BooneyToonz XIII: To Boon or Not To Boon - [END]

[Venus and Mars]

how so? i thought Clem was in Bambi's possible scumpool.

and for the post above that, are you referring to Nips? just to be clear on what you're responding to.

If Clem rc Bambi and gave her a tr, isn’t that town indicative? Agreed, clear was maybe too strong a word.

[Amrun]

@Chara: why am I the only on that list with no alignment comment?

[Amrun]

Finally caught up. What a whirlwind to catch up on. I ended up making most of the comments I wanted to as I went along, but I probably forgot something important.

I did re-ISO Bambi and Bambi is still probably town, though less strong than I felt before about it.

VOTE: emperor flippynips

I’m feelin it y’all. I am.

[Nancy Drew 39]

if i'm remembering right, Almost and i started hydraing because our play made zero sense to each other, in a game we were both town in.

haven't had a chance to catch up yet. grateful Frost isn't hammered. i also believed he was so i think it's fair to lend credence to the idea he also wasn't aware if he had been or not.

if Almost hid behind Nips: no enchantress. Nips is town. Titus and Creature's actions failed due to Almost being hidden.

if Almost did not hide behind Nips/failed the action: could have been Enchanted. explains the failures. could also be scum. could also be lying town.

Bambi: is probably town. i don't find his Titus discredit scummy nor his hammer. i do find his behaviour after the first hammer and subsequent second lolhammer to be play i dislike, but am townreading from Bambi.

IMO if A50 or Chara ever flips scum, power lynch the other. The above post is my entire case.

To requote YOUR words: Please explain this to me like I’m 5.

[Venus and Mars]

if i'm remembering right, Almost and i started hydraing because our play made zero sense to each other, in a game we were both town in.

haven't had a chance to catch up yet. grateful Frost isn't hammered. i also believed he was so i think it's fair to lend credence to the idea he also wasn't aware if he had been or not.

if Almost hid behind Nips: no enchantress. Nips is town. Titus and Creature's actions failed due to Almost being hidden.

if Almost did not hide behind Nips/failed the action: could have been Enchanted. explains the failures. could also be scum. could also be lying town.

Bambi: is probably town. i don't find his Titus discredit scummy nor his hammer. i do find his behaviour after the first hammer and subsequent second lolhammer to be play i dislike, but am townreading from Bambi.

IMO if A50 or Chara ever flips scum, power lynch the other. The above post is my entire case.

To requote YOUR words: Please explain this to me like I’m 5.

[Venus and Mars]

Flips flip proves everything.

Actually, it doesn't. I have thought about it more and came to the conclusion the Enchanter -if existed- would probably not have targeted me anyway, mainly because I didn't even specify my target by the end of the day. I think it may have been something else that caused your action(s) to fail on me, and I think Nips is Town here (I'll trust my own results, thank you very much).

Meanwhile, I am starting to give up on this Town tbh, so I'm sheeping the player I knew was Town from the get go:

VOTE: Aaron

If Nips is confirmed I don’t want to vote there and I still hard sr Drew.

[Haggle]

Haggle: is for whatever reason really pinging me today after doing the opposite yesterday, but i trust davesaz's result. it's probably just me given my read there yesterday.
2768 definitely read to me as a joke and i'm looking for players who took the BoP seriously given there doesn't seem to be real evidence for it in Frost's past games. as i read further with Haggle they ping less.

How come? I'm kinda just playing without fear of looking scummy now due to the clear, so just chucking out whatever thoughts/scumreads I have.

-Hectic

[Haggle]

chkflip: still fine with him, upset that he's no longer so obviously town given the miller claim when we had a miller flip.

Oh, I forgot about this; this is kind of a big deal actually. 2 millers in a game is unusual.

-Hectic

[Haggle]

Drew's tone with Nancy feels really unusual for him if he's scum tbh.

-Hectic

[Venus and Mars]

chkflip: still fine with him, upset that he's no longer so obviously town given the miller claim when we had a miller flip.

Oh, I forgot about this; this is kind of a big deal actually. 2 millers in a game is unusual.

-Hectic

I’ve been in games with 5 of them.

[Venus and Mars]

Drew's tone with Nancy feels really unusual for him if he's scum tbh.

-Hectic

Why? And does he act the same way in every scumgame?

[Amrun]

if i'm remembering right, Almost and i started hydraing because our play made zero sense to each other, in a game we were both town in.

haven't had a chance to catch up yet. grateful Frost isn't hammered. i also believed he was so i think it's fair to lend credence to the idea he also wasn't aware if he had been or not.

if Almost hid behind Nips: no enchantress. Nips is town. Titus and Creature's actions failed due to Almost being hidden.

if Almost did not hide behind Nips/failed the action: could have been Enchanted. explains the failures. could also be scum. could also be lying town.

Bambi: is probably town. i don't find his Titus discredit scummy nor his hammer. i do find his behaviour after the first hammer and subsequent second lolhammer to be play i dislike, but am townreading from Bambi.

IMO if A50 or Chara ever flips scum, power lynch the other. The above post is my entire case.

To requote YOUR words: Please explain this to me like I’m 5.

Re-reading it I don’t feel as strongly as I did at first, but I didn’t like the addition of A50 being lying town. Idk just felt like a weird soft defense of A50 to me.

I forgot to answer you earlier if I thought all neighborhoods were town. I don’t see any reason why they couldn’t be. However, I still think either AF or Joan (probably not both) could easily be scum.

And honestly, Joan not dying last night in favor of EJ is a mark against her.

[Haggle]

chkflip: still fine with him, upset that he's no longer so obviously town given the miller claim when we had a miller flip.

Oh, I forgot about this; this is kind of a big deal actually. 2 millers in a game is unusual.

-Hectic

I’ve been in games with 5 of them.

Oh.

Drew's tone with Nancy feels really unusual for him if he's scum tbh.

-Hectic

Why? And does he act the same way in every scumgame?

Only 1 scum game with him where he was cult leader actually. But he played a lot more cautious and less conflict-seeking/argumentative there.

-Hectic

[Venus and Mars]

chkflip: still fine with him, upset that he's no longer so obviously town given the miller claim when we had a miller flip.

Oh, I forgot about this; this is kind of a big deal actually. 2 millers in a game is unusual.

-Hectic

I’ve been in games with 5 of them.

Oh.

Drew's tone with Nancy feels really unusual for him if he's scum tbh.

-Hectic

Why? And does he act the same way in every scumgame?

Only 1 scum game with him where he was cult leader actually. But he played a lot more cautious and less conflict-seeking/argumentative there.

-Hectic

He was really nice in a year of micros too, so I don’t think that’s town indicative.

[Venus and Mars]

To all of the people meta reading Drew as town, find me another game where he has played anything similar to how he has here, because I couldn’t find one in ANY alignment, so the Drew is town here by meta has no basis.

[Chara]

how so? i thought Clem was in Bambi's possible scumpool.

and for the post above that, are you referring to Nips? just to be clear on what you're responding to.

If Clem rc Bambi and gave her a tr, isn’t that town indicative? Agreed, clear was maybe too strong a word.

i would predict scum Clem to do something like this, so i don't find it town indicative. this is a presumption from me that scum Clem would want to do what town Clem claims he tends to do, which is investigate Bambi N1 if he is able.
since Bambi has experience with Clem, his mild scumread of Clem (or lack of a townread) has some weight with me given my strong TR on Bambi.

@Chara: why am I the only on that list with no alignment comment?

coincidence. i added comments as they stood out to me, and the situation you described of being mislynched in LyLo with correct reads warranted, to me, an expression of sympathy. :> was not technically a readlist, though certainly has reads. gun to my head, i do TL you, though not in any interesting sort of way.

[quotes thread snipped]

Re-reading it I don’t feel as strongly as I did at first, but I didn’t like the addition of A50 being lying town. Idk just felt like a weird soft defense of A50 to me.

I forgot to answer you earlier if I thought all neighborhoods were town. I don’t see any reason why they couldn’t be. However, I still think either AF or Joan (probably not both) could easily be scum.

And honestly, Joan not dying last night in favor of EJ is a mark against her.

considering Almost has already proven himself to be lying this game, and i do TR him, i consider it an apt comment. that he lies as both town and scum is also information useful to reading him, in my opinion.

[Amrun]

To all of the people meta reading Drew as town, find me another game where he has played anything similar to how he has here, because I couldn’t find one in ANY alignment, so the Drew is town here by meta has no basis.

I invite you to re-read the penguin’s micro game. The level of tinfoil Drew is doing here is very similar to me with that game, where he talked himself out of neighborizing when it would have been in his favor.

[Titus]

Drunk Titus says hi!

I'm very annoyed with town atm. So annoyed it makes me paranoid. The that rhymes.

[AaronFrost]

Yeah, that’s kind of what I’m wondering, if Bambi push could possibly be a counter derail on Drew, because no one had even the slightest interest in voting her before Drew became a viable wagon.

So, I would be sus on anyone who was voting both you and Bambi rn. BEF doesn’t count since he jumped off immediately and switched to Drew.

I could definitely see that being the case.

I think BEF wasn't fully caught up when he voted for me and I was the leading wagon at the time.

Once Drew flips scum we can look back and see who was pushing Bambi

[RCEnigma]

Mixtape when?

[AaronFrost]

Oh

, I see what you're doing here, Aaron.

*cough* I mean... AaronFFrost? Never even heard of him. Well, I've heard of him, technically played a few games with him actually, but he's nothing special. Pretty terrible actually. Yeah. He once got mislynched pregame soooo

Did I ever tell you about the game I got mislynched in before it even entered signups? I think it was in the Newbie Queue

[AaronFrost]

Drew's alignment has no reflection on Flips alignment.

The TMI thing is garbage.

The VCA thing is the only valid criticism of my Flipcase. This is the first time I have done it.

VCA is garbage when we don't have a scumflip yet.

Do you really not think Drew was perspective slipping in the posts Nancy linked?

[AaronFrost]

1- What if chkflip is actually Scum who fakeclaimed Miller and I fell for it? Like, I knew a Miller was likely alright, but then someone did flip a Miller and it wasn't chkflip.

This I could see.

I lowkey forgot chk claimed miller

[AaronFrost]

He’s willing to vote whomever his tr want, so don’t really see any agenda there. Joan’s votes are a helluva a lot more suspicious imo.

What do you find suspicious about her votes?

[Venus and Mars]

To all of the people meta reading Drew as town, find me another game where he has played anything similar to how he has here, because I couldn’t find one in ANY alignment, so the Drew is town here by meta has no basis.

I invite you to re-read the penguin’s micro game. The level of tinfoil Drew is doing here is very similar to me with that game, where he talked himself out of neighborizing when it would have been in his favor.

Okay, just reread it and the only similarity I can see to this game, is that he shouldn’t be sr for what he thought was a quickhammer. I don’t know what “tin foil” you’re seeing? Maybe you can link/quote the specific posts? But he was super obvtown in that, just like in Penguin.