BooneyToonz XIII: To Boon or Not To Boon - [END]

[Venus and Mars]

I’m thinking if chk was on us, we could avoid scum hitting us with a loyal modiifier and making our role useless, because scum hitting us with a loyal would suck most of all.

I’m okay with dying today or tonight or whatever but not with getting loyal.

[chkflip]

And you're gassing "when it's optimal play" right?

[davesaz]

Hmm, does loyal prevent the action entirely or just the target's death? That's exploitable btw.

[Venus and Mars]

Hmm, does loyal prevent the action entirely or just the target's death? That's exploitable btw.

If renegade gave me a loyal, it would obviously mean I could only bomb town, so there would be 2 guaranteed town deaths if it worked but if they didn’t die, I probably still would and they’d of course be confiscum in that case.

[chkflip]

I'm still kind of struggling to understand why you don't bomb today tbh? If you wait for an even number, you blow and two people die. Then we're still at an even number. So...?

[Venus and Mars]

And you're gassing "when it's optimal play" right?

I’m okay bombing whenever. Rn, I can still hit scum, same if I’m rolestopped. But even if Adorable is very likely scum, who are the other 3? Who are we wrongly tr?

[Venus and Mars]

I'm still kind of struggling to understand why you don't bomb today tbh? If you wait for an even number, you blow and two people die. Then we're still at an even number. So...?

So, I can do that too. Shiro was saying he’s okay with us being NK’d but then he didn’t take into account renegade, so I think we either bomb today or we get RS’d and we holster but I’m fine bombing today.

If I do, it’s probably Adorable then.

[Venus and Mars]

I'm still kind of struggling to understand why you don't bomb today tbh? If you wait for an even number, you blow and two people die. Then we're still at an even number. So...?

Oh so you think it’s optimal for us to bomb today? Okay, some people earlier were saying I was being anti-town, so I wanted to rethink it.

[Venus and Mars]

Well, we have 11 1/2 days so probably best I do it either closer to EoD or should I just get it over with asap?

[chkflip]

I might just have an anti-town mentality? Idk. I just don't get how it helps.

[chkflip]

Waiting is definitely for the best. I agree with that.

[Venus and Mars]

So: non-targets (in no particular order)

Titus,
Fonz
BEF
RCE
chk
Dave
Haggle
Chemist
Creature
Joan
Amrun

[BrightEyedFish]

And to clarify, I only send dead fish, period. Not laundry. I never targeted Nancy for any reason.

So a regular Fruit (Fish) Vendor? For a Rolecop and a Tracker to see I guess that works out, and also me.

I got a PM after daystart that confirms one of these roles or a similar one. I'm guessing mod just forgot to send it with the daystart pm.

I did confirm being tracked. But I got the PM after daystart and after my chara claim.

[BrightEyedFish]

I was mistaken about there being a 2nd laundry claim.

Modifier claims:
N1: Titus (desperate), BEF (Ascetic)
N2: Me (didn't say and outing it isn't helpful to town), can't remember (can't remember)

It would be much harder to find the 2nd modifier claim for N2, as it's not easily ctrl-f. If anyone knows please post.

Remember we have to assume renegade is motivated in order for there to be two modifiers given. This could mean that one modifier is fake.

I never claimed or received a modifier.

[Venus and Mars]

If scum makes us loyal I see that as an absolute win.

Nothing changes if we target town and we become a day cop on scum instead of dying.

Unless I am misunderstanding something, there is no downside.

[Venus and Mars]

If scum makes us loyal I see that as an absolute win.

Nothing changes if we target town and we become a day cop on scum instead of dying.

Unless I am misunderstanding something, there is no downside.

~Venus

[Adorable]

Boonskie's last post was on Jan 26 and he mentioned he won't be available tomorrow and I recommend you wait till he comes back for me to say anything else.

[RCEnigma]

If scum makes us loyal I see that as an absolute win.

Nothing changes if we target town and we become a day cop on scum instead of dying.

Unless I am misunderstanding something, there is no downside.

Which is great but I dunno why scum would do that. Or give you that power.

[Venus and Mars]

If scum makes us loyal I see that as an absolute win.

Nothing changes if we target town and we become a day cop on scum instead of dying.

Unless I am misunderstanding something, there is no downside.

Which is great but I dunno why scum would do that. Or give you that power.

Nancy was scared of it, no idea why.

[chkflip]

Loyal would mean you only blow up town.

[RCEnigma]

I get what they're saying. Loyal doesn't make the role better it just changes how it functions.

[RCEnigma]

So loyal would make it so no action occurs if their target is scum. Like a day use alignment check and a town target just follows the standard roles function.

[Venus and Mars]

So loyal would make it so no action occurs if their target is scum. Like a day use alignment check and a town target just follows the standard roles function.

Which I find strictly better, we live on scum and function normally on town

~Venus

[RCEnigma]

If you target town it doesn't change anything. It also requires scum deciding to give you the modifier so it's kind of a moot point.

[Venus and Mars]

8 am discussing it because Nancy was afraid of it and wanted us rolestopped. 8 am against that because scum killing us gives us ton of info since they know we can kill at day.

~Venus