it? I will have to reread it then. Do you recall which post?

I wasn’t playing the game until now. Now that there’s actual flips, I now actually have something to work with. I tr you for a lot of reasons like being opposed to UTL lynch, for example. It’s like 97% Salad and unless one of my tr are off, probably between Karnage and Overkill11 for the partner.

I’ve never played with Postie before. I should probably check out some of her games. @Postie, if you’re reading this, please link me to a town and scumgame of yours, kthanx.

Yes, as a joke
I didn't think there would like ?3 actual vigs in the game

That was her answer, when I asked about vig claim

But why you didn't said anything about FA meta D1 and let UTL wagon exist?

3? I thought only Titus. Who are the other two?

I seriously did wonder if FA rolled scum when I saw that but it was in conjunction with my already strong Salad sr, that I actually made the connection.

I already told you, I wasn’t really playing until now.

[Nancy Drew 39]

TIL my reads are more memorable to Nancy than her own role

Yep and also a lot easier to locate.

Probably also had something to do with fruit vendor being pretty much useless and forgettable.

[Ramcius]

Oh so she redacted it? I will have to reread it then. Do you recall which post?

I wasn’t playing the game until now. Now that there’s actual flips, I now actually have something to work with. I tr you for a lot of reasons like being opposed to UTL lynch, for example. It’s like 97% Salad and unless one of my tr are off, probably between Karnage and Overkill11 for the partner.

I’ve never played with Postie before. I should probably check out some of her games. @Postie, if you’re reading this, please link me to a town and scumgame of yours, kthanx.

Yes, as a joke
I didn't think there would like ?3 actual vigs in the game

That was her answer, when I asked about vig claim

But why you didn't said anything about FA meta D1 and let UTL wagon exist?

3? I thought only Titus. Who are the other two?

I seriously did wonder if FA rolled scum when I saw that but it was in conjunction with my already strong Salad sr, that I actually made the connection.

I already told you, I wasn’t really playing until now.

We have 4 kills, Postie guessed 3 vigs

So what are your thoughts on this matter?

[Nancy Drew 39]

Oh so she redacted it? I will have to reread it then. Do you recall which post?

I wasn’t playing the game until now. Now that there’s actual flips, I now actually have something to work with. I tr you for a lot of reasons like being opposed to UTL lynch, for example. It’s like 97% Salad and unless one of my tr are off, probably between Karnage and Overkill11 for the partner.

I’ve never played with Postie before. I should probably check out some of her games. @Postie, if you’re reading this, please link me to a town and scumgame of yours, kthanx.

Yes, as a joke
I didn't think there would like ?3 actual vigs in the game

That was her answer, when I asked about vig claim

But why you didn't said anything about FA meta D1 and let UTL wagon exist?

3? I thought only Titus. Who are the other two?

I seriously did wonder if FA rolled scum when I saw that but it was in conjunction with my already strong Salad sr, that I actually made the connection.

I already told you, I wasn’t really playing until now.

We have 4 kills, Postie guessed 3 vigs

So what are your thoughts on this matter?

Could be. Could I suppose also be a scum joat/vig + an SK? I dunno, that’s why I asked for a link to MM1. I was in a game on MU where we had both a scum joat and a 1 shot vig, so we had two kills on N1.

[Nancy Drew 39]

Why not consider PGO? Or multiball? Grey color for scum is strange

Yeah, I suppose that’s also possible but if PGO, then wouldn’t there be one less death?

Like Jingle had to be the obvious scumkill, since he claimed PR and I already suggested Cheeky as the possible vigkill but why Titus and Datisi?

[Nancy Drew 39]

I signed up to Masochist Mafia not Massacre Mafia : (

Let's hope those were all vigs and there aren't also third parties dear god

I don’t think Postie’s scum despite her weird read progression on me.

[Ramcius]

Why not consider PGO? Or multiball? Grey color for scum is strange

Yeah, I suppose that’s also possible but if PGO, then wouldn’t there be one less death?

Like Jingle had to be the obvious scumkill, since he claimed PR and I already suggested Cheeky as the possible vigkill but why Titus and Datisi?

PGO can kills more than one person - they kill all visitors

I have theory about NM and Datisi being in same hood with some ability - hidden roles to hide this hood from everyone else and NMs buddies got rid of Datisi to prevent info to leak out

Jingle might've run into PGO too, I doubt it was vig. Tbh, I have hard time thinking why vig would shoot Titus, Jingle or Datisi, so 3 vig idea didn't really occurred to me

[Jingle]

Can I have an avocado?

No, avocados are bad fruits. You may instead have a mango with a nice tropical tang to it.

[Nancy Drew 39]

Why not consider PGO? Or multiball? Grey color for scum is strange

Yeah, I suppose that’s also possible but if PGO, then wouldn’t there be one less death?

Like Jingle had to be the obvious scumkill, since he claimed PR and I already suggested Cheeky as the possible vigkill but why Titus and Datisi?

PGO can kills more than one person - they kill all visitors

I have theory about NM and Datisi being in same hood with some ability - hidden roles to hide this hood from everyone else and NMs buddies got rid of Datisi to prevent info to leak out

Jingle might've run into PGO too, I doubt it was vig. Tbh, I have hard time thinking why vig would shoot Titus, Jingle or Datisi, so 3 vig idea didn't really occurred to me

Jingle hardclaimed PR, why wouldn’t scum target him? Could be true about Datisi, I guess? But it’s unlikely Titus didn’t use her shot and I can see why she might be suspicious of Cheeky defending NM and can she even vig a PGO anyway?

[Nancy Drew 39]

Can I have an avocado?

No, avocados are bad fruits. You may instead have a mango with a nice tropical tang to it.

Oh really, I thought they were good for you?

[Ramcius]

Why not consider PGO? Or multiball? Grey color for scum is strange

Yeah, I suppose that’s also possible but if PGO, then wouldn’t there be one less death?

Like Jingle had to be the obvious scumkill, since he claimed PR and I already suggested Cheeky as the possible vigkill but why Titus and Datisi?

PGO can kills more than one person - they kill all visitors

I have theory about NM and Datisi being in same hood with some ability - hidden roles to hide this hood from everyone else and NMs buddies got rid of Datisi to prevent info to leak out

Jingle might've run into PGO too, I doubt it was vig. Tbh, I have hard time thinking why vig would shoot Titus, Jingle or Datisi, so 3 vig idea didn't really occurred to me

Jingle hardclaimed PR, why wouldn’t scum target him? Could be true about Datisi, I guess? But it’s unlikely Titus didn’t use her shot and I can see why she might be suspicious of Cheeky defending NM and can she even vig a PGO anyway?

Why Titus can't be scum kill?

As for Jingle, if scum don't have strongman, they might look elsewhere as chances for protection on Jingle was very high and Jingle wasn't doing that hot to solve the game

[Nancy Drew 39]

So your theory is what - Jingle doc’d PGO?

[Ramcius]

So your theory is what - Jingle doc’d PGO?

Maybe he died due to old age, I dunno, we have 4 kills and I'm trying to piece things together. We agree that Cheeky most likely was Titus kill, rest 3 are plausible scum kills, so what is your theory? Datisi run into PGO, while Titus and Jingle was taken out by scum?

[Salamence20]

Frozen 2 was really well done. I think it lived up to the hype I gave it. Kristoffs 80’s style song was really good, and every song outside of Elsa’s one song near the end where she tries to recapture the magic of let it go was well performed.

Spoiler:

One thing though, how did no one in the kingdom realize that the king built the dam as a trick. Like how do you keep a secret war plan hidden like that.

[Nancy Drew 39]

So your theory is what - Jingle doc’d PGO?

Maybe he died due to old age, I dunno, we have 4 kills and I'm trying to piece things together. We agree that Cheeky most likely was Titus kill, rest 3 are plausible scum kills, so what is your theory? Datisi run into PGO, while Titus and Jingle was taken out by scum?

If you think Datisi and NM were in a hood, I dunno. That’s why the most useful thing would probably to get a link to MM1, so might get some idea from that.

So, if anyone can find that, it would be super helpful.

[Ramcius]

What's MM1?

It's just a theory, cause why else kill Datisi? But you think Jingle was scum kill too, so how Titus died? 3rd scum kill N1?