BooneyToonz XIII: To Boon or Not To Boon - [END]

[Chemist1422]

fwiw I just finished a game where a scum claimed cop enabler where there was a town cop claim

So I don’t think AF flip has any bearing on Joan’s alignment

[The Fonz]

It read like he could only join if he hit scum he didn't know about.

Agreed.

[50 Judge Powers]

If you reread it then that means she's more likely town actually. His ability seemed to be so he could join the scum PT but he couldn't use it on 2 of them.

Yet he

could

use it on the other two, and she is likely one of the pair he wasn't informed of.

[Titus]

So we know RCE is not renegade too.

[RCEnigma]

If you reread it then that means she's more likely town actually. His ability seemed to be so he could join the scum PT but he couldn't use it on 2 of them.

Yet he

could

use it on the other two, and she is likely one of the pair he wasn't informed of.

But if Joan was scum in that hood scum could have just recruited AF last night no?

The doc enabler claim was to draw the nightkill I assume.

[50 Judge Powers]

The neighborhood seems more likely a counter balance so he couldnt just use it willy nilly? But he joined the neighborhood on purpose for... Some reason.

Bingo! Then he did target dave and Joan was one of the two

he was informed of

. It's a means to establish communication with a team partner, and probably fish for the other two (i.e. see if Joan knew who the other two scum were).

[Bambi Jay]

If you reread it then that means she's more likely town actually. His ability seemed to be so he could join the scum PT but he couldn't use it on 2 of them.

Yet he

could

use it on the other two, and she is likely one of the pair he wasn't informed of.

... If he wasnt informed she was his partner... Of all the people to target to get into the scum PT, he targets Her? Not likely.

Drew was kinda scummy day 1 so he probably guessed he was his partner who also was a neighbor. That makes more sense to me. When he realized that wasn't the case he helped lynch him.

That's my theorycrafting anyway.

[davesaz]

Ah, um yeah. Forget I said that.

One faction but they only know one partner and don't have full communication? If that's the way to read it, then It's not multiball technically because it isn't two factions. But it isn't really singleball either. Trust Boon to have something new.

I think scum know the identity of the other pair. They'd have to to not NK them. Unclear if they have one pt or two, but "Evil Lair PT" makes me think its only one.

It does say two separate evil lairs to begin with, maybe attempting to kill one of the other pair is what unites them. He can't join the ones he knows.
If it really is a fully split team to start off, then more than just VCA can be messed up. We're really lucky that the traitor-like role flipped first.

AF probably thought they were scummy enough to possibly be the unknown scum.
I think this soft clears Joan.
Strongwill is a counter to protectives. That's gonna hurt the scum team.

The even/odd thing could mean that each half team has things that help or hinder the other half. This game is going to swing like mad.

[50 Judge Powers]

It read like he could only join if he hit scum he didn't know about.

That was for the scum PT. He couldn't have joined the PT with Joan, but he could still join the neighborhood if he targeted her neighbor. The NEIGHBORHOOD, not the Scum PT.

[Titus]

This seems like a stretch to lynch the doctor.

[Titus]

And far too prepared

[Bambi Jay]

The neighborhood seems more likely a counter balance so he couldnt just use it willy nilly? But he joined the neighborhood on purpose for... Some reason.

Bingo! Then he did target dave and Joan was one of the two

he was informed of

. It's a means to establish communication with a team partner, and probably fish for the other two (i.e. see if Joan knew who the other two scum were).

Oooooh. From that angle I guess being able to kill Drew so him and Joan could talk makes sense too.

But uhh.... Can't follow you on Joan. Sorry friend.

[50 Judge Powers]

The doc enabler claim was to draw the nightkill I assume.

If that's the case then he wanted to draw the NK of the other pair, so he could be recruited with them, and tell them that Joan & ?? are the other two.

[davesaz]

Two scum PT is implied by Aaron's flip. The PT he joined was not either one. PT cop can't get all scum by detecting one pair.

[davesaz]

Hot tinfoil -- 50 and chk are scum of different pairs.

[Bambi Jay]

The doc enabler claim was to draw the nightkill I assume.

If that's the case then he wanted to draw the NK of the other pair, so he could be recruited with them, and tell them that Joan & ?? are the other two.

Why are you assuming the other scum don't know each other? I saw Titus mention this earlier.

[davesaz]

That's probably wrong but it would be funny as hell.

Pedit: The AF flip as much as says they don't know each other.

[50 Judge Powers]

... If he wasnt informed she was his partner... Of all the people to target to get into the scum PT, he targets Her? Not likely.

If he wasn't notified of her then it's the #1 choice to target because she is OBV!SCUM. However, I think he was informed if her and joined the hood to be able to communicate with her.

[RCEnigma]

That's probably wrong but it would be funny as hell.

Pedit: The AF flip as much as says they don't know each other.

If Joan is scum then 1 scum pair has knowledge of the other via AF's role pm.

[Bambi Jay]

• You know that there are a total of 5 Evil Magical Disguise Lords of the Boonski’i. Your teammates are separated into 2 different Evil Lairs in pairs, one pair kills on Odd-Nights, one pair kills on Even-Nights. They will combine Evil Lairs when a certain condition has been met. You know that

REDACTED

and

REDACTED

are 2 of your partners. Your Party Crash ability will

NOT

succeed by targeting them, but they will work on your other 2 partners. However, if you are to be killed by the factional kill, you will instead be recruited into the Evil Lair Private Thread and be able to make the factional kill. If you somehow find yourself as the last Evil Lord alive, you will join the Evil Lair Private Thread and be able to make the factional kill.

Guys, read this again.

He knew 2 of his partners, and there's 2 separate lairs, which seems like PTs. He's a Traitor with the knowledge of his team being seperated, and Appearantly the scum team can only combine again after a certain condition.

Why are we assuming the 2 he knows are from the same pair, and why are we assuming the PAIRS don't know each other?

[50 Judge Powers]

When he realized that wasn't the case he helped lynch him.

No. He lynched him so he could have the PT for him and Joan. If you insist in pursuing your defence of Joan, then I'm afraid I must insist in the opposite direction.

[Bambi Jay]

I insist for a completely different reason, Mister Monkey.

[Joan of Arc]

I targeted Chemist, btw.

[Titus]

Occam's Razor, Joan is doctor. Renegade is proven real. Aaron was just getting information for scum.

[Titus]

Unfortunately, renegade being proven real has no bearing on RCE's alignment given ascetic is a boon to scum.

I'll go through this in the afternoon to be clearer.