Everything Is Still A Lie v2 [Canceled]

[polypies73]

Spoiler: Important Stuff

I lied!

I just noticed people were posting their favourite music,
so I wanted to share some too

good song so i am gonna talk to you tmr morning

[Rautherdir]

The jury consisting of the dead cult bastard moderator/player made a bad decision?

And probably four other players. Including the dead cult moderator, who said they didn't vote for Minstrel.

[TrueSoulHustler]

-mm

i keep forgetting to tag myself

[Korina]

No, I voted for Minstrel. Like I said, I thought it'd be funny if we started a trial this early into the day.

[TrueSoulHustler]

Trying to drag the gamestate into an abstract discussion of day 1 pacing policy I take as a scumclaim

Too easy to make provocative points about philosophy that have no actual bearing to the alignment of the player under consideration or anyone else

It shouldn't be a discussion. That should be basic knowledge.

++++++++++

-mm

[Rautherdir]

I thought you said...
Actually I'm not sure why I thought you would be consistent.

[TrueSoulHustler]

No, I voted for Minstrel. Like I said, I thought it'd be funny if we started a trial this early into the day.

I thought you said...
Actually I'm not sure why I thought you would be consistent.

the text wasnt blue so we dont have a single clue if theyre being honest

-mm

[Korina]

I never said I wasn't a Jurist. I acted like I wasn't one, but I never said I wasn't one. I also said that I was a major reason why Minstrel is being trialed today.

[Korina]

The blue text is only used when I'm acting as the game's moderator.

[ObviousScum]

Saying you should give the person on trial a trial is "suicidal"?

If you act as though the trial itself is moot then the votes tell us nothing and we waste an opportunity to evaluate votes cast in stealth

[TrueSoulHustler]

The blue text is only used when I'm acting as the game's moderator.

still we shouldnt take literally anything you say at face value
u flipped cult afterall

[ObviousScum]

The blue text is only used when I'm acting as the game's moderator.

Are you obligated to tell the truth when acting as the game moderator?

[TrueSoulHustler]

Saying you should give the person on trial a trial is "suicidal"?

If you act as though the trial itself is moot then the votes tell us nothing and we waste an opportunity to evaluate votes cast in stealth

dont put words in my mouth

ending day at lightspeed is the suicidal thing here
-mm

[ObviousScum]

The jury consisting of the dead cult bastard moderator/player made a bad decision?

And probably four other players. Including the dead cult moderator, who said they didn't vote for Minstrel.

so like half the game is in the jury then?

[ObviousScum]

Saying you should give the person on trial a trial is "suicidal"?

If you act as though the trial itself is moot then the votes tell us nothing and we waste an opportunity to evaluate votes cast in stealth

dont put words in my mouth

ending day at lightspeed is the suicidal thing here
-mm

Okay and when did I say to end the day at lightspeed? While we're busy putting words into people's mouths

[TrueSoulHustler]

Saying you should give the person on trial a trial is "suicidal"?

If you act as though the trial itself is moot then the votes tell us nothing and we waste an opportunity to evaluate votes cast in stealth

dont put words in my mouth

ending day at lightspeed is the suicidal thing here
-mm

Okay and when did I say to end the day at lightspeed? While we're busy putting words into people's mouths

arent you one of the ones that wanted a guilty vote?
if not this arguments been a mess from the get go

-mm

[Rautherdir]

Saying you should give the person on trial a trial is "suicidal"?

If you act as though the trial itself is moot then the votes tell us nothing and we waste an opportunity to evaluate votes cast in stealth

I mean. The trial is moot. Town isn't going to come to a decision that Minstrel is scum. Not this early in the game. But if we don't make it obvious then we just give scum the chance to possibly guarantee a kill on town. Which should be avoided if possible.

p-edit
By saying to give Minstrel an actual trial. Allowing for the chance that Minstrel is found guilty means allowing the day to end at lightspeed.

[Korina]

The blue text is only used when I'm acting as the game's moderator.

Are you obligated to tell the truth when acting as the game moderator?

This is a question I'm not sure how to answer, so... have a doggo.

Spoiler:

My best answer would be for the most part. I'm trying to maintain a basic trust-integrity as the game moderator, so you know that the core stuff of the game, (phases, vote counts, flips, etc.), are truthful or what the player was given. Outside of those basic, core-moderator things, no. I'm not obligated to tell the truth.

[Rautherdir]

The jury consisting of the dead cult bastard moderator/player made a bad decision?

And probably four other players. Including the dead cult moderator, who said they didn't vote for Minstrel.

so like half the game is in the jury then?

5 / 23 = 21.7%

Which is a lot less then half. (23 because I'm counting both Korina and chkflip as players. Although I'm not sure if chkflip is a player, so it might just be 22)

[Korina]

The blue text is only used when I'm acting as the game's moderator.

still we shouldnt take literally anything you say at face value
u flipped cult afterall

I mean, also, my plan for this game is to mostly shitpost and openwolf considering I'm flipped cult and the mod so...

[ObviousScum]

I've been saying people should vote guilty if they think the slot is guilty

And that if they aren't sure they should get content from the slot that will make it readable

I think I said to vote guilty immediately after he retracted the "jokeclaim" because that backpedal was bad after they just did two posts to sell it but tbh I didn't realize simple majority would end day, I thought we were locked into 36 hours for some reason. I don't really care if people guilty him or not I just think arguing he should be inno'd off policy is dumb af

You wanna argue the philosophy of it, whatever, but I think acting like a certain amount of time must pass before the day can end makes every vote uninformative until that amount of time has passed

[Korina]

The jury consisting of the dead cult bastard moderator/player made a bad decision?

And probably four other players. Including the dead cult moderator, who said they didn't vote for Minstrel.

so like half the game is in the jury then?

Hot take: What if you're all Jurists, and you just don't know it?

[ObviousScum]

If you wanna argue we should speed hammer an inno to spite korina, sure, but at that point there's no way to tell serious evaluation from virtue signalling

[TrueSoulHustler]

I've been saying people should vote guilty if they think the slot is guilty

And that if they aren't sure they should get content from the slot that will make it readable

I think I said to vote guilty immediately after he retracted the "jokeclaim" because that backpedal was bad after they just did two posts to sell it but tbh I didn't realize simple majority would end day, I thought we were locked into 36 hours for some reason. I don't really care if people guilty him or not I just think arguing he should be inno'd off policy is dumb af

You wanna argue the philosophy of it, whatever, but I think acting like a certain amount of time must pass before the day can end makes every vote uninformative until that amount of time has passed

it was an obvious joooooooooke
ur such a squareeeeeee

youd have my vote if it werent for this bloody trial
-mm

[Korina]

Honestly, I'm enjoying not having to game-mod, so please don't.