Everything Is Still A Lie v2 [Canceled]

[ObviousScum]

Counterpoint 2: THE GAME JUST STARTED. JOKE CLAIMS ARE TO BE EXPECTED. Unless the claim is miller. Or that other claim as soon as possible role that I can't remember off the top of my head.

he claimed the poetry wincon after he was trialed

[ObviousScum]

We're also on page 12, so when exactly does the "it just started nothing matters" phase end guys?

[Rautherdir]

oh i misread lol
thought it said we could
-mm

Ah, yeah. That would have been broken. Then again I guess there isn't anything stopping someone from forging a role pm.

p-edit
I'm going to guess after the trial ends.

[PeaHen]

i dont know how this trial started but it is waaaay to fuckin early

-mm

Agreed. Do we know who started the Trial?

- Turkey

i dont think so
which makes it all the more scummier on who did

-mm

Agreed.

- Turkey

[TrueSoulHustler]

We're also on page 12, so when exactly does the "it just started nothing matters" phase end guys?

literally only rauther said this im pretty sure
not giving you towncred for that
-mm

[Rautherdir]

Counterpoint 2: THE GAME JUST STARTED. JOKE CLAIMS ARE TO BE EXPECTED. Unless the claim is miller. Or that other claim as soon as possible role that I can't remember off the top of my head.

he claimed the poetry wincon after he was trialed

Okay cool.
Counterpoint 3: He claimed the joke-wincon after he was trialed.

[Minstrel]

He also hasn't claimed any significant town powers. If the slot is just a VT, then mislynching a VT and going into night before the town power structure is revealed with bad pushes can be very pro-town. Conversely, he's already retracted a joke wincon which both heads wrote a poem to sell so I don't really see this slot as town tbh

Our account was made before we got our role PM, Obum. Our theme is writing poems... come on, I was just messing around. Also, we're not VT.

-Hectic

[Minstrel]

Thank you, Rau. I've missed you dearly, friend.

-Hectic

[a Gun and a Rose]

Eh, considering the VT is basically an IC in this game, I don't think we should be claiming "not VT" either

-gun

[PeaHen]

I wonder if this game could be a blue print for this current game. That would be mega interesting.

- Turkey

[ObviousScum]

Counterpoint 3: He claimed the joke-wincon after he was trialed.

sure

but why then are you operating under the assumption that, if he was trialed simply because korina (cult) wanted him to be trialed, that he is therefore town?

[PeaHen]

Eh, considering the VT is basically an IC in this game, I don't think we should be claiming "not VT" either

-gun

Which head is which for this hydra? I need some Menalque in my life.

- Turkey

[a Gun and a Rose]

I fucked up when signing earlier (and we said it in the signup thread). There is currently no Menalque in your life.

-gun

[ObviousScum]

Our account was made before we got our role PM, Obum. Our theme is writing poems... come on, I was just messing around.

sure but maybe bear in mind that people will pay attention to the first claim you make after you're randomly trialed? we have to make some sort of judgment about your alignment and so far you've gone out of your way to make that harder

[ObviousScum]

I wonder if this game could be a blue print for this current game. That would be mega interesting.

- Turkey

I think we should use this game as a blueprint for this game

[PeaHen]

I fucked up when signing earlier (and we said it in the signup thread). There is currently no Menalque in your life.

-gun

I cannot tell if I am surprised or not by the fact that Menalque is a rose.

- Turkey

[TrueSoulHustler]

Our account was made before we got our role PM, Obum. Our theme is writing poems... come on, I was just messing around.

sure but maybe bear in mind that people will pay attention to the first claim you make after you're randomly trialed? we have to make some sort of judgment about your alignment and so far you've gone out of your way to make that harder

didnt they literally also claim nightvig
-mm

[ObviousScum]

didnt they literally also claim nightvig

no they said they "might" have a dayvig

[TrueSoulHustler]

nvm they mentioned a day vig in a poem but it wasnt a claim
they were talking about an unknown party

-mm

[PeaHen]

Mod, will votes be counted during the Trial? Like votes for other players not being trialed?

[Rautherdir]

Counterpoint 3: He claimed the joke-wincon after he was trialed.

sure

but why then are you operating under the assumption that, if he was trialed simply because korina (cult) wanted him to be trialed, that he is therefore town?

From what I can tell, the trial required a vote to start. Meaning more then one player voted to trial Minstrel. At this point in the game I'm fairly certain there aren't any town reasons to do a trial on a player.

My point is more that we shouldn't end the day this early. If we could abstain I'd go for that but the risk of scum forcing our lynch is too high. I'm not saying Minstrel is town. I'm just saying we can't risk ending the day this early and going into day 2 when not everyone has even posted (I think. I might be wrong there.)

[ObviousScum]

Why do you believe long day 1s are pro-town?

[Minstrel]

Our account was made before we got our role PM, Obum. Our theme is writing poems... come on, I was just messing around.

sure but maybe bear in mind that people will pay attention to the first claim you make after you're randomly trialed? we have to make some sort of judgment about your alignment and so far you've gone out of your way to make that harder

I sometimes fakeclaim stupid things as jokes, but yeah, not the right time after we were trialled.

-Hectic

[PeaHen]

Sing me a ballad, Minstrel.

- Turkey

[Rautherdir]

Also, nice to play another game with you Hectic. Guess I'm keeping you from getting lynched yet again. And if you're a Jester this game maybe just tell us, so we can get that over with?

p-edit
I believe ending the day while we're still in RVS is anti-town.