This is pretty incorrectLight wrote:If their play seems scummy, they are probably scum.
This is how I felt about the post. Something about Sun's rant really set an alarm bell in my mind especiallly seeing that post. However FL has really done some good things at the moment in his analysis that out weighs a newbie temper tantum.Lowell wrote:I don't think he's 100% scum. I think what farside pointed out is compelling (it wouldn't be the first time an angry noob tried to bring a teammate down with him), and that FL is therefore the best option.
Mmmm. Didnt I say this before?farside22 wrote:This is how I felt about the post. Something about Sun's rant really set an alarm bell in my mind especiallly seeing that post. However FL has really done some good things at the moment in his analysis that out weighs a newbie temper tantum.Lowell wrote:I don't think he's 100% scum. I think what farside pointed out is compelling (it wouldn't be the first time an angry noob tried to bring a teammate down with him), and that FL is therefore the best option.
It's why I changed my vote back to lowell. I really don't see a Light case anymore however. I think that is a dead end in my view.populartajo wrote:Mmmm. Didnt I say this before?farside22 wrote:This is how I felt about the post. Something about Sun's rant really set an alarm bell in my mind especiallly seeing that post. However FL has really done some good things at the moment in his analysis that out weighs a newbie temper tantum.Lowell wrote:I don't think he's 100% scum. I think what farside pointed out is compelling (it wouldn't be the first time an angry noob tried to bring a teammate down with him), and that FL is therefore the best option.
Popular, I am saying that if worse comes to worse, town should probably agree on voting whoever the best case is against. Obviously, I think Lowell is a better lynch, but with the timing, FL didn't seem like a really bad of a choice. Although, Lowell is my preference, I can see the FL lynch logic too.populartajo wrote:Rereading and to be honest, Im still not seeing what Farside is seeing. For the moment I dont support a FL lynch.
Light, whats the logic behind a FL lynch in a worse comes to worse?
Lowell suggesting that we lynch Fl instead of him seems a desesperate maneuver. Why do you think FL is 100% scum?
I dont think were screwed gimbo, stop bitching.Gimbo wrote:danggggg we're totally screwed....let's kill Lowell today
1: No, you defended sun, and then hammered/extra hammered(?). So, yeah, fall through.Lowell wrote:If I agreed with the thoughts of others I wouldn't be in this mess.
The entirety of the case on me comes down to:
1)I hammered/didn't hammer/meant to hammer/should have hammered.I've commented on this already. I wasn't sold on his scumness (only his newbishness), but "giving up" posts are to me a sign of scumness. Sun Tzu tried to hammer himself, so I followed with an extra swing just in case someone else's vote didn't count/was illegal/etc.
2)I agree with farside. She's right on this. The line to FL about him being "busted, IMO" makes no sense whatsoever UNLESS he's talking to a fellow scum, angry that he was bussed on D1. Try to make that sentence make sense with Sun as scum and FL as town..... I dare you.
3)Light-kun can't be bothered to think. Not my problem. I've been clear about why FL deserves to die, and why we deserve for you think harder than just jumping on the nearest bandwagon.
I see the logic of a FL lynch. I really do, but you have seemed kind of scummy. Plus, FL has been very pro town, and I can see lynching him after analyzing the early days again with more public knowledge. (ie, dead confirmed townie/mafia.) Yes, in light that Sun is mafia, FL can seem suspicious. But, I would have been more suspicious if Sun was town. Mostly because of all the happy on my vote comments by FL. So, I am going to have to wait and see his play and how players flip before I can really figure out what side he's on. (And please don't use some lame argument like: vote him now and find out.) 