BooneyToonz XIII: To Boon or Not To Boon - [END]

[chkflip]

Nancy, Tybalt (the town vig flavor) is the only knife welder to have flipped thus far. It behooves me to think that, of the cop claims I find most credible, the one with knife flavor is most credible. It may be that the only slots that davesaz would obtain guilties on are of flavored characters that use knives. It would then mean that Haggle's flavor isn't one that uses a knife. It may be Haggle's partner that uses a knife while Haggle uses, say, a sword or something. Knifesmith is oddly specific and I'm willing to bet there's a reason for it.

Bambi, I 100% agree. Which is why I haven't based my read of you on that game alone.

Fish, that's fair; however, why Joan over Haggle?

Amrun, he's acting in the same vein as you regarding claiming. I was town reading him for that minimally, yes, but I also had firm belief that Frank (his predecessor) was very town as well. His replacing into the game, the way he entered and interacted with it, and his insistence on reading absolutely everything are indicative of town to me.

Pedit: Nancy, no disrespect intended, but I don't feel like you're going to hit scum here. I'm sorry?

[Venus and Mars]

Guys, the Fishie is like me in that he's naturally scummy, he just doesn't have my outstanding personality to back it up.

Let me vouch for him RN.

+1

Glad I’m not the only one seeing this. NEVER LYNCH The FISH!!!

[Titus]

I might as well out what I know since my role is now toast.
I was a "daggersmith" which is just a flavored version of a gunsmith.
I checked Haggle, who does not have a dagger (gun). That means not mafia unless doctor.
The Juvenile Delinquent thing was not something I was aware of. The setup is hella swingy with this type of thing and Titus's modifier changing.
Hopefully it's somewhat balanced swing, if there is such a thing.

Perhaps the large number of semi-conf town is the compensation for the swing.

@Chkflip, All scum have daggers according to Davesaz claim. He's a flavored gunsmith.

[Venus and Mars]

Amrun, I'm not your biggest fan rn either. Talk to me. Let us discuss like Vulcans and come to understand one another so we can choke each other out tomorrow after Nancy shoots town today.

Unrelated, Joan and Titus syncing hard rn.

Why do you think she shoots town? She's literally refusing the shots I want. That should make you in game happy and thus her more likely to hit scum.

Yeah, @chk, especially since you have no clue who I’m going to shoot yet.

[Titus]

@Nancy wasn't Gameshow the game where I scumread RC and you left me high and dry? So RC could mindfuck me all game?

[chkflip]

OOH ROMEO FLAVOR DIED BY SWORD.

FUCK I'M GOOD.

[Venus and Mars]

This post is fucking delicious.

That's fair, but I'm not wrong am I?

And if half the playerlist truly isn't contributing then surely you weren't lynched, no?

Apparently I wasn't but when I log on during my work break and this is the first post I see

Drew just hammered??? This better flip scum.

-Hectic

I'm understandably not going to be happy especially when no one gave a solid reason why they think I'm scum

Thank you Sherlock, I already pointed that out, so why the premature discredit?

And I asked you to explain how they were scum with the Dave knifeclear, because without that, they’d probably be my target for that. The timing just doesn’t seem like a coincidence.

[Bambi Jay]

OOH ROMEO FLAVOR DIED BY SWORD.

FUCK I'M GOOD.

Knife is just a small sword, Chk.

I'd agree if it was poison like I'm Proposing, but that's a stretch.

[chkflip]

Gunsmith is the type of cop that is interjected with fuckery by design. Initiating false positives by way of flavor kills is a small leap to take my friends.

[Venus and Mars]

This post is fucking delicious.

That's fair, but I'm not wrong am I?

And if half the playerlist truly isn't contributing then surely you weren't lynched, no?

Apparently I wasn't but when I log on during my work break and this is the first post I see

Drew just hammered??? This better flip scum.

-Hectic

I'm understandably not going to be happy especially when no one gave a solid reason why they think I'm scum

No one gave a reason is usually scum talking to town. Just fyi. That's delicious spew.

You’re forgetting AF was traitor, so it really doesn’t count for anti-spew.

[Titus]

This post is fucking delicious.

That's fair, but I'm not wrong am I?

And if half the playerlist truly isn't contributing then surely you weren't lynched, no?

Apparently I wasn't but when I log on during my work break and this is the first post I see

Drew just hammered??? This better flip scum.

-Hectic

I'm understandably not going to be happy especially when no one gave a solid reason why they think I'm scum

Thank you Sherlock, I already pointed that out, so why the premature discredit?

And I asked you to explain how they were scum with the Dave knifeclear, because without that, they’d probably be my target for that. The timing just doesn’t seem like a coincidence.

I read it as a town gambit. Tell people a slot is hammered. Get reactions. Evaluate slot.

[Venus and Mars]

You're not paying enough attention to the right part. Aaron freaked out because his PARTNER thought he'd been hammered.

There's also the RVS tell (old but reliable) and the general feel of how the slot treated Haggle throughout the game. The bus is real homies.

Yes but what about the knife clear? How do you explain that?

[chkflip]

OOH ROMEO FLAVOR DIED BY SWORD.

FUCK I'M GOOD.

Knife is just a small sword, Chk.

I'd agree if it was poison like I'm Proposing, but that's a stretch.

Knife ain't no damn small sword wtf rofl.

I can't even

[Venus and Mars]

There was no reason to believe Frost was hammered. He was only at 6 votes. Haggle postures, Frost FREAKS out, and the wagon dissipates.

I know, I know, it's too brilliant. You're welcome.

I figured it out BEFORE you, so I’ll take that credit tyvm but I still need an explanation wrt Dave’s knifeclear.

[Venus and Mars]

HURT: Amrun, Adorable, Enigma, JP50, Fonz

Amrun is the scummier of the 2 FVer's in my opinion, and has a better chance of being a pair with one of the other 4 then Fishie does.

Adorable Rolecopped me n1 but frankly while I can agree on that, it makes more sense they're also scum so scum get hurt by the Delinquint dying as well. Also the Indecisive modifier could have been a lie.

Enigma is riding my wavelengths and creeping me out, plus being the second JOAT claim. I dunno if the Ascetic thing is a lie, but I'm not wasting my Night Action on him. Let Creature track him and see if he gets "target went nowhere" or "no result".

Fonz is now the only unclaimed guy left and whatever his role is could clear someone or confirm he's scummy. But he's withholding it.

I'd give my opinions on Almost but that's just me saying Nancy can shoot him and I wouldn't be too mad.

. So what changed for you since last night?

Whaduya mean?

You were clearly opposed to that. A50 shot.

[Venus and Mars]

If he doesn't use a knife... Hidden Poisoner? Poison in a Shakespeare play go hand in hand.

Right, knifeclear doesn’t make them town and we can get plenty of good reads on who was pushing Haggle vs R & J.

[Venus and Mars]

You're voting for me rn actually IIRC.

Am I still?? Sorry!

VOTE: Titus

That post proves she didn’t know Drew’s alignment.

[Venus and Mars]

Frost's D1 stuff with Haggle is concerning.

Finally a post that is making sense to me because he was the one who tried to stop AF wagon but then we have Dave knife clear, so how does town!Dave get knifeclear on scum!Haggle unless they are scum doc?

But why would scum even have a doctor with only a night 3, 5, 7 vig? Aaron was tired and didn't count votes...like everyone else.

Bambi said scum can be poisoner.

[chkflip]

Holy fuck are you scrolling past my explanation and asking me the same question on repeat on purpose, or...?

[chkflip]

First paragraph, top of the page. Hard to miss.

[BrightEyedFish]

Fish, that's fair; however, why Joan over Haggle?

Maybe because later in AFs ISO Joan stood out more. Haggle was more prominent in the early parts of the ISO. I wouldn't be surpised if both are AFs named partners.

HURT: Joan, Haggle, 50JP

[Bambi Jay]

I was opposed, and even in that post he's the shot I'm only okay with, not encouraging.

Tis just me accepting he's a prime candidate.

[Venus and Mars]

I also feel like a lot of you are putting stock into meta based on a single game a bit too much tbf. I'm not saying meta is bad, but basing a read from meta of a single game isn't enough. If that were the case I'd be questioning why Bambi is different and Nancy is similar to the single game I've finished with both separately.

But you know I’m pretty much IC now, however I don’t think I’m playing remotely similarly to our last game. I would say how but since it was a mime game, it wouldn’t be terribly useful.

[chkflip]

Do I, though?

[Venus and Mars]

If he doesn't use a knife... Hidden Poisoner? Poison in a Shakespeare play go hand in hand.

This is a semi-serious theory by the way. Does a Poisoner show up to a gunsmith-Knifesmith?

No, I doubt it. They definitely didn’t in Forgotten Hourglass.